In April 2021, the European Super League (ESL), a breakaway competition featuring the “big six” Premier League clubs as well as three teams from each of Italy and Spain, was announced. The proposal sent shockwaves through European football and drew condemnation from the British Prime Minister and the French president. It was also met by near-universal fan outrage and, a matter of days after the proposal was announced, all six Premier League clubs had withdrawn from the competition.

However, what began as routine fan protests evolved into a broader conversation about governance, accountability and the legal structures that shape the game. The ESL’s collapse did more than simply halt an unpopular competition model; it crystallised the influence that supporters can exert when their interests are threatened and prompted policymakers, regulators and clubs to rethink how fans’ voices are embedded within the sport’s decision-making frameworks.

Fan-led review

Almost immediately, the UK government announced a “fan-led review” of football governance which, when published in November 2021, vowed to “set a clear course for a stronger national game with the interest of fans at its heart”. Most notably, it recommended that an independent regulator, established by an Act of Parliament, was put in place. This, coupled with a strengthened owners’ and directors’ test and fans obtaining greater say in the management of clubs and key heritage such as team names, badges and stadia, was accepted by the government when it published The 2023 Football Governance White Paper. 2024 saw a new government elected in the UK but the Labour government continued with the legislation and passed the proposed reforms and The Football Governance Act 2025 became law (and our 2025 report discusses this legislation in detail).1

Outside of this statutory framework, the Premier League introduced its Fan Engagement Standard in 2023, which was designed to reinforce clubs’ relationships with their supporters. This set certain additional requirements to embed fan engagement across all clubs, such as establishing fan advisory boards, publishing an annual fan engagement plan and creating consultation frameworks for key decisions. These amendments certainly represent a cultural shift: fan involvement within football has transformed from reactive protest to proactive power in recent years, as fan involvement has been codified in both statute and league rules.

Have reforms gone far enough?

Some may argue that the reforms have not gone far enough. Fans still have no real control over key ownership decisions beyond consultation – or indeed who owns their clubs – and the power they receive is still largely dependent on clubs’ willingness to engage. Question marks also remain over the direct enforcement powers that fans possess under both the Football Governance Act 2025 and the Fan Engagement Standards; the Football Governance Act 2025, for instance, is primarily enforced by the IFR and the Fan Engagement Standards by the Premier League.

True fan ownership models, such as AFC Wimbledon and Exeter City, remain elusive and it can be argued that, even after the reforms, fans are still largely reacting to crises rather than having more meaningful powers (which is reminiscent of the landscape prior to these reforms). Earlier this year, for instance, Tottenham Hotspur and Manchester United fans protested against their clubs’ owners and board as results turned. In each case, the club removed the first team manager but, even after this, as Tottenham Hotspur Supporters' Trust accused the club of selectively editing the written version of what was said at a fans’ meeting and Jim Ratcliffe was heavily criticised by Manchester United supporters for his comments on immigration in the UK, there was no credible threat to their positions as owners.

Elsewhere in the Premier League, Chelsea, West Ham and Wolves fans have all protested against their owners but the issue is perhaps best exemplified by Sheffield Wednesday, whose relegation from the Championship in February was the earliest in the history of the EFL. Protests against the club’s former owner, Chansiri, increased during the 2024-2025 season and, after a chaotic summer where a large number of the senior squad were sold or released, the club entered administration in October 2025. After a 12-point deduction for entering administration, the club were then deducted a further six points in December 2025 for EFL regulation breaches as Chansiri was banned from owning or directing an EFL football club for three years. Whilst fan protests against Chansiri were common, and EFL action may act as a deterrent to other owners, Chansiri’s refusal to sell the club ultimately resulted in points deductions and a relegation to the third tier, which somewhat evidence the lack of true, meaningful power that fans possess.

The IFR will of course also hope that its new owners’ and directors’ test will block problematic individuals from buying and running football clubs but whether this has increased fan power specifically is debatable. In previous reports, we have discussed the unique nature of football club ownership in comparison with other assets,2 in which owners are subject to a certain level of public scrutiny which does fetter their power somewhat in practice. This scrutiny has continued over the last few years and, short of a compulsory sale mechanism (which could be hugely damaging to investor confidence in English football), it is difficult to see what additional checks and balances the IFR and Premier League could practically implement on incumbent owners.

Fan power within English football has undoubtedly increased over the past five years – mandatory engagement standards and entrenched statutory obligations on clubs marks a fundamental and systemic change in approach. However, as demonstrated, there are still key limitations. Crucially, fans’ power rarely extends beyond consultation rights and, to a certain extent, the reforms rely on procedural compliance by clubs. Over the coming years, it will be interesting to see how the IFR exercises its power and whether in reality fan power increases beyond the extent explicitly stated in the reforms.

Footnotes

  1. 1

    Norton Rose Fulbright, Keeping possession: Ownership trends in English Premier League football (2025).

  2. 2

    Norton Rose Fulbright, Keeping possession: Ownership trends in English Premier League football (2022); Norton Rose Fulbright, Keeping possession: Ownership trends in English Premier League football (2023).

card-grid-item, aem-sourced
Keeping possession
Ownership trends in English Premier League football
/content/nrf-eds/en-gb/insights/topics/keeping-possession

Contact