On 7 June 2022, the Supreme Court of Appeal handed down unanimous judgment in an appeal against a decision of the High Court in Commissioner, South African Revenue Service & others v Dragon Freight & others. The SCA, in upholding the appeal, found that a decision taken by SARS to detain and thereafter seize clothing imported from China was lawful and reasonable for the purposes of the Promotion of Administrative Justice Act, 2000.
The importers of the clothing were alleged by SARS to have mis-declared the true value of 19 containers of clothing with the purpose of paying significantly less customs and excise duty to the State. The effect of the mis-declaration and underpayment of duties was to give the importers a huge competitive advantage over the local clothing industry.
Norton Rose Fulbright South Africa (NRFSA) represented two of the country’s largest clothing manufacturer associations, namely the South African Apparel Association (SAAA) and the Apparel and Textile Association of South Africa (ATASA) in placing before the court evidence that the prices claimed by the importers were inconceivable and, at times, up to 1000% lower than prices that could be obtained in the open market. SAAA and ATASA also stressed the tremendous impact that such practices would have on the local manufacturing and retail industries.
In its judgment, the SCA confirmed that the methodology and decision making by SARS (which in turn relied upon the evidence provided by SAAA and ATASA) was sound; that the explanations provided by the importers were not dependable; and that there was accordingly no basis to interfere in SARS’ decision to seize and forfeit ownership of the goods to the State.
Adv Emma Webber of the Johannesburg Bar, instructed by Jason Whyte, Laura Macfarlane and Frances Barker of NRFSA argued the matter on behalf of SAAA and ATASA.