Historically, the UK has operated a residence-based tax system for taxing companies. Under this system, the profits of a UK company’s foreign permanent establishment (PE) have been included in the calculation of its worldwide profits and been subject to UK Corporation Tax (CT) with credit for any foreign tax paid. Since 2011, a company has been able to elect to exempt those foreign PE profits and losses from UK corporation tax (the PE Rules).
On 21 May 2026, the UK Government announced its intentions to make the elective exemption regime mandatory, such that the PE Rules would apply automatically to all companies with foreign PEs (the New PE Rules). Draft legislation was published on 13 July 2026, with a consultation running until 13 September 2026. The draft legislation remains unamended following the most recent Autumn Budget; any post-consultation changes are expected to occur once the Finance Bill is published shortly.
The New PE Rules are intended to take effect for accounting periods starting 1 January 2027, subject to certain anti-avoidance provisions which took effect from the date of the draft legislation’s publication. Although the Government had initially announced that the New PE Rules would apply to oil and gas companies from as early as 1 September 2026, no accelerated timeline was included in the draft legislation. We covered the basic intention behind the New PE Rules in our Newsletter in June 2026 (Mandatory foreign PE exemption: What UK-resident multinationals need to know | United Kingdom | Global law firm | Norton Rose Fulbright). This update highlights some additional points that have arisen as a result of the publication of draft legislation, including a summary of the anti-avoidance rules, points around branch allocation and transfer pricing and the interaction with Pillar Two.
Knowledgeable action may be classed as avoidance
The New PE Rules are intended address a perceived “one-way” impact on UK taxation under the previously existing branch rules. HMRC were concerned that, where an overseas activity was profitable, its profits would be included in a company’s UK CT calculations, but the UK corporation tax due would be reduced as a result of credit for the foreign taxes paid in the PE jurisdiction; whereas if the venture were loss-making, the UK would give relief for the losses against other profits of the company. This broader intention is important to bear in mind when examining the New PE Rules’ anti-avoidance tests.
The New PE Rules’ anti-forestalling provisions are intended to engage on satisfaction of three tests – timing, purpose, and abuse. While anti-abuse provisions are nothing new, the drafting of these tests represents an expansive approach by the legislator.
- Condition A, the timing test, requires that the arrangements are entered into on or after 13 July 2026. This is the date on which the draft legislation was first published, meaning that this test would be met near-automatically by any mitigating action an organisation may choose to take.
- Condition B, the purpose test, sets out that the arrangement must have as its main purpose, or one of its main purposes, to obtain a tax advantage (within the meaning set out at section 1139 of CTA 2010). For periods prior to commencement of the New PE Rules, this is intended to apply where the arrangement involves bringing forward or anticipating income, expenditure, profits or loss which would otherwise be in a post-commencement accounting period. The drafting of this test is, arguably, broad enough to include actions by a company which chooses to reorganise its affairs in light of the New PE Rules – for example, by bringing forward losses that might otherwise arise in 2027 so that the losses arise in 2026, when they might be able to be used in the UK under the existing PE Rules.
- Condition C, the abuse test, then looks at whether it is reasonable to regard the arrangements as circumventing the intended commencement or operation of, or otherwise exploiting shortcomings in, the New PE Rules. Once again, the drafting of the provision is open to quite broad interpretation. The test requires that all the relevant circumstances are to be taken into account, and that includes – but is not limited to – assessing whether the arrangement includes steps are contrived or abnormal, or lack a genuine commercial purpose. While in line with the guiding legislative principle that genuine commercial actions should not be viewed as abusive, the drafting does leave open the possibility of challenge where parties are taking those commercial decisions because they are aware of the impact of the rules commencing next year.
Taken together, the potential wide scope of these tests means that businesses should be careful when considering what steps may be available to mitigate the tax impact of the New PE Rules. Whilst it must be anticipated by HMRC that the New PE Rules might lead to behavioural change (such as incorporation of existing branches), businesses should be careful not to fall into the anti-avoidance rules, and should keep in mind the relatively broad ambit of these steps when deciding which mitigatory actions to take over the next few months.
Increased importance of transfer pricing and branch allocation rules
Historically, where the PE profits were chargeable to corporation tax in the UK, even though they may have been sheltered by foreign tax credits, there was little benefit to HMRC in expending resources to examine intra-UK transfer pricing between a UK company and the non-UK branch of another group company or to challenge the allocation of profits to a non-UK PE. In either case, the result would be largely neutral from a UK corporation tax perspective because the profits of the non-UK PE would be included in the corporation tax computations in any event.
The change to the New PE Rules is likely to provide an incentive for HMRC to revisit transfer pricing arrangements, including those already in place, and to seek to adjust transactions between the UK company’s head office or other UK resident members of the group and its overseas PE.
A common example is where there are service arrangements in place between the head office and the branch; HMRC may seek to increase the taxable income in the UK resident company by arguing that the management services allocated by the head office to the branch are insufficient to reflect the true value created by its key personnel. Companies should consider a review of any existing transfer pricing or profit allocation arrangements, and the implementation of checks to ensure any future ones are sufficiently robust. By ensuring that it has the appropriate documentation and analysis available to support any positions taken, a company will both be able to reduce its risk of HMRC challenge, and streamline its administrative burdens in responding to HMRC enquiries down the line. Whilst the local taxation of the branch would typically infer that these arrangements have already been looked at by the tax authorities in the PE jurisdiction, this does not mean that HMRC will agree with this, potentially leading to disagreements and the need to resort to time consuming Treaty dispute mechanisms.
Interaction with Pillar Two
In principle, the New PE Rules are expected to remove some of the complexities in applying the Pillar Two rules to the operations of entities with overseas PEs. The New PE Rules will require companies to isolate the profits attributable to the overseas PE which should, in most cases, be equivalent to the profits that should be attributable to that jurisdiction (and not the UK) for the purposes of Pillar Two.
The definition of a PE under the New PE Rules has also been amended in line with the approach taken by the government’s updates to the UK’s Pillar Two rules earlier this year, which aligned the UK’s definition with that of the OECD. However, the New PE Rules only incorporate the first two limbs of the definition found within the UK’s Pillar Two legislation. They do not import the third, which is intended to define a PE where a country has no double tax treaty with the UK but still calculates profits on the PE under its domestic rules. This raises the possibility that the measure of covered tax under the Pillar Two rules is slightly different to the amount that is exempted from UK tax under the New PE Rules. This is a matter that invites closer scrutiny and attention from international groups, and is a question that will depend on the particular facts of any particular transaction. Overall, companies would be well-served to keep their eyes on any areas of uncertainty – especially in the transitional period – where the interaction of the New PE Rules and the Pillar Two rules could produce some surprising results.