A comprehensive review of recent regulatory developments

Authors: Mark Highman, Stephan Ariyan, Sebastian Souchet, Gage Raju-Salicki

Introduction

Over the course of the last few months, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) has taken a number of significant actions that clarify the CFTC’s regulatory framework regarding both perpetual contracts and trading in derivatives markets on a 24/7 basis.

Perpetuals

The following are the principal regulatory developments regarding perpetual contracts:

  1. The CFTC issued an order permitting the listing as a futures contract of a perpetual contract that references the spot price of bitcoin by KalshiEX LLC (the Kalshi Perpetuals Order).
  2. The CFTC issued a policy statement on the listing of certain perpetual contracts on assets other than Bitcoin (the Perpetuals Policy Statement).1
  3. CFTC staff issued CFTC Letter 26-17 providing conditional no-action relief enabling a registered futures commission merchant (FCM) to provide customer access to foreign-listed perpetual futures products and post digital commodities and payment stablecoins to a non-US broker for this purpose.2
  4. The Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME) filed a suit against the CFTC challenging the legality of both the Perpetuals Policy Statement and the Kalshi Perpetuals Order, arguing that perpetuals are swaps, not futures.
  5. The CFTC issued a request for comment seeking public input on the potential listing of perpetual contracts that reference physically delivered or storable energy commodities (the Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC).3 The CFTC later extended the comment period on the Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC from July 27, 2026 to August 26, 2026, and expanded the request to seek additional comment on the NYMEX 10-Barrel WTI Crude Oil Futures contract that CME self-certified on July 8, 2026 and that the CFTC stayed on July 9, 2026.4

24/7 Trading

The following are the principal regulatory developments regarding 24/7 trading:

  1. CFTC staff issued CFTC Letter No. 26-16, setting forth expectations for designated contract markets (DCMs), swap execution facilities (SEFs), derivatives clearing organizations (DCOs), and FCMs seeking to extend trading and/or clearing operations to a 24/7 basis (the 24/7 Trading Advisory).5
  2. In the Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC, the CFTC requested public comment addressing the extension of standard futures contracts to 24/7 trading without any change to their fixed expiration, delivery or settlement terms.
  3. The CFTC issued an order instituting proceedings and stating the listing of the 10-Barrel WTI Crude Oil Futures contract self-certified by the New York Mercantile Exchange, Inc. (NYMEX) under CFTC Rule 40.2, on the basis that the contract, designed to trade on a continuous 24/7 basis, raises unresolved questions regarding compliance with the CEA and DCM Core Principles (the NYMEX Stay Order).6

This article provides a comprehensive review of these regulatory developments and addresses the practical implications of such developments for derivatives market participants.

Regulatory developments regarding perpetual contracts

Background

Non-US trading

Perpetual contracts have become a popular form of crypto derivative trading in global markets. However, due to regulatory uncertainty regarding the classification of such contracts in the United States, “the market for perpetual contracts has largely developed outside of the US, with the majority of trading occurring on offshore trading venues.”7

Perpetual contract funding rate mechanism

In contrast to traditional futures contracts, which are structured to primarily rely on a fixed expiration date to achieve economic alignment with the underlying asset’s spot price, perpetual contracts are derivatives contracts that “have no fixed expiration date, and which rely on a periodic funding rate mechanism…to maintain relative price parity with the underlying asset’s spot price.”8 The periodic funding rate mechanism provides a periodic payment between the long and short sides of the perpetuals contract, “the direction and magnitude of which is generally determined by the difference between the perpetual contract’s market price and the underlying asset’s spot price.”9 For example, traders taking long positions will make payments to traders taking short positions when the relevant perpetual contract trades above the spot price of the underlying asset, and traders taking short positions will make payments to traders taking long positions when the relevant perpetual contract trades below the spot price of the underlying asset.10 Such periodic payments are intended to economically incentivize market participants to “arbitrage away the price differential by opening positions on whichever side of the market is accruing the payments.”11

Prior initiatives

Prior to the issuance of the Perpetuals Policy Statement and related regulatory developments concerning perpetuals contracts, in April 2025, the CFTC issued a request for comment on perpetual derivatives which sought input on the risks of perpetual contracts and whether perpetual contracts should be classified as futures or swaps for purposes of the Commodity Exchange Act (CEA) and the CFTC Rules.12 Furthermore, in July 2025, the President’s Working Group on Digital Asset Markets issued a report recommending that the CFTC and the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) “permit eligible market participants to access derivatives, including perpetual contracts, through regulated intermediaries and that the agencies use existing exemptive and interpretative authorities to provide near-term clarity for innovative derivatives products.”13

The Kalshi Perpetuals Order: Perpetuals on bitcoin

In the Kalshi Perpetuals Order, the CFTC approved for listing as a futures contract on Kalshi a perpetual contract that references the spot price of bitcoin (the BTCPERP Contract).14 The BTCPERP Contract is a “cash-settled derivative contract that references the spot price, in US dollars, of one bitcoin, as measured by the CF Benchmarks Bitcoin Real Time Index…[which] provides a continuous measure of the US dollar price of bitcoin, derived from observable transactions on major crypto asset trading platforms.” 15 The CFTC approved the BTCPERP Contract pursuant to Kalshi’s CFTC Rule 40.3 voluntary submission for product approval.16 The Kalshi Perpetuals Order extends to both the BTCPERP Contract and “similarly structured perpetual contracts that reference the spot price of bitcoin or other digital commodities that have deep, active and continuous spot market trading.”17

Notably, the CFTC stated that its approval of the listing and clearing of the BTCPERP Contract as a futures contract was “informed by certain characteristics of the bitcoin spot market that allow [the periodic funding rate mechanism designed to maintain price convergence with the underlying bitcoin spot price] to function consistently with DCM Core Principle 3.”18 In particular, the CFTC highlighted that the bitcoin spot market is continuously traded 24/7 and that such trading is broadly distributed across various trading venues allowing for the reference price underlying the BTCPERP Contract “to be continuously observed while the contract is trading.”19 Furthermore, the CFTC emphasized that (i) trading in the bitcoin spot market is “deep and liquid, such that the contract reference price cannot be changed at a relatively low cost,” and (ii) 24/7 trading in the bitcoin spot market “enables arbitrageurs to trade in the spot market when they trade the BTCPERP Contract; otherwise, the price convergence incentive could not be acted upon in real time, and price dislocations could grow, triggering liquidations or leading to settlement at distorted levels before the spot market reopens.”20

The Perpetuals Policy Statement: Contracts on assets other than bitcoin

The Perpetuals Policy Statement articulates the CFTC’s view that perpetual contracts that reference underlying asset classes beyond those contemplated in the Kalshi Perpetuals Order should be submitted for CFTC review and approval pursuant to the voluntary product approval process under CFTC Rule 40.3.21 The CFTC expressed the view that “given the novel characteristics of perpetual contracts, including their lack of a traditional expiration date and the complex questions concerning, among others, market structure and customer protections, the [CFTC] believes that the public interest is best served by requiring perpetual contracts that reference assets that are not contemplated in the [Kalshi Perpetuals Order] to undergo [CFTC] review and approval pursuant to [CFTC Rule] 40.3.”22

According to the Perpetuals Policy Statement, perpetual contracts on agricultural products, precious metals, equity securities and narrow-based security indexes, among other assets classes, should be submitted for CFTC review and approval in accordance with the requirements of CFTC Rule 40.3.23 Notably, the CFTC expressly stated that perpetual contracts are likely particularly “ill-suited” for agricultural products based on the considerations identified in the Kalshi Perpetuals Order, “while perpetual contracts that reference equity securities on narrow-based security indexes, among others, would benefit from review by the [CFTC] and the [SEC].”24

Importantly, the CFTC stated in the Perpetuals Policy Statement that each asset class on which a perpetual contract is based will raise distinct considerations and “merit independent analysis and review based on their unique circumstances.”25 Indeed, the CFTC makes clear in the Perpetuals Policy Statement that “[e]ach contract submitted to the [CFTC] under [P]art 40 will continue to be evaluated on its own terms.”26

CFTC Letter 26-17: Coinbase FCM providing customer access to Non-US perpetuals

In response to a request from Coinbase Financial Markets, a CFTC-registered FCM (the Coinbase FCM), CFTC staff issued CFTC Letter 26-17 that (i) established an interpretive position confirming that perpetuals listed on Deribit FZE (Deribit Perpetuals), a Dubai foreign board of trade (FBOT) regulated by the Dubai Virtual Assets Regulatory Authority, qualify as “foreign futures” under CFTC Rule 30.1; and (ii) provided conditional no-action relief permitting the Coinbase FCM to post customer-owned digital commodities and payment stablecoins (Customer Digital Assets) to Coinbase Bermuda Limited, its Bermuda-based, affiliated foreign broker (the Non-US Coinbase Broker), to margin customers’ foreign futures and foreign options positions where the affiliated foreign broker has obtained a right of re-use over the Customer Digital Assets.27

Regulatory background

Under CFTC Rule 30.1, the term “foreign futures” is defined to mean any contract for the purchase or sale of any commodity for future delivery made, or to be made, on or subject to the rules of any FBOT.28

CEA Section 4(b)(2) authorizes the CFTC to adopt rules to safeguard customer funds received by an FCM to margin customer foreign futures and foreign option positions entered into on an FBOT.29 Pursuant to CEA Section 4(b)(2), the CFTC adopted CFTC Rule 30.7, which imposes requirements regarding an FCM’s treatment and holding of funds deposited by customers (30.7 Customers) as margin for foreign futures and foreign option transactions (30.7 Customer Funds).30 Among other things, CFTC Rule 30.7 requires that (i) an FCM maintain at all times a sufficient amount of funds in specially designated accounts to satisfy the account balances of all 30.7 Customers, (ii) 30.7 Customer Funds be held in clearly identifiable accounts at certain permitted categories of depository institutions (Permitted Depositories) and (iii) an FCM obtain an acknowledgement letter from each depository that it uses to hold 30.7 Customer Funds.31 In addition, CFTC Rule 30.7 requires an FCM holding 30.7 Customer Funds in accounts maintained outside of the United States (for example, with a foreign broker or Permitted Depository in a foreign jurisdiction) to deposit the 30.7 Customer Funds pursuant to the laws and regulations of the non-US jurisdiction that provide the “greatest degree of protection” to such funds and not waive (by contract or otherwise) any of the protections afforded customer funds under the laws of the non-US jurisdiction.32

CFTC staff interpretation on Deribit Perpetuals as foreign futures

CFTC Letter 26-17 confirmed that Deribit Perpetuals may be categorized as “foreign futures” as such term is defined in CFTC Rule 30.1. As described in CFTC Letter 26-17, “Deribit Perpetuals” are “perpetual-term derivative contracts that provide their holders with long or short, as applicable, economic exposure to the spot price of an underlying digital commodity through a ‘funding rate mechanism’” which involves reference to the spot price of the underlying digital commodity as measured by reference to a Deribit index on the digital commodity’s spot price.33

In determining that Deribit Perpetuals can be categorized as foreign futures, the CFTC staff considered Deribit Perpetuals as a similarly structured product as the BTCPERP Contract in the Kalshi Perpetuals Order, and noted that under the rules of the Dubai Virtual Assets Regulatory Authority, “perpetual contracts are classified as a subcategory of exchange-traded derivatives,” and that the Dubai Virtual Assets Regulatory Authority’s rules “do not characterize perpetuals as swaps or contain other provisions that would contradict a regulatory categorization of perpetuals as futures.”34

Consistent with the Kalshi Perpetuals Order, the CFTC staff’s interpretation in CFTC Letter 26-17 is “limited in scope to perpetual contracts that are structured similarly to the Deribit Perpetuals . . . and that are based on the spot price of digital commodities that have deep, active and continuous spot market trading.”35

No-action relief for customer digital assets posted under a right of re-use

CFTC Letter 26-17 provides no-action relief under CFTC Rule 30.7 to permit the Coinbase FCM to post Customer Digital Assets with the Non-US Coinbase Broker to margin customers’ foreign futures and foreign option positions on Deribit where the Non-US Coinbase Broker has obtained a “right of re-use” over the Customer Digital Assets.36 A “right of re-use” refers to a “customer granting a legal right of use of such Customer Digital Assets deposited with [the Coinbase FCM] as margin collateral for the customer’s foreign futures or foreign option positions pursuant to an agreement between the parties and subject to the right of re-use being authorized or required under the local regulatory regime of the relevant foreign broker, FBOT and/or foreign clearing organization.”37

The no-action relief granted under CFTC Letter 26-17 is subject to satisfaction of nine conditions:

Maintaining existing corporate structure

The Coinbase FCM, the Non-US Coinbase Broker and Deribit must remain wholly owned subsidiaries of Coinbase Global, Inc., a public reporting company registered with the SEC.

Acknowledgment letter

The Coinbase FCM must ensure that the Non-US Coinbase Broker and Deribit enter into an agreement consistent in substance with the “Acknowledgment Letter for CFTC Regulation 30.7 Customer Secured Account” set forth in Appendix E to Part 30 of the CFTC Rules, with conforming naming changes to reflect the relevant digital asset context. This agreement must be filed with the CFTC.

Financial disclosures to 30.7 customers

The Coinbase FCM must make Deribit’s annual audited financial statements and System and Organization Controls report available to relevant 30.7 Customers.

No criminal disqualification

Neither Deribit, the Non-US Coinbase Broker, nor any of their respective affiliates may be subject to a “criminal disqualification.”38

Risk and security controls

The Coinbase FCM must ensure that the Non-US Coinbase Broker and Deribit handle Customer Digital Assets in accordance with a program of risk analysis and oversight regarding their operations and systems that includes information security controls and is integrated at the consolidated entity level as part of an affiliated group that includes a US public reporting company.

Local authorization of right of re-use

The right of re-use must be authorized or required under the local regulatory regime applicable to the Non-US Coinbase Broker or Deribit, or under Deribit’s own rules.

Limited use of customer digital assets

The Non-US Coinbase Broker may use or re-use the Customer Digital Assets solely for the purpose of margining or securing 30.7 Customer obligations arising from such customers’ foreign futures and foreign options positions.

Enhanced customer disclosures

In addition to the standard disclosures required under CFTC Rules 1.55(b) and 30.6, the Coinbase FCM must provide 30.7 Customers with a disclosure statement that describes: (i) the transaction and 30.7 Customer Funds flow; (ii) the role of each Coinbase Global affiliate in the transaction chain; and (iii) Deribit’s default management framework.

Compliance with CFTC Letter 26-05

The Coinbase FCM must comply with all conditions set forth in CFTC Letter 26-05 regarding the qualifications that Customer Digital Assets must meet to be valued by the Coinbase FCM when (i) determining whether or to what extent a 30.7 Customer account is undermargined for purposes of CFTC Rule 1.17(c)(5)(viii) and (ii) performing segregation calculations pursuant to CFTC Rule 30.7(f)(2).

On June 18, 2026, the Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME) filed a suit against the CFTC in the US District Court for the District of Columbia challenging the legality of both the Perpetuals Policy Statement and the Kalshi Perpetuals Order.39

Substantive arguments: Perpetuals are swaps, not futures

The CME argues that perpetuals fall within the statutory definition of a “swap” under CEA Section 1a(47) because: (i) the funding payments of a perpetual contract rise and fall with the difference between the perpetual contract price and the price of the underlying asset; (ii) a perpetual contract transfers between the parties to the contract the financial risk associated with a future change in the value or level of the contract—meaning a perpetuals contract’s purpose is “speculation—in real or near-real time—on the changing spot price of the underlying”; and (iii) a perpetual contract “does not convey any interest in a commodity and lacks any expiration date so is not a ‘contract of sale of a commodity for future delivery.’”40

Prior CFTC enforcement treatment of perpetuals as swaps

The CME argues that the CFTC’s historical enforcement position treated perpetuals as swaps as the “CFTC has brought a series of enforcement actions against offshore entities offering trading in perpetuals based on the premise that perpetual contracts meet the definition of ‘swap’ in the CEA as amended.”41 The CME argues that the Kalshi Perpetuals Order and the Perpetuals Policy Statement are a “departure from the CFTC’s past consistent practice of classifying perpetuals as swaps across a series of enforcement actions.”42

Procedural challenges

The CME challenges the Kalshi Perpetuals Order and the Perpetuals Policy Statement on procedural grounds. The CME argues that while the “CFTC recognized that the Kalshi application raised ‘novel’ and ‘complex’ issues,” the CFTC “did not provide any opportunity for public comment” on the Kalshi Perpetuals Order as CFTC Chairman Selig, acting as the sole confirmed commissioner, approved the order just one day after Kalshi submitted its application, despite the CFTC’s regulations providing it with 45-90 days to review an application involving a product that raises “novel or complex issues.”43 Furthermore, the CME argues that despite receiving more than 150 comments in response to the CFTC’s April 2025 request for comment on perpetuals, the CFTC did not address any such comments.44

Thus, the CME argues that the CFTC’s actions in issuing the Kalshi Perpetuals Order and Perpetuals Policy Statement violate the CEA and are arbitrary and capricious under the Administrative Procedure Act for “failing to analyze the applicable statutory scheme, recognize the departure from the CFTC’s prior (and correct) position that perpetuals are swaps, or acknowledge the important real-world implications of this new sweeping approach.”45 The CME argues that the US District Court for the District of Columbia should “vacate these actions and issue a declaration that cryptocurrency perpetual contracts are swaps and not futures.”46

Perpetual energy contracts

In the Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC, the CFTC included nearly 40 questions seeking public comment on the potential listing of perpetual contracts that reference physically delivered or storable energy commodities.47 More specifically, the CFTC’s request for comment includes questions addressing the following areas:

Use cases, commercial demand and threshold considerations

The CFTC asks firms to identify any physically delivered or stored energy commodities for which a perpetual contract could serve identifiable hedging or risk management needs “not already met by existing standard futures, options or swaps.”48 The CFTC also asks whether specific data currently exists regarding the actual users of perpetual contracts in existing non-digital asset markets and whether there are energy commodities for which a perpetual contract would be particularly well-suited or particularly ill-suited.49

The CFTC asks whether trading volume in a perpetual contract could affect price formation in a related standard futures contract (including front-month price discovery) and whether listing a perpetual contract could affect the volatility, margin requirements and reliability of standard futures contracts.50

Reference price and continuous observability

The CFTC asks whether there is a cash price series for crude oil that satisfies the requirements of Appendix C to Part 38 of the CFTC Rules (governing reliability of settlement prices) and that could serve as a reference price observable at every funding interval.51 The CFTC notes that for a perpetual contract, “the reference must be reliable at every funding interval, without interruption, for as long as the contract remains active,” a materially more demanding standard than the single-moment-in-time analysis applicable to a traditional cash-settled futures contract.52 The CFTC also asks whether price discovery for crude oil is located in the futures market rather than in a continuously traded physical cash market, and what the reliability and manipulation implications are of a perpetual contract referencing the DCM’s own futures price, a third-party DCM’s futures price, an assessed or surveyed physical price or a composite index.53

Applicability of funding rate mechanism to energy markets

The request for comment asks whether a funding-rate mechanism, developed in markets for assets without significant cost of carry, can accurately reflect physical market dynamics such as storage costs, convenience yield and seasonality.54 It also asks what distortions could arise over extended holding periods due to the interaction of accumulated funding payments with the physical fundamentals of a storable energy commodity, including storage cycles, seasonal demand and term structure (contango and backwardation).55

Physical delivery, storage constraints and market stress

The CFTC invokes the April 20, 2020 episode in which the expiring NYMEX West Texas Intermediate crude oil futures contract settled at a negative price amid constrained storage at the delivery point.56 It asks what the implications of such physical-market dislocations are for the design and resilience of a perpetual contract referencing crude oil, including for its mark price, funding payments and any automatic liquidation processes.57 The CFTC also notes that the standard futures contract that experienced that episode “was eventually resolved through the expiration and delivery process,” while a perpetual has no such terminal event.58

Position limits

The CFTC asks how a perpetual contract referencing a commodity such as NYMEX West Texas Intermediate crude oil would be integrated into the Part 150 position limits framework, given that it has no delivery and no expiration, and whether a perpetual position should be treated as continuously within the spot month, never within it, or mapped to the spot month of the referenced contract as it rolls.59 The CFTC also asks whether a large perpetual position could create an economic incentive to influence the referenced contract’s price during its spot month without the perpetual itself participating in delivery.60

Clearing, margin and default management; Customer protection; Cross-asset criteria

The request for comment asks:

  • What clearing, margining and default-management considerations differ from, or arise in addition to, those applicable to existing cleared futures contracts on the same commodity for a perpetual contract referencing an energy commodity61
  • What automatic liquidations or risk-mitigation mechanisms would be appropriate and what operational considerations are raised by the calculation and settlement of funding payments on a continuous basis62
  • What customer-protection considerations, including suitability, disclosure and the risk of rapid loss, arise from offering a perpetual contract on a geopolitically sensitive physical commodity to retail participants, and whether access should be limited to eligible contract participants or tiered by sophistication63
  • What criteria should be considered by the CFTC in determining whether a given underlying commodity can support a perpetual contract consistent with DCM Core Principles64

Regulatory developments regarding 24/7 derivatives trading

The 24/7 Trading Advisory

On May 29, 2026, the CFTC staff issued the 24/7 Trading Advisory establishing the CFTC staff’s expectations for trading platforms (DCMs and SEFs), DCOs and FCMs engaging in trading on a 24/7 basis.

Appropriateness of 24/7 trading for different asset classes

CFTC staff state that switching to 24/7 trading and clearing “may not currently be suitable for all asset classes.”65 Although derivatives referencing crypto assets “may be well-suited for 24/7 trading due to their digital infrastructure and global reach…other derivatives markets, such as in agricultural products, may be less suited for 24/7 trading due to their unique customer bases, regional nature and the specialized trading and hedging practices in those markets.” Accordingly, the CFTC staff state that DCMs, SEFs and DCOs “should consider market needs, the trading characteristics of the underlying markets, specific contract features and design, and the potential implications for risk management, clearing and trading activities when considering a transition to 24/7 trading, clearing and settlement.”66

The CFTC staff stated that they will “engage in a detailed review of any plans, and associated analysis, to determine whether the extension of market hours complies with the CEA and [CFTC] regulations thereunder.”67 Furthermore, the CFTC staff recommend that “any DCMs, SEFs or DCOs considering 24/7 trading or associated clearing operations for specific products or markets, and FCMs seeking to intermediate such operations, engage with [CFTC] staff beforehand.”68

We address below the key takeaways from the 24/7 Trading Advisory for (i) trading platforms, (ii) DCOs and (iii) FCMs.

Key Takeaways for DCMs and SEFs offering 24/7 derivatives trading

****

In order to comply with applicable Core Principles under the CEA and CFTC regulations, DCMs and SEFs offering 24/7 trading should address the following issues:

Settlement process

DCMs and SEFs should “avoid offering contracts that settle during off-peak periods” (for example, overnight and weekends), which may result in manipulation, disruptions of the settlement process, and trading, market, and pricing disruptions or distortions.69

Real-time monitoring and risk controls

Because extending trading hours to a 24/7 schedule could potentially result in “reduced liquidity, increased volatility [and] widened bid/ask spreads” in certain markets or products, creating greater opportunities for market manipulation, DCMs and SEFs must:

  • “…conduct real-time monitoring and maintain robust market surveillance for abusive trading practices of the product or market that is trading under a 24/7 schedule because of the inherent risks of a thinly traded market” 70
  • Adopt effective risk control mechanisms in order to prevent and reduce the “potential risk of market disruptions that may be present in a 24/7 trading environment”71
System safeguards

The 24/7 Trading Advisory emphasizes that “automated systems must be constantly monitored and regularly tested to ensure they remain secure and scalable under varying loads, including off-peak hours when staffing and oversight may be reduced.”72

The potentially increased risk of operational failures, cyber threats and system outages requires “robust business continuity and disaster recovery plans that can respond swiftly to incidents at any time.”73 Furthermore, DCM and SEF systems should be designed for “high availability and resilience, including the elimination of single points of failure, the use of redundant infrastructure, real-time data synchronization and ongoing validation of component-level availability.”74 DCMs and SEFs should also maintain “duplicate or parallel production environments that support rolling upgrades, live cutovers and back-out procedures, in accordance with generally accepted best practices.”75

Compliance staffing and resources

The 24/7 Trading Advisory notes that maintaining sufficient real-time surveillance and compliance coverage overnight and during weekends may cause resource strain for DCMs and SEFs and may raise issues regarding the timely identification and mitigation of emerging risks. In addition, for DCMs and SEFs that use a regulatory service provider, the 24/7 Trading Advisory reiterates that while such regulated entities must “ensure that the provider has the capacity and resources necessary to provide timely and effective regulatory services, including adequate staff and automated surveillance systems,” such DCMs and SEFs “remain responsible for the performance of any regulatory services received, for compliance with their obligations under the [CEA] and [CFTC] regulations and for the regulatory service provider’s performance” on their behalf.76

To support 24/7 trading, the 24/7 Trading Advisory states that DCMs and SEFs should implement additional compliance measures, including (i) increasing compliance staffing and resources to ensure adequate coverage and real-time, continuous monitoring, (ii) updating procedures to reflect the demands of continuous operations and (iii) establishing new operational protocols specifically tailored to mitigate risks and maintain market integrity in a 24/7 trading environment.77

Key takeaways for DCOs clearing of 24/7 derivatives markets

With respect to the regulatory obligations applicable to DCOs under the CEA and CFTC Rules in the context of extending market access to a 24/7 basis, the 24/7 Trading Advisory states that the CFTC staff will consider, among other things, the potential effects of 24/7 trading operations on a DCO’s (i) clearing, margin and settlement arrangements; (ii) system safeguards; (iii) market-integrity controls; and (iv) staffing and governance.78 More specifically, the 24/7 Trading Advisory notes that extended hours trading may involve one of the following models with respect to clearing: (i) collateral calls continue to be made only during traditional market hours (reflective of current 24/7 trading in US derivatives markets); (ii) participants being allowed to opt into posting collateral during weekend hours; or (iii) participants being required to post collateral during weekend hours.

Weekday-only margin calls

The 24/7 Trading Advisory emphasizes that a DCO that retains weekday-only collateral calls must still satisfy its financial-resources and liquidity obligations continuously, including across multi-day bank closures, as required by DCO Core Principle B.79 Accordingly, DCOs should evaluate the impacts caused by a divergence between trading and clearing frequencies on areas including risk tolerances, stress scenarios and participant behavior.80 DCOs should also explain to the CFTC “any mitigants implemented to ensure that they are still meeting [Core Principle B] (for example, adjusting the size of the guarantee fund, or to margin calibrations, in response to novel risks posed by weekend trading).”81

DCOs should ensure initial margin requirements address the unique risks posed by a given product or portfolio, including considering the need for pre-funding of initial margin or additional liquidity buffers for initial margin during extended hours.82 Margin calibrations should also be adjusted to ensure appropriate coverage for multi-day exposures.

Weekend provision of margin

Regarding clearing models involving participants exchanging collateral over the weekend either on an optional or required basis, the advisory highlights that a DCO must continue to ensure that eligible collateral “remains restricted to ‘those that have minimal credit, market and liquidity risks.’”83 DCOs may need to consider and quantify changes in such risks due to the fact that traditional forms of collateral (such as cash) may be less widely available over the weekend.84 Although the risks of weekend posting of stablecoins and other digital assets as margin may be “less acute,” such asset classes may raise the need for DCOs to evaluate other risks unique to such “innovative classes of collateral.”85

Among other things, DCOs should consider the following factors regarding clearing models involving weekend collateral exchange:

  1. Operational structures allowing for timely and reliable movement of collateral
  2. The ability to readily convert between collateral types
  3. Exposure monitoring during trading periods with participant and liquidity profiles distinct from weekday trading
  4. Distinct default management procedures that consider and address weekend risks86

Importantly, the 24/7 Trading Advisory states that weekend clearing models, “especially those where all market participants are required to participate in weekend collateral posting and transfer, may be neither prudent nor viable” for markets concentrated in specific geographic regions or hours (, US regional markets like agriculture or livestock), or where operational or liquidity costs of weekend collateral are especially high for traditional end users.87

FCM regulatory obligations

The 24/7 Trading Advisory addresses four areas of heightened concern for FCMs intermediating 24/7 transactions:

Segregation requirements

The advisory warns that extending trading hours to a 24/7 basis without weekend or holiday settlement “may cause FCMs to violate segregation requirements, and possibly capital requirements, if there is significant volatility in the relevant market or products.”88 The advisory reminds FCMs that they must comply with applicable segregation requirements at all times.89 Consistent with the risk management requirements of CFTC Rule 1.11, FCMs intermediating transactions on a 24/7 basis are “expected to assess and adjust…the targeted amount of residual interest [they] seek[] to maintain in segregated accounts” to account for risks associated with 24/7 trading and related clearing activities.90 FCMs should also consider other risk mitigation options such as “customer prefunding of accounts that trade on a 24/7 basis.”91

Customer disclosures

FCMs may need to enhance existing risk management programs to account for weekend, holiday and overnight trading, including auto-liquidation of undermargined customer accounts.92 FCMs should ensure that appropriate risk disclosures regarding all applicable aspects of extended trading hours are provided to customers and the public, consistent with the requirements of CFTC Rule 1.55.93

Risk management program

FCMs offering extended-hours trading should consider whether amendments to risk management policies and procedures are necessary to address risks related to segregation of customer funds, operational risks and capital risks.94

Operational capabilities and staffing

FCMs must maintain adequate front-office and back-office systems with adequate staffing to ensure those systems are operational during extended trading hours, and must consider whether critical third-party service providers can perform necessary services consistent with CFTC and exchange requirements during extended trading hours.95

Perpetuals & 24/7 trading RFC

As noted above, on June 25, 2026, the CFTC published a request for comment addressing the extension of standard futures contracts to 24/7 trading without any change to their fixed expiration, delivery or settlement terms.96 The comment period for the RFC, as extended, closed on August 26, 2026. With respect to 24/7 trading of standard futures, the CFTC’s request for comment poses thirty detailed questions across three different issue areas:

Price reliability and manipulation risk

The CFTC asks whether extending trading hours to a 24/7 basis would materially change the availability or reliability of prices formed during overnight, weekend and holiday periods.97 The CFTC also specifically asks about the reliability and manipulation implications of a futures price observed during periods when no contemporaneous physical trading occurs in the underlying cash market, noting that the cash market for crude oil and other energy commodities is “generally assessed during defined windows, rather than traded 24/7.”98

Off-hours settlement and payment infrastructure

The request for comment devotes substantial attention to the settlement gap created when contracts trade 24/7 but traditional fiat payment systems, including Fedwire and CHIPS, do not operate.99 The CFTC asks how DCMs and DCOs could ensure robust margin call and settlement processes during such periods, what real-time or tokenized payment infrastructure would be integrated into the clearing process, and what procedures would be available to clearing members that do not hold digital or tokenized assets.100 The CFTC also asks whether contracts traded 24/7 should require an additional initial-margin buffer in advance of weekend or extended-holiday closures, and what forms of collateral (such as, cash, US Treasury securities, tokenized Treasury securities and stablecoins.) could be eligible to satisfy margin obligations when traditional payment systems are unavailable.101

The Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC asks over a dozen questions addressing the downstream effects of weekend price formation on: (i) OTC derivatives markets, including barrier options, structured products and collateral agreements; (ii) physical commercial contracts incorporating futures prices through averaging mechanisms, settlement formulas and index references; (iii) official closing prices, settlement prices and benchmark calculations; (iv) investment portfolios, index products, ETFs, mutual funds and pensions; (v) leveraged, inverse and other futures-linked ETFs; and (vi) options referencing ETFs.102 The CFTC asks how prices established during extended trading hours might be used or construed to trigger termination events, early termination rights, additional collateral requirements or valuation disputes under OTC derivatives and financing arrangements.103 It also asks whether there is a concern that price formation in a smaller contract trading 24/7 may influence the larger benchmark contract that trades during traditional hours.104

Additional questions regarding the NYMEX Oil 24/7 contract and operational readiness

In the comment-period extension, the CFTC requested additional comment on three further topics:

First, it asks whether 24/7 trading in a smaller crude oil contract referencing, or closely correlated with, the same underlying crude oil market could create incentives for participants holding benchmark futures or TAS positions to establish positions before the benchmark market closes, trade over the weekend in a manner that moves prices and influence price formation when benchmark markets reopen, including potentially resulting in crude oil prices reaching negative prices. 105Second, the CFTC invites comment on all aspects of the continuous trading of NYMEX’s stayed 10-Barrel WTI Crude Oil Futures contract, including implications for reference-price reliability, manipulation resistance, surveillance, position limits, margin, clearing, settlement, customer protection and effects on physical crude oil markets and commercial participants.106

Third, the CFTC asks industry participants to identify the concrete steps, investments, systems, staffing and process changes needed to support 24/7 crude oil futures trading and to estimate the time required to implement them.107

The NYMEX Stay Order

On July 9, 2026, the CFTC issued the NYMEX Stay Order in response to NYMEX’s July 8, 2026 self-certification under CEA Section 5c(c)(1) and CFTC Rule 40.2 to list for trading the 10-Barrel WTI Crude Oil Futures contract (the WTI Contract), a futures contract on West Texas Intermediate crude oil that, unlike NYMEX’s other crude oil futures contracts, is designed to trade 24 hours per day, seven days per week, except for limited maintenance windows, including weekend and holiday periods during which the underlying physical crude oil market is not assessed. Absent CFTC action, the WTI Contract could have been listed and available for trading one business day after the CFTC’s receipt of the submission.108

In the NYMEX Stay Order, the CFTC took three actions: (i) it instituted a proceeding to determine whether NYMEX’s certification that the WTI Contract complies with the CEA and the CFTC’s regulations was false; (ii) it requested, pursuant to CEA Section 8a(7), that NYMEX alter the WTI Contract’s terms and conditions to discontinue continuous trading and limit trading to conventional trading hours applicable to NYMEX’s comparable crude oil futures contracts; and (iii) it stayed the listing of the WTI Contract, effective immediately, during the pendency of those proceedings, pursuant to CFTC Rule 40.2(c). The NYMEX Stay Order expressly states that it makes no final determination as to whether the WTI Contract complies with the CEA.109

The CFTC identified several substantive concerns regarding the continuous trading of crude oil futures. First, the CFTC noted that crude oil is among the most consequential of physical commodities, with its price setting the cost of energy throughout the real economy and serving as the reference against which producers, refiners, transporters and consumers manage the risk of physical supply.110 The cash market for crude oil is assessed within defined daily windows; outside those windows, no contemporaneous physical transaction exists against which a futures price can be tested. The CFTC expressed concern that a continuously traded oil futures contract may generate its most consequential prices at the very hours those prices are least susceptible to verification, precisely when futures liquidity would be thinnest and a single participant’s activities could carry the greatest price impact.111 The CFTC stated that a futures price formed in such conditions is vulnerable to manipulation and less likely to reflect the value of the underlying commodity, raising concerns under DCM Core Principle 3 (which permits a contract market to list only contracts that are not readily susceptible to manipulation) and DCM Core Principle 4 (which requires the capacity to prevent manipulation, price distortion and disruption of the cash-settlement process through market surveillance).112

Second, the CFTC raised concerns regarding the potential influence of the WTI Contract on benchmark crude oil futures prices.113 Standard crude oil futures serve as benchmarks against which commercial participants hedge their physical positions, and physical contracts for supply, transportation and financing incorporate them through averaging, settlement and index provisions. The CFTC expressed concern that a smaller, continuously traded, retail-oriented contract could exert influence on the larger benchmark during the very periods when the benchmark itself is closed, and that outsized movements originating in those hours may carry into the regular trading day and into the physical arrangements layered upon the benchmark, reaching the producers, refiners and consumers for whom the futures market exists to serve.114

Third, the CFTC identified concerns regarding the payment and clearing infrastructure necessary to support continuous trading. Trading on weekends, overnight and on holidays generates margin, settlement and default-management obligations at times when Fedwire, CHIPS and the bank payment infrastructure on which clearing depends do not operate. The CFTC questioned whether a DCO can call and collect margin and effect settlement in those conditions, whether it would be driven to advance liquidity and absorb the resulting credit and liquidity exposure when member funds cannot move and whether price movements formed in illiquid off-hours trading would force additional variation margin, collateral calls and liquidations—with the attendant potential for liquidation cascades and the transmission of stress into related markets and onto the clearinghouse itself.115

The CFTC emphasized that it is presently examining, through the Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC (with an extended comment period that closed on August 26, 2026), whether the extension of standard energy futures to continuous around-the-clock trading is consistent with the DCM Core Principles. The NYMEX Stay Order directs NYMEX to file a written answer with the Secretary of the CFTC no later than July 24, 2026, demonstrating why its certification that the WTI Contract complies with the CEA and the DCM Core Principles should not be found to be false, and to advise the CFTC in writing by the same date whether it will alter the WTI Contract’s terms and conditions as requested.116

The NYMEX Stay Order is notable as the first instance in which the CFTC has exercised its authority under CFTC Rule 40.2(c) to stay the listing of a self-certified product in the context of 24/7 trading.

Conclusion

Taken together, the CFTC’s actions detailed above are meaningful steps towards clarity regarding the regulatory treatment of perpetual contracts and regulatory obligations applicable to CFTC registrants in the context of extended hours trading and clearing. The Perpetuals Policy Statement, Kalshi Perpetuals Order and guidance provided by CFTC Letter 26-17 represent a significant step toward onshoring a product class that has developed almost entirely in offshore markets. Furthermore, the NYMEX Stay Order signals that the CFTC may be choosing not to permit the self-certification process to be used to introduce continuously traded energy futures while the CFTC’s review of the regulatory implications of such trading remains pending.117

Whether the CFTC ultimately moves from staff guidance to formal rulemaking remains to be seen, but registrants considering developing, listing or trading perpetual contracts in the US should carefully review whether their proposed products fall within the scope of the CFTC’s guidance. Market participants considering the development or listing of 24/7 energy futures products should take note that the CFTC has demonstrated a willingness to act swiftly to preserve the status quo where it determines that a self-certification does not adequately demonstrate compliance with the CEA and the DCM Core Principles, particularly with respect to physically delivered commodities whose underlying cash markets do not trade on a continuous basis.

Market participants should actively monitor regulatory developments in the perpetuals space, including the ultimate outcome of the CME’s litigation against the CFTC. Furthermore, registrants considering establishing 24/7 operations should consider engaging with CFTC staff to begin building the operational and compliance infrastructure that the 24/7 Trading Advisory contemplates.

Special thanks to senior counsel Stephan Ariyan for assisting in the preparation of this article.

Footnotes

  1. 1

    See Policy Statement, Commodity Futures Trading Commission, Policy Statement Concerning the Listing of Perpetual Contracts, 91 Fed. Reg. 33160 (June 3, 2026); Commodity Futures Trading Commission, Order Approving KalshiEx LLC BTCPERP Futures Contract (May 29, 2026).

  2. 2

    See Commission Staff Interpretation and No-Action, Commodity Futures Trading Commission, Staff Interpretation Regarding the Categorization of Deribit Perpetuals as Foreign Futures and No-Action Position Regarding Digital Commodities and Payment Stablecoins Deposited to Margin Customer Positions with a Foreign Broker Under a Right of Re-Use (May 29, 2026) (“CFTC Letter 26-17”).

  3. 3

    See Request for Comment, Commodity Futures Trading Commission, Request for Comment on the Extension of Standard Futures Contracts to 24/7 Trading and on Perpetual Contracts Referencing Physically Delivered or Storable Energy Commodities, 91 Fed. Reg. 38334 (June 25, 2026).

  4. 4

    See Request for Comment, Commodity Futures Trading Commission, Request for Comment on the Extension of Standard Futures Contracts to 24/7 Trading and on Perpetual Contracts Referencing Physically Delivered or Storable Energy Commodities, 91 Fed. Reg. 47158 (July 28, 2026).

  5. 5

    See CFTC Staff Letter No. 26-16, Staff Advisory for Extending Trading and/or Clearing Operations to a 24 Hours-a-Day, 7 Days-a-Week Basis (May 29, 2026).

  6. 6

    See, Press Release No. 9265-26, Commodity Futures Trading Commission, CFTC to Stay Self-Certified Contract on 24/7 Trading for Crude Oil Futures (July 9, 2026); In re 10-Barrel WTI Crude Oil futures contract self-certified by the New York Mercantile Exchange, Inc. under Commission Regulation 40.2, Order Instituting Proceedings and Staying the Listing of the Contract Under Commission Regulation 40.2(c) (July 9, 2026).

  7. 7

    Perpetuals Policy Statement at 33161.

  8. 8

    Perpetuals Policy Statement at 33160-61.

  9. 9

    Perpetuals Policy Statement at 33161.

  10. 10

    Perpetuals Policy Statement at 33161.

  11. 11

    See CFTC Request for Comment, Request for Comment on the Trading and Clearing of “Perpetual” Style Derivatives (April 21, 2025). This request for comment was issued in conjunction with a request for comment on 24/7 derivatives trading which sought public input on the operational, surveillance, clearing, and margin implications of extending CFTC-regulated derivatives trading to a continuous basis. See CFTC Request for Comment, Request for Comment on Trading and Clearing Derivatives on a 24/7 Basis (April 21, 2025).

  12. 12

    See CFTC Request for Comment, Request for Comment on the Trading and Clearing of “Perpetual” Style Derivatives (April 21, 2025). This request for comment was issued in conjunction with a request for comment on 24/7 derivatives trading which sought public input on the operational, surveillance, clearing, and margin implications of extending CFTC-regulated derivatives trading to a continuous basis. See CFTC Request for Comment, Request for Comment on Trading and Clearing Derivatives on a 24/7 Basis (April 21, 2025).

  13. 13

    Perpetuals Policy Statement at 33161; see also President’s Working Group on Digital Asset Markets, Strengthening American Leadership in Digital Financial Technology (July 30, 2025).

  14. 14

    Note that the CEA and CFTC Rules do not define “futures contract” or “contract of sale for future delivery.” However, the CFTC has provided guidance indicating its view as to what constitutes a futures contract. See, e.g., Section 4(a): Applicability of Commodity Futures Regulations to Transactions Involving Gold Coins and Gold Bullion, CFTC Letter 97-01 (Dec. 12, 1996) (“[B]ased upon various definitions provided in Section 1a of the [CEA], futures contracts would include agreements for the purchase or sale of ‘all . . . goods and articles . . . and all services, rights, and interests in which contracts for future delivery are presently or in the future dealt in,’ but would exclude ‘any sale of any cash commodity for deferred shipment or delivery.’ ”); “Futures Contract”, CFTC Glossary (“An agreement to purchase or sell a commodity for delivery in the future: (1) at a price that is determined at initiation of the contract; (2) that obligates each party to the contract to fulfill the contract at the specified price; (3) that is used to assume or shift price risk; and (4) that may be satisfied by delivery or offset.”). When evaluating a contract to determine whether it constitutes a futures contract for purposes of the CEA and CFTC Rules, courts and the CFTC have “assess[ed] each transaction ‘as a whole with a critical eye toward its underlying purpose’ by evaluating whether certain characteristics common to futures contracts are present.” See Kalshi Perpetuals Order at 3 (citing CFTC v. Co Petro Marketing Group, Inc., 680 F.2d 573 (9th Cir. 1982)).

  15. 15

    Kalshi Perpetuals Order at 1.

  16. 16

    Kalshi Perpetuals Order at 6. Notably, with respect to whether the indefinite duration of the BTCPERP Contract would affect the contract’s regulatory classification as a futures contract, the CFTC relied on Kalshi’s analysis that “courts have not viewed [the characteristic of “futurity”—i.e., the concept that a futures contract provides for the purchase or sale of a commodity at a fixed date in the future] as necessary to conclude that a contract is a futures contract.” See Kalshi Perpetuals Order at 5. Kalshi’s analysis relied in significant part on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit case Chicago Mercantile Exchange v. SEC, 883 F.2d 537 (7th Cir. 1989). See Kalshi Perpetuals Order at 5. Kalshi argued that Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals concluded in Chicago Mercantile Exchange v. SEC that “contracts of ‘indefinite duration’ can possess the attribute of ‘futurity’—generally associated with futures contracts—because futurity means ‘value that is set in the future’ and exists where contracts provide for future executory payment obligations, not only where a contract has a final settlement date and fixed term.” See Kalshi Perpetuals Order at 5 (citing Chicago Mercantile Exchange v. SEC, 883 F.2d at 541).

  17. 17

    Kalshi Perpetuals Order at 8.

  18. 18

    Kalshi Perpetuals Order at 6; see also CFTC Rule 38.200.

  19. 19

    Kalshi Perpetuals Order at 7.

  20. 20

    Kalshi Perpetuals Order at 7-8. In connection with the issuance of the Perpetuals Policy Statement and the Kalshi Perpetuals Order, the staff of the CFTC’s Division of Market Oversight (“DMO”) issued CFTC Letter 26-19 which provided time-limited, conditional no-action relief allowing DCMs to remove the expiration dates from the terms and conditions of their existing perpetual-style digital commodity futures contracts in order to effectively convert the existing perpetual-style contracts into digital commodity perpetual futures contracts notwithstanding the requirements of CFTC Rules 40.6(a)(3) (i.e., the ten business day pre-filing requirement) and 40.6(b)(1) (the ten business day CFTC review period). See CFTC Letter No. 26-19, No-Action Positions Regarding Removal of Expiration Dates from Existing Digital Commodity Perpetual-Style Futures Contracts (June 12, 2026). Such relief expired on June 30, 2026.

  21. 21

    Perpetuals Policy Statement at 33161.

  22. 22

    Perpetuals Policy Statement at 33161-62.

  23. 23

    Perpetuals Policy Statement at 33161 n.5.

  24. 24

    Perpetuals Policy Statement at 33161 n.5. The CFTC included the same statement in the Kalshi Perpetuals Order. See Kalshi Perpetuals Order at 9 n.25.

  25. 25

    Perpetuals Policy Statement at 33161 n.5. Id.

  26. 26

    Perpetuals Policy Statement at 33161. As the Perpetuals Policy Statement makes clear, it is a general statement of policy issued under Section 553(b)(A) of the Administrative Procedures Act and “does not impose any obligation on any person, modify or supersede any provision of the [CEA]…or the [CFTC’s] regulations thereunder, [or] create any new right or benefit enforceable at law or in equity.” Id.

  27. 27

    See CFTC Letter 26-17 at 6-16. For purposes of CFTC Letter 26-17, “digital commodity” has the meaning given to it under the Joint Interpretation. Furthermore, the term “payment stablecoin” means: (i) prior to the effective date of the Guiding and Establishing National Innovation for U.S. Stablecoins Act, 12 U.S.C. §§ 5901-5916 (July 18, 2025) (“GENIUS Act”), a USD-denominated stablecoin that is issued by a state-regulated money transmitter, state-regulated trust company, or a national trust bank; maintains reserve assets limited to direct or indirect investments in cash, U.S. treasury securities or overnight U.S. Treasury repurchase agreements; and publishes monthly attestations regarding the composition of the reserve assets and whether the fair value of the assets held in reserve is equal to the amount of stablecoins in circulation; and (ii) following the effective date of the GENIUS Act, a stablecoin that meets the requirements contained in the GENIUS Act’s definition of “payment stablecoin” and is issued by a “permitted payment stablecoin issuer” or a “foreign payment stablecoin issuer” that complies with the GENIUS Act’s requirements applicable to such issuers. See 12 U.S.C. §§ 5901(11)-(12), (22).

  28. 28

    See CFTC Rule 30.1. For purposes of CFTC Letter 26-17, the term “FBOT” is distinguished from a CFTC-registered FBOT under Part 48 of the CFTC Rules that provides “direct access” as defined in CFTC Rule 48.2(c). In addition, CFTC Rule 30.1 defines the term “foreign option” to mean, in relevant part, any transaction or agreement which is or is held out to be of the character of, or is commonly known to trade as, an “option” made or to be made on or subject to the rules of any FBOT. See CFTC Rule 30.1.

  29. 29

    CFTC Letter 26-17 at 5.

  30. 30

    CFTC Letter 26-17 at 5. CFTC Rule 30.1 defines the term “30.7 customer” to include both U.S. and non-U.S. persons who trade foreign futures or foreign options through an FCM. Furthermore, CFTC Rule 30.7 defines the term “30.7 customer funds” to mean any money, securities, or other property received by an FCM from, for, or on behalf of 30.7 Customers to margin, guarantee or secure foreign futures or foreign option positions, or money, securities or other property accruing to 30.7 customers as a result of foreign futures and foreign option positions. See CFTC Rule 30.1.

  31. 31

    See CFTC Rule 30.7(b)-(d). Permitted Depositories include banks and trust companies located in the United States, banks and trust companies located outside of the United States with more than US$1 billion of regulatory capital, CFTC-registered FCMs, CFTC-registered derivatives clearing organizations, clearing organizations of FBOTs, members of FBOTs, and designated depositories of members of FBOTs or foreign clearing organizations. See CFTC Rule 30.7(b). Furthermore, CFTC Rule 30.7(d) requires that pursuant to the terms of the required acknowledgment letter, each depository must acknowledge, among other things, that (i) the FCM opened the account for the purpose of depositing 30.7 Customer Funds belonging to 30.7 Customers for trading foreign futures and/or foreign options; (ii) the depository will hold the 30.7 Customer Funds separate from its own funds and separate from any proprietary funds deposited by the FCM; and (iii) the 30.7 Customer Funds will be treated in accordance with CEA Section 4(b) and CFTC Rule 30.7. The standard form acknowledgement letter that an FCM is required to execute with each depository is located at Appendix E to Part 30 of the CFTC Rules.

  32. 32

    See CFTC Rule 30.7(c); CFTC Letter 26-17 at 6.

  33. 33

    CFTC Letter 26-17 at 4. CFTC Letter 26-17 states that Deribit calculates funding payments owed or due to holders of Deribit Perpetuals every millisecond and that each funding payment is the product of: “(i) a funding rate, which is based on the difference between the mark price of the Deribit Perpetual at a given time and the price of the underlying digital commodity (by reference to the relevant index) at that time subject to applicable damping rates and caps, as described in the Deribit Perpetual’s product specifications; (ii) the holder’s open position size; (iii) the holder’s position side (long or short); and (iv) the fraction obtained by dividing the amount of time over which the funding rate was applied by eight hours.” CFTC Letter 26-17 at 4 n.15. At daily settlement, “Deribit will distribute or collect margin obligations from all members with open long or short positions in the Deribit Perpetuals, including aggregate funding payment obligations and/or entitlements accrued since the prior settlement period. Each Deribit Perpetual will have a standard size corresponding to a fixed amount of the underlying digital commodity.” Id.

  34. 34

    See CFTC Letter 26-17 at 8.

  35. 35

    See CFTC Letter 26-17 at 8.

  36. 36

    See CFTC Letter 26-17 at 8-16. CFTC Letter 26-17 builds on guidance provided in CFTC Letter 25-38 and CFTC Letter 26-05.[1] In CFTC Letter 25-38, CFTC staff provided no-action relief permitting an FCM to transfer customer securities to a non-U.S. FCM for purposes of margining transactions in foreign futures and options subject to substantially similar conditions to those adopted in CFTC Letter 26-17.[1] In CFTC Letter 26-05, the CFTC permitted CFTC-registered FCMs to accept certain non-securities digital assets, including payment stablecoins, Bitcoin and Ether, as margin for derivatives transactions, and to deposit proprietary payment stablecoins as residual interest, subject to conditions regarding valuation and haircuts, regulatory reporting, and adherence to risk management requirements.[1] The no-action relief granted under CFTC Letter 26-17 effectively extends the regulatory interpretations established by CFTC Letter 25-38 and CFTC Letter 26-05 to Customer Digital Assets—i.e., digital assets that are not securities.

  37. 37

    See CFTC Letter 26-17 at 2 n.8.

  38. 38

    A “criminal disqualification” is defined to mean “the person has plead to, or been convicted of, a felony or a misdemeanor that provides the Commission with the grounds to refuse to register or to revoke, condition, or restrict the registration of the person pursuant to the applicable provision of [CEA] Sections 8a(2)(D), 8a(3)(D), 8a(3)(E) or 8a(3)(H).” See CFTC Letter 26-17 at 11 n.42.

  39. 39

    See Chicago Mercantile Exchange, Inc. v. Selig (Complaint), No. 1:26-cv-02157 (D.D.C. filed June 18, 2026) (“CME Perpetuals Complaint”).

  40. 40

    See CME Perpetuals Complaint at *111-120.

  41. 41

    See CME Perpetuals Complaint at 121-24 (citing CFTC v. Zhao *(Complaint), No. 23-cv-1887 (N.D. Ill Mar. 27, 2023), ECF No. 1; CFTC v. HDR Glob. Trading Ltd. (Complaint), No. 20-cv-8132 (S.D.N.Y. Oct. 1, 2020), ECF No. 1; CFTC v. Eisenberg (Complaint), No. 23-cv-173 (S.D.N.Y. Jan. 9, 2023), ECF No. 1; In re Deridex Inc., CFTC Order No. 23-42 (Sept. 7, 2023).

  42. 42

    See CME Perpetuals Complaint at *147. Notably, on the same day that the CME filed its suit against the CFTC, the CFTC and the SEC jointly issued a request for comment seeking input regarding clarification of the definitions of “swap” and “security-based swap” under the Dodd-Frank Act’s Title VII framework. See Joint Request for Comment, Joint Request for Comment on Further Definition of “Swap” and “Security-Based Swap” and on Alternative Compliance, 91 Fed. Reg. 37873 (June 24, 2026) (“Swap Definitions RFC”). Among other things, the joint request asks whether there is a need for “greater clarity regarding whether a cash-settled ‘perpetual’ contract referencing an equity security could be treated as a security future.” See Swap Definitions RFC at 37876.

  43. 43

    See CME Perpetuals Complaint at *137-46 (citing Perpetuals Policy Statement at 33161 and CFTC Rule 40.3(c)(2)-(3)).

  44. 44

    See CME Perpetuals Complaint at *140-41.

  45. 45

    CME Perpetuals Complaint at *11.

  46. 46

    CME Perpetuals Complaint at *11.

  47. 47

    See Request for Comment, Commodity Futures Trading Commission, Request for Comment on the Extension of Standard Futures Contracts to 24/7 Trading and on Perpetual Contracts Referencing Physically Delivered or Storable Energy Commodities, 91 Fed. Reg. 38334 (June 25, 2026).

  48. 48

    Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC at 38337.

  49. 49

    Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC at 38337.

  50. 50

    Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC at 38337.

  51. 51

    Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC at 38337.

  52. 52

    Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC at 38338.

  53. 53

    Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC at 38337-38.

  54. 54

    Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC at 38338.

  55. 55

    Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC at 38338.

  56. 56

    Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC at 38338.

  57. 57

    Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC at 38338.

  58. 58

    Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC at 38338.

  59. 59

    Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC at 38338-39.

  60. 60

    24/7 Trading RFC at 38339.

  61. 61

    24/7 Trading RFC at 38339.

  62. 62

    24/7 Trading RFC at 38339.

  63. 63

    24/7 Trading RFC at 38339.

  64. 64

    Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC at 38339.

  65. 65

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 2.

  66. 66

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 2.

  67. 67

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 1.

  68. 68

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 1. The 24/7 Trading Advisory states that any CFTC registrant adopting 24/7 operations by rule submission under Part 40 of the CFTC Rules should provide a comprehensive explanation of the proposed changes, their expected effects on risk and the mitigation strategies to be employed. Such proposed rule changes must demonstrate compliance with all relevant provisions of the CEA, including the applicable Core Principles and CFTC regulations thereunder. The 24/7 Trading Advisory notes that registrants are required to address substantive opposing views expressed by governing board or committee members, entity members or market participants. See 24/7 Trading Advisory at 8; see also CFTC Rule 40.6(a)(7)(vi); CFTC Rule 40.5(a)(8).

  69. 69

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 3. See 7 U.S.C. § 7(d)(3); 7 U.S.C. § 7b-3(f)(3); CFTC Rules 37.300-301, 38.200-201.

  70. 70

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 4.

  71. 71

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 4.

  72. 72

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 4.

  73. 73

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 4.

  74. 74

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 4.

  75. 75

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 4.

  76. 76

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 5 and n.14.

  77. 77

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 5.

  78. 78

    Depending on the clearing model used for 24/7 derivatives clearing, DCOs may need to consider the requirements of DCO Core Principles relating to (i) information and operational security; (ii) business continuity and disaster recovery planning and resources; (iii) capacity and performance planning; (iv) systems operations; (v) systems development and quality assurance; and (vi) physical/environmental security.[1] DCOs may also need to consider Revised Enterprise Technology Risk Assessments, updated procedures for notice filings related to material system impairments or business continuity and disaster recovery activation that occur during weekend hours, and “staffing coverage plans across operations, risk management, compliance, surveillance, cybersecurity, and incident response, as well as vendor/service-provider coverage for critical dependencies (e.g., cloud/hosting, network, and market-support services).” 24/7 Trading Advisory at 8

  79. 79

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 6; 7 U.S.C. 7a-1(c)(2)(B).

  80. 80

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 6.

  81. 81

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 6-7.

  82. 82

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 6-7.

  83. 83

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 7.

  84. 84

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 7.

  85. 85

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 7.

  86. 86

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 7.

  87. 87

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 7-8.

  88. 88

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 9.

  89. 89

    See 7 U.S.C. § 6d; CFTC Rule 1.20, CFTC Rule 22.2, and CFTC Rule 30.7.

  90. 90

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 9-10.

  91. 91

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 10.

  92. 92

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 10. The Advisory specifically flags the risk of auto-liquidation cascades—i.e., a sudden, large price move could trigger numerous simultaneous, same-direction orders, resulting in further liquidations, potentially affecting both customers who actively trade during extended hours and those who trade only during traditional hours.

  93. 93

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 10.

  94. 94

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 10.

  95. 95

    24/7 Trading Advisory at 10-11.

  96. 96

    Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC at 38334-35.

  97. 97

    Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC at 38335-36.

  98. 98

    Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC at 38335-36.

  99. 99

    Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC at 38336.

  100. 100

    Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC at 38336.

  101. 101

    Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC at 38336.

  102. 102

    Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC at 38336-37.

  103. 103

    Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC at 38337.

  104. 104

    Perpetuals & 24/7 Trading RFC at 38337.

  105. 105

    See Request for Comment, Commodity Futures Trading Commission, Request for Comment on the Extension of Standard Futures Contracts to 24/7 Trading and on Perpetual Contracts Referencing Physically Delivered or Storable Energy Commodities, 91 Fed. Reg. 47158 (July 28, 2026).

  106. 106

    Id.

  107. 107

    Id.

  108. 108

    NYMEX Stay Order at 1.

  109. 109

    NYMEX Stay Order at 1.

  110. 110

    NYMEX Stay Order at 6.

  111. 111

    NYMEX Stay Order at 7.

  112. 112

    NYMEX Stay Order at 4.

  113. 113

    NYMEX Stay Order at 8.

  114. 114

    NYMEX Stay Order at 8.

  115. 115

    NYMEX Stay Order at 8.

  116. 116

    NYMEX Stay Order at 8-9.

  117. 117

    Relatedly, Kalshi has recently listed perpetuals on precious metals such as gold, platinum, silver, as well as perpetuals on certain broad-based securities indexes, exchange-traded fund shares, and equity securities. See, e.g., KalshiEX LLC, CFTC Regulation 40.2(a) Notification Regarding the Initial Listing of the GOLDPERP Futures Contract (Sept. 8, 2026); KalshiEX LLC, CFTC Regulation 40.3(a), Voluntary submission of new products for Commission review and approval regarding the Initial Listing of the SILVERPERP Futures Contract (July 21, 2026); KalshiEX LLC, Commission Regulations 40.3(a) and 41.23(b), Voluntary submission of new security futures products for Commission review and approval regarding the Initial Listing of Perpetual SFPs on the Underlying Securities Identified in the Schedule of Contracts (Appendix A) (Sept. 18, 2026); KalshiEX LLC, Commission Regulation 40.3(a), Voluntary submission of new products for Commission review and approval regarding the Initial Listing of the US500 Futures Contract (Aug. 18, 2026); see also C. Tolomia, Kalshi Launches Gold and Silver Perpetual Futures with CFTC Approval, Yahoo! Finance (Sept. 10, 2026); S. Rae, Kalshi Files to Bring Perpetual Futures to US Stocks and ETFs, TradingView (Sept. 22, 2026); D. Giangiulio, Kalshi Seeks to Launch ‘Perps’ on Equity Indexes As It Moves in on Traditional Exchanges’ Turf, CNBC (Aug. 18, 2026).

Contact