How market disruption is forcing auto brands to restructure – and what that means under Australia’s Franchising Code

The pressure is building

Australia’s automotive retail sector is at the beginning of a period of profound disruption. A combination of softening consumer demand, rising interest rates, cost-of-living pressures, and the rapid and successful market entry of new Chinese electric vehicle brands is creating extraordinary commercial pressure on established auto manufacturers and importers. The traditional dealership model – built around bricks-and-mortar premises, glamorous showrooms, geographic exclusivity, tied service and spare parts revenue, and long-standing franchisor-dealer relationships – is under sustained challenge.

In response, a number of major auto brands are actively considering – or have already commenced – significant restructuring of their distribution models. This may take a range of forms: rationalising dealer networks, changing the nature of parts distribution arrangements, transitioning to agency models, or withdrawing from segments of the market altogether. Whatever form it takes, any such change will need to engage with a complex and demanding regulatory framework in Australia that many international head offices significantly underestimate.

The rise of the multi-brand mega-dealer businesses has created an additional market dynamic.  Dealers are now actively questioning the sustainability of their current brands and some are even replacing legacy brands with more profitable new brands that offer greater sales margins and increased sales volumes.  As sales decline for legacy brands, the value of the ongoing service and repair activities – traditionally the jewel in the crown for dealers - also reduces.

For any auto brand that has a dealer or distribution network in Australia, the starting point for legal risk assessment is section 45 of the Franchising Code of Conduct (Code). Section 45 is deceptively straightforward in its terms but has broad and far-reaching application. It requires a franchisor to compensate a franchisee where the franchisor terminates a franchise agreement, or decides not to renew it, for the purposes of – among other things – “changing its distribution model”.

The phrase “changing its distribution model” was inserted into the Code following the exit of the Holden brand from the Australian market and is, by design, very broadly worded. It is not limited to structural changes as to how vehicles are sold but can also cover a variation from a total dealership model to agency, to a blended arrangement of dealership and direct distribution.  It applies either at wholesale or retail level, In our view, it could potentially extend to changes in vehicle mix, alteration in spare parts distribution arrangements, conversion of some activities from reseller to agency, or any other significant alteration to the way in which a brand’s products reach consumers. This means that almost any material change to an auto brand’s business model in Australia has the potential to engage section 45. Importantly, it is not relevant why the change occurs – the change could, for example, be as a result of dealer-initiated terminations.

What does section 45 actually require?

Where section 45 is engaged, the franchisor’s obligations are substantial. They include:

  • Compensation for dealers and distributors whose agreements are terminated early, including lost profits (calculated as the NPV of anticipated profits for the balance of the term), unamortised capital expenditure incurred at the franchisor’s direction, loss of the opportunity to sell goodwill, and the costs of winding up operations.
  • A minimum of 12 months’ written notice before the end of the term, together with a written plan for the winding down of operations.
  • A buyback obligation at the end of the term, requiring the franchisor to repurchase vehicles, spare parts and special tools held by the dealer at cost or current market price, whichever is greater.
  • Obligations of good faith throughout the process, requiring the franchisor to act honestly and not arbitrarily in its dealings with dealers, including in negotiations regarding the restructure.

It is important to note that the compensation obligation under section 45 does not apply if the franchise agreement simply runs its full term and is not renewed. This means that careful timing of a restructure – aligning changes with the natural expiry of agreements – can significantly reduce a brand’s financial exposure.

However, in our experience, this should be viewed as a planning tool rather than an escape mechanism. Allowing agreements to simply expire and then presenting dealers with a fundamentally different business model rarely ends well. In recent litigation involving Mercedes dealers, the majority of affected dealers joined a class action, even though the franchisor had waited for agreements to expire before implementing its new model. Although this class action was ultimately unsuccessful1, the potential for impacted dealers to litigate over a restructure should not be discounted (as we discuss below).

The broader regulatory and political landscape

Section 45 of the Code is only one element of the legal framework. Any proposed restructuring of an auto brand’s distribution model in Australia must also have regard to the Australian Consumer Law prohibitions on misleading conduct, unconscionable conduct, unfair contract terms in standard form small business contracts, and taking action based on an unfair contract term.  The penalties for contraventions of the Code and the Australian Consumer Law are severe – $218,400 for breaches of most sections of the Code, and up to the greater of $100 million, 30% of annual turnover, or three times the benefit obtained for many Australian Consumer Law contraventions.  Liability can also extend to individuals, including directors, officers, legal counsel and managers, knowingly concerned in a breach.

If dealers consider they have been adversely impacted, there is a real risk of them taking group action, which is often supported by a media campaign and political activism.  This can prompt ACCC interest and even campaigns for additional legislative protection, as has been the case following both the Holden market exit and the unsuccessful legal action by Mercedes-Benz dealers.  Dealer representative bodies have strongly advocated for a broad prohibition on unfair trading practices in franchising.  As part of the Government’s recent consultation on the design of extending unfair trading practices protections to franchisees and small business, the Australian Automotive Dealer Association submitted that the unfair trading practices prohibition should apply to all franchisees without limitation, and the framework should focus on commercial dependency, rather than business size.

Australia’s level of regulation is now significantly out-of-step with international regulation of the automotive sector.  This presents a particular challenge for local management of international brands.  In our experience, head offices frequently underestimate the complexity of Australia’s regulatory environment, and what they may consider to be a routine distribution restructure can quickly become a legal, political, and media issue. Early and effective communication between Australian management and head office – framed around the specific regulatory obligations and reputational risks in Australia – is essential.

What should auto brands be doing now?

In our view, the first step is awareness. Auto brands considering any change to their distribution models should obtain early legal advice on their specific contractual and regulatory position before any decision is made or communicated. Key steps include:

  • Audit existing dealer and distributor agreements to identify relevant termination rights, notice periods, compensation obligations, and amendment powers.
  • Model the financial exposure under different restructuring scenarios, including early termination (which triggers compensation) and expiry-based transition.
  • Develop a consultative process that engages dealers and their representatives before final decisions are announced – not as a formality, but as a genuine mechanism to understand concerns and explore agreed outcomes.
  • Design and implement a comprehensive change management program that addresses not just legal compliance but also the psychological and reputational dimensions of the transition – including the well-documented human factors that drive resistance to change.
  • Develop a stakeholder communications strategy that addresses dealers, employees, customers, media, regulators, and politicians before any public announcement.

How we can help

We have deep experience advising auto manufacturers, importers, and distributors on distribution restructuring, franchising law, and change management in the Australian market. We have assisted a number of brands to navigate the regulatory and commercial challenges of dealer non-renewal, market exit and distribution model change.

We offer a comprehensive suite of services including risk assessments and legal audits of existing dealer and distributor agreements, financial exposure modelling, change management program design, Franchising Code compliance advice, ACCC engagement strategy, and communications support. We can engage formally or provide an initial informal briefing to help brands understand their position.

Footnotes

  1. 1

    For more details on this decision, see our article here: (Fortunately) no surprises in the Mercedes decision | Australia | Global law firm | Norton Rose Fulbright

Contact