A recent Ontario Court of Appeal (ONCA) decision has provided guidance on when the value of fringe benefits will be awarded as damages following an employee’s wrongful dismissal.1 In Hill, the ONCA overturned a lower court decision that awarded a former employee over $125,000 in damages on account of the employee’s loss of a company vehicle and cell phone.
What are fringe benefits?
A "fringe benefit" is a form of compensation an employer provides to an employee beyond the employee's wages, salary, or other monetary compensation. Common fringe benefits include employer-funded medical and dental insurance, gym memberships or fitness spending accounts, access to vehicles or transportation allowances, company cell phones with allowance for personal use, and so on. In essence, fringe benefits represent the additional quantifiable value employees receive from their employment relationship that is not reflected in their base pay.
When is a fringe benefit compensable as damages?
When employees are wrongfully dismissed (i.e., dismissed without the working notice they are entitled to under contract or at common law) they are entitled to damages representing the compensation they would have received during the notice period. These damages may include the value of fringe benefits that formed part of their overall compensation package.
However, not all work-related privileges or items (e.g., access to a car or a cell phone) are compensable fringe benefits. The key question is whether the item confers a genuine personal advantage on the employee or is merely a tool of the trade provided to enable job performance. Where an item provides a genuine personal advantage, its value is more likely to form part of the dismissed employee's reasonable notice damages. Conversely, where the item is primarily provided to enable employees to perform their duties, courts have generally concluded that no compensation is owed during the notice period. Note that occasional or emergency personal use of a business-related item does not convert it into a compensable personal benefit.
The onus is on the employee to establish entitlement to damages for loss of fringe benefits. For example, in Hill the court considered the following factors in determining that Mr. Hill failed to prove the company vehicle was a personal benefit entitling him to damages for loss:2
- Benefit claim: Mr. Hill did not include a claim for damages for loss of the vehicle in his statement of claim.
- T4 reporting: Mr. Hill’s T4s did not list the vehicle as a personal benefit.
- Tax disclosure: Mr. Hill did not report the vehicle to the CRA as a personal benefit.3
- Alternatives: There was no evidence that Mr. Hill used the vehicle for personal transportation or he lacked alternative transportation.
- Replacement costs: There was no evidence that Mr. Hill had incurred the expense of leasing a replacement vehicle.
Mr. Hill likewise failed to prove entitlement to damages for loss of a company cell phone. There was no evidence that the cell phone was intended for anything other than employment use.
Takeaway for employers
Fringe benefits are a valuable form of compensation employers can use to attract and retain employees. However, they may also represent an additional liability upon termination of employment. To minimize risk of damages awards for fringe benefits, employers may:
- Establish workplace policies that stipulate a tool or allowance is not meant for personal use or benefit (e.g., a company car is meant only for business use). The employer must also ensure employees do not begin to treat a tool or allowance as a personal benefit in practice.
- Draft fringe benefit policies and agreements to stipulate employees will have no right to damages for loss of those benefits upon termination beyond any applicable statutory notice period.
- Contractually limit an employee’s termination notice period, as low as statutory minimums, such that any period over which damages are calculated is brief.
In designing fringe benefits employers must also ensure compliance with applicable tax law. Employers may be required to deduct and remit applicable income tax, make Employment Insurance contributions, or Canada Pension Plan contributions in relation to fringe benefits.
The author would like to thank Éadaoin O'Gorman, articling student, for her contribution in preparing this legal update.
Footnotes
-
Hill v. 1359768 Ontario Inc. (B&B Towing), 2026 ONCA 577, at para. 53
-
It is important to note that fringe benefits are generally considered taxable income under the Income Tax Act and must be reported accordingly. That said, how the parties characterize a particular benefit does not necessarily determine whether the Canada Revenue Agency will treat it as taxable.