In Oceanus Capital SARL v Lloyd’s Insurance Company S.A. (M/V “Vyssos”) [2026] EWCA Civ 863, the Court of Appeal unanimously dismissed Lloyd’s Insurance Company S.A.’s (“Lloyd’s”) appeal, upholding the first instance decision in favour of Oceanus Capital SARL (“Oceanus”) and confirming its entitlement to recover US$3.6 million under its Mortgagees’ Interest Insurance (“MII”) policy.
This is understood to be the first appellate consideration of the standard London MII wording, and the decision is of significant importance to ship financiers and MII underwriters across the London market.
This article is a follow-up to our earlier piece on the first instance decision and analyses what the Court of Appeal decided on each ground of appeal.
Background
The Vyssos was a cargo ship which was damaged by a mine strike in Ukrainian waters in December 2023 and became a constructive total loss. Oceanus, who had a mortgage interest secured over the vessel as part of a financing arrangement with the owner, sought to recover under the owner’s marine war risks policy which was also assigned to it as part of the security package. However, the war risks policy did not respond as a result of a breach of the underlying trading warranties that required additional cover to be obtained before voyaging to Ukrainian waters. Oceanus had consented to the voyage under the false impression that such additional cover had been obtained, having been provided with a forged additional cover note.
Oceanus subsequently sought to claim under its MII policy with Lloyd’s (a breach of the trading warranties in the war risks policy was an "insured peril" under the MII Policy). Lloyd’s declined the claim, arguing in part that the forged insurance cover was not a risk assumed under the MII policy.
Oceanus’ claim against Lloyd’s was successful at first instance. Lloyd’s appealed, and the Court of Appeal was therefore asked to determine the three issues summarised below.
For more information on the background and the first instance decision, please see here.
Lloyd’s grounds of appeal
On appeal, Lloyd’s advanced three grounds:
- Proximate cause: the proximate cause of Oceanus’ loss was the forgery of the additional cover note, not the failure of the war risks policy to respond as a result of an insured peril under the MII policy;
- Privity: Oceanus was privy to the breach of the trading warranties (having known of and consented to the voyage to Ukraine) and so the claim was excluded under the terms of the policy; and
- Fortuity: the loss was not fortuitous because Oceanus chose to let the vessel sail to Ukraine knowing the war risks policy would not respond if there was damage to the ship, making non-payment an inevitable consequence of its own voluntary choice.
The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal on all three grounds.
The Court of Appeal’s reasoning
Ground 1: Proximate cause
The Court of Appeal agreed that the loss must be proximately caused by an insured peril, but rejected the argument that the reason the war risks policy failed was because the additional cover was a fraudulent nullity. A forged document is not capable of creating a policy nor operating as a cause for a party’s loss, for the mere fact that it simply does not exist. As a result, the forged additional cover could not have been the proximate cause of Oceanus’ loss.
In addition, the Court held that whether MII cover responds to a claim is an objective question about what caused the loss, taking into account what is covered under the policy and whether the relevant conditions are satisfied. The mortgagee’s subjective (and mistaken) belief with regards to the state of cover was therefore irrelevant. On the first instance judge’s findings of the facts, the vessel would have sailed to Ukraine even if no forgery had been produced and Oceanus had objected. The casualty and loss would therefore have occurred just the same and so the deception was not causative to Oceanus’ loss. The court agreed with Oceanus that it would be “curious and uncommercial” if Oceanus was worse off by having been positively deceived by the owners than if they had just been kept in the dark about the voyage to Ukrainian waters.
Ground 2: Privity
The Court of Appeal also accepted Oceanus’ argument that its consent to the vessel’s voyage was vitiated by the fraud practised upon it. In reaching this conclusion, the Court applied the “fraud vitiates consent” doctrine, drawing on previous authorities.
The Court held that fraud does not negate the fact of consent, but it can negate the legal consequences that would otherwise flow from it, provided that the fraud is sufficiently connected to the subject matter of the consent. Here, the forged cover note led Oceanus to believe that adequate alternative cover was in place, such that the war risks policy would respond and would not be relevant to a claim under the MII policy. The Court found this to be sufficient to invalidate the apparent consent that Oceanus provided.
By contrast, the Court noted that hypothetical deceptions would not vitiate consent (for example, a lie about vessel speed or an intention to spoof satellite tracking) and would merely be collateral to the question of whether the MII policy responded.
Ground 3: Fortuity
The Court of Appeal rejected the Appellant’s fortuity argument for two reasons.
First, the Court found that where there are a number of insured perils which must act together to bring about the insured loss (here being the loss or damage to the ship, which appears to be covered by the owner’s policies, but which did not respond), fortuity in any one of those elements would be sufficient to render the overall loss fortuitous. Here, the Court held that the loss of the vessel due to a mine strike satisfied the fortuity element, given that it occurred as a matter of pure chance and was not an inevitability.
Second, since Oceanus’ consent was vitiated by fraud (as found on Ground 2), its “choice” to allow the voyage could not be treated as a genuine voluntary election capable of defeating the requirement of fortuity.
Key Takeaways
The decision underpins important considerations for ship financiers and marine insurers alike:
-
A forged policy is no policy at all
In construing the wording of the MII policy, the Court confirmed that MII cover responds to physical loss caused by an insured peril, irrespective of what the mortgagee subjectively believed about the state of cover. Importantly, the wording in standard London MII refers to policies actually in existence, which a forged cover note is not, and such a document could not therefore be the cause of a mortgagee’s loss. For ship financiers, the decision confirms the importance of obtaining MII policy as a separate layer of protection within the security package, independent of the integrity of the owners’ own insurance arrangements.
-
Fraud vitiates consent for privity purposes
The Court’s decision that fraud could vitiate consent and negate privity provides an important safeguard for mortgagees, especially in light of the realities of shipping finance whereby the mortgagee rarely has oversight or input in vessel management or operations. Nonetheless, where a borrower’s conduct raises concerns about the validity of insurance cover, mortgagees should actively protest and document their objections contemporaneously, so as to establish that any apparent consent to the vessel’s trading activities was conditional upon compliance with the underlying insurance policies.
-
Fortuity
Finally, MII underwriters should note that the scope for defeating a claim on fortuity grounds is narrow where the underlying physical loss was itself accidental. Moreover, as was the case in this instance, where there are a number of contingencies in respect of a loss, the fortuity principle would only act in the underwriter’s favour where all elements were inevitable.
With thanks to Humza Nadeem for his assistance in preparing this post.