Global Horizon Scanner

Legal privilege in cross-border investigations has come under fresh scrutiny in recent cases, particularly in relation to documents created in internal investigations and where AI tools are used.

Recent decisions in the US, UK, Australia, Canada, the Netherlands and Germany (as set out below) highlight divergences in privilege laws, but have common themes, namely: (i) document the purpose of the investigation at the outset; (ii) restrict who receives investigative material (and take great care in the use of AI tools); and (iii) do not assume that involving lawyers in a communication or marking it as privileged will, by itself, preserve privilege.

Taken together, these cases show the importance of understanding relevant jurisdictions’ privilege laws from the outset of an investigation and putting in place tailored controls to protect privilege.

US

AI tools: public platforms may be treated as third parties

In United States v. Heppner, a New York federal court held that a criminal defendant’s prompts to and outputs from a public generative AI tool were not protected by attorney-client privilege nor work-product protection. The court treated the AI system as neither the attorney nor the attorney’s agent and viewed use of a public platform (with terms permitting data collection, model training and potential government access) as a third-party disclosure. It also found that the defendant’s self-directed use was not for the purpose of obtaining legal advice.

By contrast, in Warner v. Gilbarco, Inc., a Michigan federal court denied a motion to compel AI-assisted materials prepared by a pro se litigant, treating generative AI as a tool rather than a person and holding that its use did not waive work-product protection in civil litigation. The court did not address the platform’s privacy policies. The cases are difficult to reconcile: AI may be treated as a tool in one setting and as a non-privileged third party in another. See our more detailed article on these two cases here.

Investigation scope / purpose and selective disclosure

On 3 October 2025, the Sixth Circuit in the case of In re FirstEnergy Corporation reaffirmed that privilege turns on whether an internal investigation was intended to facilitate legal advice, not on whether the advice was later used to inform business decisions. It also held that work-product protection can apply to materials prepared in anticipation of litigation despite concurrent employment and business concerns.

The court rejected the argument that FirstEnergy had waived privilege over the investigation materials by disclosing part of the investigation materials to enforcement authorities and the company’s independent auditor. It reasoned that the disclosed material was largely non-privileged and that the auditor was not an adversary.

Practical takeaways

The practical lessons learned from the above cases are that for US-linked investigations, lawyers should (i) direct and document any AI-assisted work; (ii) confirm that the provider does not use client data for training or permit external access; (iii) restrict prompts, outputs and investigation files to the appropriate legal team; and (iv) be mindful of how investigations and investigation reports are structured and documented. In respect of (iv) this can be through documenting the intended legal purpose of the materials / report and assessing the risk of waiver before sharing any investigation material.

Canada

Privilege at the point of seizure

Various privileges in Canada protect those subject to regulatory and criminal investigations. Similar to the position under UK law, the two most important are: (i) solicitor-client privilege, which is near absolute under Canadian law and protects communications and documents exchanged in the context of obtaining legal advice; and (ii) litigation privilege, which casts a broad net of protection over communications directly relating to reasonably anticipated or ongoing litigation or prosecution.

Regulators and law enforcement agencies are strictly bound by the rules of privilege and are not empowered to require the disclosure of privileged documents or to access or review privileged documents seized during the execution of a search warrant.

In the May 2025 decision in Lamarche v. British Columbia (Securities Commission), a regulator was exposed to civil liability for breach of privacy rights, stemming from the regulator’s seizure of privileged email records.

In a separate case relating to an investigation conducted by the Competition Bureau, the strict application of privilege to communications between cooperating witnesses in a bid-rigging investigation and their counsel led to an unfavourable outcome for the defendants in a related criminal case. In normal circumstances, information provided to the Competition Bureau after a certain investigative stage must be disclosed to the accused pursuant to the Crown’s disclosure obligations. However, because of the way in which the investigation was conducted (including a failure to take any of the Vetrovec precautions with respect to the cooperating witnesses, either during the proffer stage or its subsequent investigation, and the use of witnesses’ counsel as intermediaries), information and records that normally would have been in the regulator’s hands (that is, not ordinarily privileged) remained in the hands of the counsel for the cooperating witnesses (including counsel’s notes of the witnesses’ first statements to the regulator on the facts of the case). The court prohibited disclosure of key investigative materials to the defendants, despite these being materials that would normally be required to be disclosed by the prosecution. Ultimately, the court took a broad view of protections afforded by legal privilege, stating that the “obvious unfairness to the defendants” simply was not enough to abrogate “an essential legal privilege”.

The practical implications in-house counsel should consider in the event of any search, seizure and review process by authorities is to (i) establish a privilege protocol before an external investigation begins; (ii) identify Canadian counsel early; (iii) segregate privileged material; (iv) maintain a clear privilege log; and (v) resolve claims to privilege before any production to the authority.

UK

Recent UK developments address three linked questions: (i) who may inspect corporate legal advice; (ii) what happens when confidential material is uploaded to AI; and (iii) which intra-client documents can attract legal advice privilege.

August 2025: the shareholder rule is abolished

In Jardine Strategic Ltd v Oasis Investments II Master Fund Ltd & Ors (No 2) [2025] UKPC 34, the Privy Council abolished the shareholder rule, which had prevented a company in litigation with its shareholders from withholding legal advice from inspection. Though Privy Council decisions are not technically binding in England and Wales, the reasoning is likely to be highly persuasive. The decision may offer greater protection for advice received by directors during internal investigations, subject to the ordinary limits and exceptions to privilege. In-house teams should nevertheless confirm the governing law and dispute resolution forum applicable to the company’s relationship with the adverse shareholder (for example, taking into account any articles of association, shareholder agreement etc.) before relying on the protection that it is entitled to withhold legal advice from that adverse shareholder. The practical implications of this decision are not just limited to cases where a shareholder seeks advice obtained by the company in relation to an investigation - it may also be relevant whenever an adverse shareholder seeks access to privileged company communications in the context of litigation, pre-action disputes, or other contentious shareholder-company interactions.

November 2025: open-source AI uploads and waiver

The Upper Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber) held that uploading confidential material to an open-source AI tool such as ChatGPT breaches confidentiality and waives legal professional privilege, while distinguishing closed-source tools, where confidentiality is not breached. The key message is clear: do not put privileged material into a public or open tool, and verify the confidentiality, retention, training and access terms of any enterprise product before use. Our team’s more detailed briefing is available here.

April 2026: a developing position on intra-client documents

In April 2026, the High Court held at first instance that documents created by or between members of the authorised “client group” may attract legal advice privilege where their dominant purpose is to seek legal advice. That is potentially broader than the previous position, under which intra-client documents were protected only if they disclosed the substance of an otherwise privileged lawyer-client communication. The decision is not binding on higher courts, but it may affect how investigation teams collect facts and record instructions where litigation privilege is unavailable. However, there are a couple of points of caution. First, the decision does not alter the narrow definition of who falls within the "client group", which remains governed by Three Rivers (No 5). Second, the dominant purpose test continues to apply, and documents created for mixed purposes may not qualify. It is therefore prudent for companies to continue to limit the scope of dissemination of the privileged legal advice; and ensure that it is clearly documented that the dominant purpose of the document is to seek, obtain or facilitate legal advice. Where an investigation generates documents for mixed purposes, clients should maintain distinct workstreams and clearly delineate which documents are created for the dominant purpose of legal advice and which are not. Please see our article here for more details.

Practical takeaways

For UK-linked investigations, we advise clients to (i) define the client group at the outset (and keep this as tight as possible); (ii) keep factual collection and legal advice within that client group where possible; and (iii) treat the use of AI tools and shareholder access to advice as separate waiver or inspection risks.

Netherlands

Tax proceedings and subsequent criminal cases

In March 2025, the Dutch Supreme Court held that submitting privileged documents in tax proceedings does not, by itself, waive privilege in subsequent criminal proceedings. However, if the tax court reproduces the information in a public judgment, the reproduced content is no longer confidential. In-house counsel should seek protective treatment for privileged material and review proposed filings and judgments carefully as publication may make confidentiality impossible to maintain.

Australia

Dominant purpose: the legal ‘wrapper’ is not enough

Recent Federal Court decisions show that a report commissioned through lawyers during a cyber incident or other crisis may still be non-privileged if its dominant purpose is regulatory, governance, public assurance or operational rather than legal. Under Australian common law, privilege attaches to confidential communications made for the dominant purpose of obtaining legal advice or use in existing or anticipated litigation. “Dominant purpose” means the ruling or most influential purpose, assessed objectively on the totality of the evidence.

In the Medibank class action arising from a cyber incident, the primary judge found Deloitte’s post-incident review, root-cause analysis and Australian Prudential Regulatory Authority (APRA) report non-privileged because Medibank also intended to learn from the incident, meet regulatory obligations and share the results. Cybersecurity reports were privileged because their dominant purpose was to provide technical assistance to Medibank’s lawyers. In Medibank Private Limited v McClure [2026] FCAFC 38, the Full Court refused leave to appeal.

As in FirstEnergy, the court looked to the function of the material rather than the label or the later use.

Practical takeaway

Before commissioning work, define the legal deliverable and separate it from compliance, operational, regulatory and public-assurance outputs. It is important to use distinct scopes, teams and distribution lists where possible; document the purpose contemporaneously; and ensure public statements do not describe the same report as a general business or governance product.

Germany

Professional secrecy is narrower and context-specific

German law is based on professional secrecy (berufsrechtliche Verschwiegenheit) and statutory limits on seizure, including Sections 97 and 110 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Strafprozessordnung, StPO). It does not provide a general common-law style legal professional privilege. Protection often depends on the procedural setting and whether the lawyer acts as defence counsel or in a defence-equivalent role; documents held by the client or a third party may be more vulnerable to seizure than documents held by the lawyer.

In July 2025, the German Federal Constitutional Court reiterated that searches of law firms are exceptional and subject to strict proportionality because they may expose information belonging to uninvolved clients. The decision also confirmed that documents may still be reviewed under applicable procedural safeguards.

The position in relation to use of AI remains uncertain

German and EU law do not yet provide settled guidance on whether professional secrecy or legal professional privilege survives the use of generative AI. The German Federal Bar Association’s December 2024 guidance warns that non-confidential AI tools may compromise secrecy. For a German-linked investigation, use tools that preserve control over client information and avoid unauthorised disclosure; involve German counsel before storing or processing investigative material outside the defence team.

Conclusion

In light of the above decisions, for a cross-border investigation, it is important to start with a jurisdiction map and a written privilege plan and to (i) identify the client group and legal purpose; (ii) separate legal advice and work product from public-facing outputs; (iii) use legal counsel-directed AI in controlled environments; (iv) restrict access and sharing; and (v) obtain local advice before searches, tax filings, regulator production or public disclosure. The aim is not to force one jurisdiction’s rules on privilege onto another, but to build a process that takes account of the strictest relevant privilege regime.

Contact