On 18 May 2026, HM Treasury (HMT) published its long-anticipated policy statement on reform of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 (CCA 1974), confirming its intention to repeal many of the remaining CCA 1974 provisions and much of the associated secondary legislation. The policy statement responds to the Phase 1 consultation published in May 2025 and, notably, also addresses the remaining CCA 1974 provisions that had been earmarked for a Phase 2 consultation, which HMT has now decided not to proceed with as a separate exercise.
The reforms signal a decisive shift away from a prescriptive, statute-based regime towards a more flexible, outcomes-focused framework under Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) rules, underpinned by the Consumer Duty. However, certain complex provisions, including connected lender liability (sections 75 and 75A) and unfair relationships (sections 140A–C), will remain untouched for the time being pending further policy work.
The reforms will be delivered through the Financial Services and Markets Bill, which was introduced to the House of Lords on 19 May 2026. In this briefing note, we examine the key elements of HMT's policy statement, the FCA's response, and the practical implications for firms operating in the consumer credit market.
HMT confirms the shift from statute to FCA rules
Consumer credit has long played a key role in the UK’s financial services landscape. When brought into force, the CCA 1974 was a significant piece of legislation that introduced important consumer protections and replaced what had arguably been a fragmented regime. From that point, the Office of Fair Trading (OFT) was responsible for overseeing this market and had some limited supervisory and enforcement powers. In 2014 there was another big shift in regulation when responsibility for consumer credit was transferred to the FCA under the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 (FSMA 2000), resulting in the current regime governed by both FCA and CCA 1974 derived rules. The current work by HMT is intended to build on that initial approach by transferring further regulatory power from legislation to the regulator, with the aim of introducing a more agile regime. This was first set out in a consultation in 2022 and was underpinned by five principles: that the regime should be proportionate, aligned, forward-looking, deliverable, and simplified.
In May 2025, HMT published its Phase 1 consultation, which addressed the overall approach to reform and set out detailed proposals in relation to information requirements, sanctions, and criminal offences. Crucially, HMT’s now published policy statement confirms the intention to repeal many of the remaining CCA 1974 provisions and much of the associated secondary legislation, on the basis that they are no longer appropriate in light of technological change and wider regulatory developments. This will have major implications for firms.
High profile remediation exercises associated with potential non-compliance with certain statutory requirements relating to post-contractual information – where customer harm was challenging to identify in practice – have been viewed as inconsistent with the prevailing regulatory framework for consumer finance beyond the CCA 1974, which focuses on identifying, preventing and remediating customer harm where it has occurred. These ‘sanctions’ provisions have been a core area for reform, and have contributed to questions around UK competitiveness when they give rise to systemic remediation exercises.
Where CCA 1974 provisions are repealed, some will fall away entirely whilst others will be recast into FCA rules. That said, HMT has been clear that the objective is not for the FCA to replicate the CCA 1974 provisions. Rather, the intention is that the FCA will determine what requirements are appropriate, having regard to its statutory objectives, powers under FSMA 2000, and existing rules, including the Consumer Duty. However, it is important to also note that there are certain provisions that will be retained in legislation, in particular where they are complex and require further policy work or create third-party rights and obligations that cannot readily be recast into FCA rules, and so some aspects of the existing CCA 1974 regime will remain.
The FCA published its own short statement alongside HMT’s policy statement, setting out that it considers HMT’s paper to be an important step towards a more flexible regime by placing greater emphasis on FCA rules and guidance than prescriptive legislative requirements. Importantly, the FCA intends to consult on its approach to those elements of the framework previously set out in legislation and so, arguably, the true extent of the shift will ultimately be determined by how far the FCA goes in terms of revising the requirements that applied under the previous approach when setting out their expectations.
Ultimately, it does appear that these reforms represent the potential for a decisive shift towards a modernised and flexible consumer credit regime, built on outcomes-based principles rather than prescriptive legislation, and aligned with the wider shift to an increasingly regulator-led UK model of financial services.
From prescribed notices to consumer understanding: The new disclosure agenda for consumer credit
In short, it is intended that the majority of information disclosure requirements in the CCA 1974 and accompanying secondary legislation will be repealed and recast into FCA rules, subject to FCA consultation on those replacement requirements. These requirements span the full consumer credit journey, encompassing pre-contractual disclosures (such as the Pre-Contract Credit Information document (PCCI) and credit agreements), post-contractual communications (including statements and copies of agreements), and arrears, default and forbearance notifications (such as arrears and default notices). Moving these requirements into the FCA Handbook is intended, in line with the broader principles of this reform, to enable less prescriptive and more flexible regulation to enable the use of developing technology, and better consumer outcomes aligned with the Consumer Duty. In addition, and in line with the broader policy, future regulatory changes will be quicker to bring in, as they will not require legislative change, allowing the FCA to be able to respond more effectively to developments and changes in the market.
HMT has explained that their approach was underpinned by three key considerations. First, statutory disclosures under the CCA 1974 are often overly prescriptive, whereas FCA's rules and the Consumer Duty principle offer a more flexible, outcomes-focused approach that is better suited to supporting informed consumer decisions. Second, the existing regime creates barriers to innovation, with rigid formats and outdated requirements limiting firms' ability to utilise digital technology in consumer journeys. Third, the dual regulatory framework is complex, increasing compliance burdens and creating legal uncertainty.
End of automatic unenforceability?
HMT consulted on whether the FCA regime alone—without the automatic sanctions currently set out in the CCA 1974—would provide sufficient consumer protection. Under the CCA 1974, breaching certain information requirements can trigger sanctions that render a credit agreement unenforceable. A lender may also lose the right to charge interest and default sums for the period during which it remains non-compliant. HMT took the view that these sanctions are disproportionate, particularly in light of the FCA's existing supervisory and enforcement powers.
While some consumer groups expressed concern that removing CCA 1974 sanctions would eliminate a crucial, self-policing deterrent and questioned whether the FCA regime, including the Consumer Duty, would consistently deliver robust outcomes, a clear theme in industry responses was that CCA 1974 sanctions were often disproportionate, triggered by technical non-compliance without evidence of harm.
HMT considered that several elements of the current regime essentially undermined the effectiveness of any deterrent. In particular, HMT highlighted that the meaning of unenforceability, and what constitutes enforcement action taken under a credit agreement by a firm, is complex and often unclear, as it is not defined in the legislation. As a result, a concern has been that differing views and interpretations exist over the steps firms may take if credit agreements are unenforceable, such as whether a lender can chase for payments, and consumers are often confused about what unenforceability means for them in practice, including their obligation to repay, the amount to be repaid, and the impact on their credit file.
HMT further noted that the regulatory landscape has changed considerably since the sanctions were introduced. As mentioned above, the OFT's supervisory and enforcement powers were much more limited than the FCA's, and consumers lacked access to the Financial Ombudsman Service (FOS) until 2007.
HMT therefore confirmed that it will repeal the CCA 1974 provisions on automatic sanctions. More specifically, as sanctions attach to certain information disclosure requirements, they will fall away with the repeal of those requirements as discussed above. Overall, HMT considers that removing the sanctions regime will bring the regulation of consumer credit into line with the approach taken in relation to other financial services sectors and will also mean that firms’ liability for redress in the event of any wrongdoing is more commensurate with the level of consumer harm.
Not all CCA 1974 teeth are being pulled
That said, HMT has ultimately taken a different approach to criminal offences currently set out in the CCA 1974. The HMT consultation set out three options for reforming those offences: repealing all CCA 1974 criminal offences and instead relying on the FCA to take enforcement action where possible under its existing supervisory and regulatory powers; retaining all criminal offences in their current form; or a hybrid approach, under which all criminal offences would be repealed save for those relating to the protection of minors and the canvassing of credit off trade premises, with the FCA assuming enforcement responsibility in respect of all other matters.
HMT acknowledged the breadth of views expressed and confirmed its commitment to ensuring that any reform of the CCA 1974 maintains robust consumer protection and that criminal offences, in particular, are an important deterrent. As a result, despite the Ministry of Justice's general policy that unnecessary offences should be repealed where they are no longer needed, HMT nevertheless concluded that the relevant criminal offences continue to fulfil a vital protective function, particularly those deterring the promotion of credit to minors and unsolicited doorstep selling of credit products.
In contrast to the approach taken to automatic sanctions, HMT has confirmed it will retain the criminal offences in the CCA 1974. As discussed further below, this illustrates that HMT still acknowledges the importance in some contexts of prescriptive legislative requirements and its view that not all risks arising from financial services will necessarily be suitable for being addressed solely through FCA rules, guidance, and supervisory and enforcement powers.
Repeal, recast or retain
HMT proposes that CCA 1974 provisions not covered by its earlier Phase 1 consultation should fall into one of two categories: (1) provisions to be repealed and, where appropriate, recast into FCA rules (subject to consultation); and (2) provisions to be retained in legislation (subject to any necessary amendments). Annex A of the policy statement contains the full provision-by-provision list showing HMT’s proposed treatment of each section of the CCA 1974. A condensed version of is set out below.
Provisions to be repealed |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Retained provisions |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Provisions to be retained and potentially amended |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
The governing principle is that important rights and protections which need to remain in legislation will be retained, while those that can be delivered "more clearly, proportionately and flexibly" through FCA rules will be repealed from the statute and recast into the FCA Handbook where appropriate and subject to consultation. Where provisions are no longer required at all — because the market has moved on or because other regulatory mechanisms already achieve the same outcome — they will fall away on repeal without being recast. Critically, where provisions are being repealed and recast in FCA rules, HMT commits that it will only commence the repeal once the relevant FCA rules are in place, with implementation dates aligned so that no gaps arise in the transition from the old regime to the new.
The decision on which category a provision falls into is not solely a matter of consumer-protection but it also turns on what the FCA can lawfully do under the FSMA 2000 framework. HMT acknowledges an important limitation in the sense that FCA rules can only apply to authorised persons and must advance the FCA's statutory objectives. Where a CCA 1974 provision creates third-party rights or obligations — for example, rights exercisable against a supplier or a connected lender who may not themselves be an FCA-authorised firm — the provision cannot simply be replicated as an FCA rule and must instead be retained in legislation.
For complex provisions requiring further policy work, HMT has decided to leave these unchanged for the moment. This pragmatic approach reflects the fact that some CCA 1974 provisions interact in ways that make partial reform risky without a comprehensive redesign, and that stakeholder engagement to date has not produced sufficient consensus on the appropriate replacement mechanism. These complex provisions will therefore continue to operate within the CCA 1974 framework while HMT develops further proposals.
The big-ticket CCA 1974 rights are parked
For complex provisions requiring further policy work, HMT has decided to leave these unchanged for the time being. This category expressly includes antecedent negotiations under section 56, connected lender liability under sections 75 and 75A, and the unfair relationships regime under sections 140A–140C. HMT describes these as highly technical provisions underpinned by a considerable body of case law and established market practice, for which more detailed policy work is required. These complex provisions will therefore continue to operate within the CCA 1974 framework while HMT develops further proposals.
As for other sections of the CCA 1974 which are central to the functioning of these complex provisions, these too are not being amended for the moment. For instance, section 12 (regarding debtor-creditor-supplier agreements), which is particularly important for the operation of section 56 (antecedent negotiations) and section 75 (connected lender liability), is being retained in its current form. Any amendment to it will be considered alongside the future work on sections 56 and 75.
Another factor likely to have informed HMT’s decision not to amend these provisions at this stage is the concern, raised by a number of consumer groups, that there is a tension between the Government's support for green finance initiatives—such as subsidised loans and credit arrangements for home energy efficiency improvements—and the statutory protections afforded by sections 56, 75 and 75A of the CCA 1974. These consumer groups argue that reforms intended to promote green finance could inadvertently weaken consumer protection, given that the existing CCA 1974 provisions are widely perceived as essential to maintaining consumer confidence in green credit products.
Mind the transition
There is an overarching recognition throughout the policy statement that moving towards the new regime is likely to be disruptive for firms, consumers, and intermediaries alike. For this reason, transitional provisions will play a key role in the reform process: the stated objectives of these provisions are to avoid legal uncertainty, minimize operational costs, and ensure that consumers do not experience detriment as a result of the changeover. The exact length of the transitional periods will be determined by HMT, but they are designed to reflect the significant scale of change needed by firms and consumer groups across a range of consumer credit and hire products, including: secured and unsecured lending; running-account credit; and hire-purchase agreements.
For firms, the following key principles for transition periods will be welcomed:
- Extended implementation periods — allowing firms sufficient time to update systems, processes, and documentation before the new rules take full effect.
- Continued use of existing documentation during migration — so that agreements entered into under the current regime remain valid and enforceable without the need for immediate re-papering.
- Safe harbour or regulatory forbearance — providing a degree of protection for firms where minor inconsistencies arise whilst the changes are being embedded, provided those firms are taking reasonable steps towards compliance.
- A clear cut-off date — beyond which the new regime applies in full, reducing the scope for confusion as to which framework governs a given agreement or transaction.
The policy statement also acknowledges broad agreement on the need for strong safeguards to mitigate the risk of consumer detriment during the transition. These safeguards are to be supported by clear public timelines so that all market participants can plan accordingly; grandfathering and back-book protections to preserve the rights of consumers with existing agreements; and prominent communication campaigns directed at both firms and consumers to ensure awareness of the changes and any action required.
Notwithstanding these commitments, a number of material questions remain open. The precise duration of each transitional period has yet to be confirmed, and it is not yet clear whether different product types or firm categories will be subject to differentiated timetables. Similarly, the scope of any regulatory forbearance—including the threshold for what constitutes a "minor" inconsistency—will require further elaboration, most likely through FCA rules or guidance.
Innovation, inclusion and product design
Innovation, inclusion and product design are recurring policy drivers throughout HMT's approach to CCA 1974 reform. The policy statement frames the existing legislation as a barrier to all three: its prescriptive, paper-era requirements constrain how firms design products, communicate with consumers, and respond to technological change. HMT's stated intention is to replace that rigidity with a regulatory architecture capable of keeping pace with evolving credit markets, digital customer journeys, and new product types.
On innovation, HMT's central proposition is that transferring detailed conduct requirements from statute to FCA rules will remove obstacles to firms developing and delivering credit products suited to a digital economy. The CCA 1974 fixed-form information disclosure obligations, for example, were designed for an era of posted letters and branch-based lending; they sit awkwardly alongside app-based credit journeys and real-time decision-making. By repealing these requirements and empowering the FCA to set technology-neutral, outcomes-focused rules, HMT expects firms to innovate in how they present information, design repayment structures, and tailor products to individual consumer circumstances.
Inclusion is treated as both a justification for reform and a risk to be managed. HMT argues that an agile, FCA-led regime can better support consumers who have historically been underserved — for instance by enabling firms to tailor communications to consumers with lower literacy, limited English, or reduced digital capability. At the same time, the policy statement acknowledges consultation respondents' concerns that digitally excluded consumers could be disadvantaged by the shift away from statutory protections. HMT's response is that the FCA's Consumer Duty, the FOS, and FCA supervisory and enforcement powers together provide adequate safeguards for vulnerable and protected groups. Separately, HMT's Financial Inclusion Strategy recognises that 1.6 million people in the UK are largely offline and millions more lack the access, skills, or confidence to engage digitally, and commits to working with DSIT on its Digital Inclusion Action Plan in parallel with CCA 1974 reform.
Product design sits at the intersection of these two themes. HMT expects consumer credit firms to tailor products and consumer journeys in line with the Consumer Duty, with the FCA highlighting good practice where firms have used data to identify consumers in vulnerable circumstances experiencing worse outcomes and have improved the clarity and timeliness of communications accordingly. The reformed regime is intended to give firms the flexibility to design products — from buy-now-pay-later (BNPL) to open-ended running-account credit — without being constrained by statutory categories and form requirements that no longer reflect how consumers borrow or how lenders operate.
Broader reforms
Importantly, the CCA 1974 reforms in HMT’s policy statement do not sit in isolation. They form part of a broader reconfiguration of the UK’s retail finance regulatory perimeter that HMT has been pursuing across several workstreams, with BNPL, credit broking, business lending and the scope of regulated credit all remaining actively in play.
The regulation of BNPL — now formally termed deferred payment credit (DPC) in the legislation — is the most prominent perimeter expansion running alongside CCA 1974 reform. HMT brought BNPL within the FCA's regulated activities framework through the FSMA 2000 (Regulated Activities etc.) (Amendment) Order 2025, laid in Parliament in May 2025. Under this regime, which came into force on 15 July 2026, BNPL providers must obtain FCA authorisation, carry out proportionate affordability assessments, provide clear pre-contractual information, and support consumers in financial difficulty. Consumers will also gain access to the FOS for the first time when using these products. CCA 1974 information disclosure requirements have been disapplied for DPC agreements so that the FCA can consult on bespoke rules tailored to the online settings in which these products are predominantly used — a design choice that anticipates the broader direction of CCA 1974 reform.
The credit broking perimeter has required particular attention as a consequence of BNPL regulation. When a merchant offers a consumer the option to pay via a third-party BNPL lender, that merchant is engaging in credit broking — a regulated activity requiring FCA authorisation unless there is an available carve out. The scale of this issue is considerable: the FCA reported approximately 7,095 firms with credit broking permissions only, and many more unregulated retailers and online marketplaces may be drawn into the perimeter for the first time. HMT recognised the risk that the new BNPL regime could inadvertently impose disproportionate regulatory burdens on businesses that simply offer BNPL as a payment option. In June 2025 it published a policy update confirming that domestic premises suppliers — such as tradespeople and home service providers — would not be required to hold credit broking permissions to offer BNPL products, using a negative statutory instrument. The policy statement also signals further work on credit broking as a next step in the CCA 1974 reform programme.
Business lending is a further perimeter question that HMT has flagged alongside CCA 1974 reform. At present, whether a loan to an SME is regulated depends on a combination of factors including the identity of the borrower, the value of the loan and its purpose; lending above £25,000 for business purposes to corporates falls outside the consumer credit perimeter altogether. Industry stakeholders have called for clarity on the regulatory boundary for business lending, and the FCA has noted that the Government is exploring this issue as part of its CCA 1974 reform programme. HMT continues to consider whether and how to extend or adjust the regulatory perimeter for business lending. The Financial Inclusion Strategy has also signalled interest in widening credit broking exemptions beyond registered social landlords to other organisations supporting consumers with their finances. Taken together, these developments confirm that the scope and definitions questions originally earmarked for a Phase 2 consultation remain live policy issues, even though HMT has decided not to proceed with Phase 2 as a separate exercise.
The Financial Services and Markets Bill
As mentioned above the Financial Services and Markets Bill is the principal legislative vehicle for delivering the CCA 1974 reforms. At the time of writing the Bill was introduced in the House of Lords on 19 May 2026 and received its second reading on 8 June 2026 and was committed to Grand Committee for detailed clause-by-clause scrutiny. Once enacted, it will be cited as the Financial Services and Markets Act 2026.
Conclusion
HMT's policy statement represents the most significant restructuring of UK consumer credit regulation in over a decade, building on the initial transfer of supervisory responsibility from the OFT to the FCA in 2014. Whilst the direction of travel is now clear — a shift from prescriptive statutory requirements towards an outcomes-based, FCA-led regime — the full picture will only emerge once the FCA has consulted on and finalised its replacement rules. The transitional period is also likely to be a significant source of implementation risk, and firms will need to manage the move from the existing to the new regime carefully.
In the meantime, firms should be considering the following practical steps:
- Map existing CCA compliance obligations against the policy statement. Firms should use the detailed provisions table at Annex A of HMT's policy statement to identify which CCA 1974 provisions that currently apply to their business are to be repealed, recast, or retained. This exercise will help firms understand where their compliance frameworks will need to change and where existing obligations will remain in force.
- Monitor and engage with FCA consultations. The FCA has confirmed that it intends to consult on the key elements of the new consumer credit regulatory framework. These consultations will determine the substance of the replacement rules, and firms should engage actively to help shape a workable and proportionate regime. In particular, firms should focus on how the FCA proposes to approach information disclosure requirements, given the current uncertainty over the level of prescription that will be retained.
- Assess the impact of removing automatic sanctions. The repeal of unenforceability and disentitlement to interest sanctions will change the risk profile for firms, particularly in relation to historical non-compliance with CCA 1974 information requirements. Firms should consider how this affects ongoing litigation or disputes, as well as the adequacy of their existing compliance and quality assurance processes under the new regime.
- Track the Financial Services and Markets Bill through Parliament. The Bill is the legislative vehicle for these reforms, and it may be amended as it progresses through both Houses. Firms should monitor the Bill's passage closely, particularly any amendments that could alter the scope or timing of the reforms.
- Prepare for transition. HMT has confirmed that transitional provisions will be set out in secondary legislation, including an extended implementation period and protections for pre-existing agreements. Firms should begin planning for the transition now, including assessing the operational impact on documentation, systems, and customer communications, and should anticipate that the FCA may offer safe harbour or regulatory forbearance for minor inconsistencies during the migration period.
- Continue to monitor the complex CCA 1974 provisions. Sections 56, 75, 75A and 140A–C remain unchanged for now, but HMT has indicated that further policy work is under way. Firms with significant exposure to connected lender liability or unfair relationships claims should continue to engage with industry bodies and HMT as proposals in these areas develop.
Taken together, the reforms present both opportunities and challenges. Firms that engage early — both with the legislative process and the FCA's rulemaking — will be best placed to influence the shape of the new regime and to manage the transition effectively.
The authors wish to thank Savannah Harper, Trainee Solicitor, Norton Rose Fulbright LLP for her contribution.