The High Court has considered pension increase rules under which increases above 5 per cent RPI could be paid only if, after consulting the scheme actuary, the trustee considered this would not increase the employer's contributions. The judgment addresses what amounts to an increase in employer contributions, the degree of certainty trustees must have before granting higher increases, and the impact of a scheme's sectionalised structure on that assessment.
The dispute arose after the retail prices index (RPI) exceeded 5 per cent and the trustee wished to award excess increases worth around £26 million. The employer disagreed.
The Court considered several questions about the requirement that excess increases must not result in an increase in the employer’s contributions. These included:
- What constitutes an increase in the employer's contributions? The Court held that this is not limited to an immediate increase. It also includes future increases, and the trustee must take account of reasonably foreseeable future events.
- How much certainty is needed that employer contributions will not increase? The Court held that there must not be material uncertainty as to whether paying the increase would result in higher employer contributions. It rejected lower thresholds based on a "real possibility" or a "realistic possibility" of an increase.
The Court also considered whether the scheme's sectionalised structure should be taken into account when assessing the resources available to pay the excess increases. It concluded that the trustee should take account of similar increase rules in other sections of the scheme where there may be claims for full RPI increases.
The full judgment is here.