Facts
The dispute concerned a contract for the sale of Iraqi oil products, which incorporated the BP GTCs “Except as specifically detailed above” between Mercuria (as buyer) and Onex (as seller).
The contract provided:
- That the production was high sulphur straight-run fuel oil “in line with the following typicals”. Following which a table set out results and specified that organic chloride (“OC”) content was 4.10.
- That the product would meet certain guarantees as specified in a separate table (which did not include reference to OC).
The BP GTCs defined typical as a “quality or characteristic…given without guarantee and not amounting to a representation or warranty that such typical quality or attribute will be present…”
The OC content of the cargo, when tested after discharge, averaged 16 ppm which ultimately resulted in Mercuria selling the cargo at a lower price than it would have had the cargo not been contaminated.
Key issues
The central question was whether reference to “in line with the following typicals” in the contract imposed an obligation on Onex to supply product with an OC content below 4.10.
Mercuria argued that “in line with” were words of obligation and that section 59.1.1 of the BP GTCs did not declaw that agreement in circumstances where:
- Section 59.1.1 of the BP GTCs was not incorporated because the BP GTCs were only incorporated “except as specifically detailed above” and the Additional Terms specifically required the cargo to be “in line with the typicals”.
- The BP GTCs were inconsistent with the “in line with the following typicals” wording in the Recap and so the latter terms would prevail.
- The parties had “otherwise stated in the Special Provisions” for the purpose of section 59.1.1.
Onex countered that:
- The parties, in describing the product by reference to typicals, were using the term in the sense defined in section 57.1.61 of the BP GTCs, a quality or characteristic "often attributable to […] Product from a particular source, given without guarantee and not amounting to a representation or warranty that such typical quality or attribute will be present in the […] Product supplied".
- Section 59.1.1 was the exclusive provision dealing with Quality of Product, confining quality obligations to the express Specifications agreed in the contract.
- Section 59.1.1. took full effect in excluding typicals as not forming part of the description, quality etc of the Product.
- The words "in line with" did not override these provisions.
- There was no conflict between section 59.1.1 and the Recap.
The Court's decision
Citing Pagnan SpA v Tradax Ocean Transportation [1987] 2 All ER 565 and the principles set out in Septo Trading Inc v Tintrade Ltd ("The Nounou") [2021] EWCA Civ 718 [2021] 2 Lloyds Rep 591 and Lukoil Asia Pacific Pte Ltd v Ocean Tankers (Pte) Ltd ("The Ocean Neptune") [2018] 1 Lloyd's Rep. 654, the Court found:
- The contract should be construed as a whole, and in doing so, the meaning of typicals was contained in sections 57.1.61 and 59.1.1 of the BP GTCs. The contract drew a distinction between guaranteed obligations and typicals and reference in the special provision to “in line with” did not elevate the “typical” characteristic into a warranty.
- A reasonable person in the position of these “experienced parties” would have understood the contract to draw a clear distinction between guaranteed specifications and typicals. BP GTCs are widely used in the industry, and both parties were (or should have been) aware of their effect.
- A practical approach involves considering both the special conditions and the BP GTCs.
- The BP GTCs did not deprive the special conditions of effect but rather supplemented and clarified them. There was no relevant inconsistency between the BP GTCs and the special conditions.
- The contract could and should be read as a whole, with the special conditions and the printed terms interpreted together.
Mercuria argued in the alternative that; (1) Onex was in breach of a guarantee that the Product was 100% SOMO IRAQI HSSR; and (2) that the level of OC was such that the Cargo no longer complied with its specification / it was an inferior specification in breach of section 59.1.1 of the BP GTCs.
The Court rejected both arguments. It held that the 100% requirement concerned the origin of the cargo, not its quality. As to whether the Cargo was SOMO Basrah Pipeline High-Sulphur SRFO, the Court applied the test from Ashington Piggeries v Christopher Hill [1972] AC 441, asking whether the cargo had lost its commercial identity by reason of the contamination. Noting that over 93% of the cargo was ultimately resold as Iraqi SRFO, the Court held that the cargo remained SRFO regardless of its elevated OC content.
Key takeaways
- Commodity traders incorporating the BP GTCs (or similar industry standard terms) should note that references to “typical” specifications will, generally, not create binding guarantees unless expressly stated otherwise. Only those specifications expressly stated as “guaranteed” or “warranted” form the basis of the seller’s obligations as to quality and description.
- Care should be taken when drafting recaps, special provisions, or additional terms to avoid ambiguity as to whether a specification is intended to be a binding guarantee. Where parties intend typicals to create binding obligations, this must be stated in clear and unambiguous terms that expressly override the relevant provisions of the BP GTCs.
- The Court’s reliance on the widespread industry use and understanding of the BP GTCs also serves as a reminder that parties to commodity sale contracts must consider the effect and meaning of standard terms.
With thanks to Chris Menon for their assistance with this article.