The California Legislature is moving forward with legislation designed to curb the recent surge of lawsuits alleging violations of the California Invasion of Privacy Act(CIPA). In response to a deluge of lawsuits challenging commonplace website technologies, Senate Bill 690 (SB 690) was introduced in 2025. As originally drafted, the bill would have created a broad “commercial business purpose” exception to several CIPA provisions, including its wiretapping, eavesdropping and pen register provisions. Recent amendments this month substantially narrowed that approach: rather than broadly exempting commercial activity, the bill would now significantly restrict private enforcement—but only for claims under CIPA’s pen register and trap-and-trace provisions arising from websites and online or mobile applications.

Penal Code section 638.51 currently prohibits the use of a pen register or trap-and-trace device without authorization, and plaintiffs have alleged that common website tracking technologies—such as pixels and analytics tools—fall within the scope of that prohibition. Private plaintiffs have relied on this statute to bring claims seeking monetary damages based on a website’s alleged unauthorized tracking activity.

Section 638.51 has proven particularly attractive to plaintiffs because it is relatively easier to plead than many other CIPA provisions. The statute broadly defines pen registers and trap-and-trace devices to encompass technologies that capture dialing, routing, addressing or signaling information. Relying on that expansive language, plaintiffs have asserted claims based on routine internet communications, alleging that websites collect information such as IP addresses and other data necessary for standard browser-to-website interactions. In some cases, plaintiffs have sought to characterize ordinary website functionality as the operation of a pen register or trap-and-trace device, creating potential liability based on commonplace internet practices rather than traditional surveillance activity.

Under SB 690’s most recent amendment, however, only the California Attorney General would be authorized to bring an action for a violation of section 638.51 for actions arising from conduct occurring on an internet website, online application or mobile application. The amendment would also apply retroactively to any pending claim in an action commenced within two years before the bill’s operative date. This means that many recently filed or currently pending section 638.51 claims based on website tracking could be subject to dismissal or otherwise impacted if the bill is enacted. The amendment may also help curb future claims premised on routine website operations and reduce the risk that businesses face liability for standard internet communications and technical processes.

SB 690 is not yet law. The bill remains pending in the California Legislature and must still clear additional legislative steps before it can be sent to the governor. Businesses currently evaluating new CIPA-related demands may therefore want to monitor the bill’s progress before resolving claims that allege violations of section 638.51.

Contact