Introduction
The Court of Appeal recently clarified the role of the regime established under the Public Interest Disclosure (Whistleblower Protection) Act (PIDA) in protecting employee whistleblowers while maintaining confidence in public entities.
In Campbell v Alberta (Public Interest Commissioner),1 the Court of Appeal confirmed that in PIDA whistleblower cases, the anonymity of whistleblowers and witnesses outweighs a respondent’s expectation of knowing the identities of the whistleblower and others involved in investigations.
In this case, a disclosure was submitted under PIDA alleging misconduct by a school division superintendent (the Respondent). The PIDA Commissioner (the Commissioner) interviewed 34 current and former employees during the investigation and determined that the Respondent created a workplace culture of fear, harassment, and intimidation. After the release of the “genericized” findings and the Commissioner’s report concluding that the Respondent had committed wrongdoing under PIDA, the Respondent sought judicial review. The Respondent argued that the identities of the whistleblower and individuals interviewed during the investigation were not disclosed, thereby preventing her from preparing a full defence to the allegations against her.
A King’s Bench judge agreed with the Respondent and quashed the Commissioner’s report on the basis that withholding the witnesses’ identities breached the duty of procedural fairness. The Court of Appeal reversed that decision. The Court of Appeal held that, absent extenuating circumstances, witness and whistleblower confidentiality is a pillar of PIDA and must be upheld. Investigations under PIDA must balance the right to know and meaningfully respond to allegations while maintaining employees' anonymity.
The PIDA regime explained
The PIDA regime differs from other professional disciplinary schemes because it investigates misconduct involving public entities, protects employees throughout the disclosure process, and recommends corrective measures to maintain public confidence in those entities.
Before beginning an investigation, the Commissioner must be satisfied that all internal mechanisms to address the misconduct have been used or considered. If satisfied, an informal investigation is conducted, involving interviews with whistleblowers and witnesses, as well as reviews of applicable, non-privileged documents. At the conclusion of the investigation, the Commissioner issues a final, genericized report to protect the identities of whistleblowers and witnesses.
The final report includes appropriate recommendations that are not binding on the public entity. However, if the Commissioner believes that the entity has not appropriately followed the recommendations, the Commissioner may make a further report on the matter.
The PIDA process differs significantly from a professional discipline matter or judicial decision. The Court of Appeal emphasized that PIDA focuses on “wrongdoing above wrongdoers.” As such, the Commissioner cannot compel an entity to take corrective measures or impose sanctions on those who contribute to wrongdoing. The PIDA process can best be analogized to an audit, reporting deficiencies, but leaving specific corrective actions to the public entity.
Employee protections under PIDA
Under PIDA, the statutory default is anonymity of whistleblowers and investigation participants. However, a whistleblower’s identity may be disclosed in limited circumstances if the public or an individual’s interest outweighs the potential harm to a whistleblower. For example, it is an established principle of procedural fairness that a respondent knows the case against them. Where allegations carry serious potential consequences for a respondent, disclosure may be required. However, this is typically not applicable to PIDA because recommendations are non-binding.
Takeaways for employers
PIDA applies only to Alberta's public sector, but the Campbell decision reflects tensions between anonymity and disclosure in all workplace investigations. Courts may decline to order that the identities of whistleblowers or witnesses be disclosed so long as the subject of an investigation receives enough information to understand and meaningfully respond to allegations against them.
A critical difference between the PIDA regime and private-sector workplace investigations lies in the consequences. Under PIDA, the Commissioner cannot impose discipline, terminate employment, or levy sanctions. That limited enforcement justifies a higher threshold for disclosure. Private-sector investigations, by contrast, often lead directly to termination, demotion, or civil liability. Higher stakes attract greater procedural fairness obligations. Employers cannot replicate PIDA's model of total anonymity where the investigation will ground a dismissal or disciplinary action.
In conducting and relying upon workplace investigations, employers must balance the integrity of whistleblower procedures with the procedural fairness rights of their subjects. Whether whistleblowers and witnesses remain anonymous will depend on how much the outcome of the investigation affects the individuals or organizations that are the subject of the investigation.
Footnotes
-
Campbell v Alberta (Public Interest Commissioner), 2026 ABCA 184.