Introduction
Section 8 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms (Charter) protects everyone in Canada from search or seizure by state agents that compromises their reasonable expectation of privacy. In plain terms, the government cannot pry into your information, premises, or records unless the law allows it and it is done in a reasonable way. This protection applies not only in criminal investigations, but also when regulators demand documents or data from businesses.
For businesses, section 8 most often arises when a regulator issues a summons or document request during an investigation. Even in heavily regulated industries, the regulator’s request must fit the purpose of the inquiry. Regulators generally do not need criminal law standards like “probable grounds,” but they cannot demand everything under the sun. The hallmark is reasonableness: the demand should be tailored to categories of records that may be relevant to the investigation, and the process must be fair.
In May 2026, the Supreme Court of Canada (SCC) granted leave to appeal in Binance Holdings Limited v. Ontario Securities Commission, a landmark decision that constrains the investigatory powers of regulators.1 The appeal marks the first time that the SCC must determine the intersection between digital privacy laws and section 8 Charter protections in the regulatory context.
Section 8 jurisprudence
Courts have consistently interpreted section 8 as a balancing exercise. The goal is “to strike a reasonable balance between the right of individuals to be left alone and the right of the state to intrude on privacy in the furtherance of its responsibilities for law enforcement.”2 In Hunter v Southam, Dickson J. recognized that section 8 was not designed to authorize governmental power, but rather, to constrain it.3
To establish a violation of section 8, claimants must first show that a state actor invaded their “reasonable expectation of privacy.” In R. v. Tessling, the SCC set out the formulation of the reasonable expectation of privacy inquiry, which requires the court to answer four questions4:
- Determine the “subject matter” of the alleged search.
- Whether the claimant had a “direct interest” in the subject matter.
- Whether the claimant had a subjective expectation of privacy in the subject matter.
- Whether the claimant’s expectation of privacy was “objectively reasonable.”
Once a claimant establishes that a state actor invaded its own reasonable expectation of privacy, it must then show that this “search or seizure” was “unreasonable” under section 8. To be reasonable under section 8, the intrusion must be authorized by law, adhere to any conditions attached to the statutory or common law search power, and those search powers must be “reasonable” on their face.5
Courts have generally been more forgiving of deviations from the Hunter standards outside the criminal context. The SCC’s early section 8 jurisprudence establishes that “[t]he greater the departure from the realm of criminal law, the more flexible will be the approach to the standard of reasonableness.”6 A less demanding standard for regulatory or administrative searches and seizures aligns with a purposive interpretation of section 8.7
The Court of Appeal’s decision
In Binance, the Ontario Securities Commission (OSC) had launched an investigation into Binance’s Canadian trading operations. An OSC investigator issued a summons compelling Binance to produce wide-ranging records, including “all communications” about Ontario (and Canada generally) among directors, officers, employees, contractors, agents, and consultants over a two-and-a-half year period. Binance challenged the summons as overbroad and unconstitutional under section 8 of the Charter.
The Ontario Court of Appeal allowed the appeal in part. First, it held that the OSC cannot use its statutory “revocation/variation” power to review an investigator’s summons; that avenue is not available to the Commission. Second, it found the Divisional Court erred in refusing to hear Binance’s Charter arguments on judicial review.
The Court of Appeal also decided the section 8 issue itself: the summons was an unreasonable seizure. While companies in regulated sectors have a lower expectation of privacy, regulators must confine production demands to categories of documents they have reason to believe may be relevant to the inquiry. Allowing this demand would be to sanction “fishing expeditions.” The court set the summons aside and ordered the OSC to return documents obtained under it, without prejudice to issuing a narrower, Charter-compliant summons.
Why this matters beyond securities
For other heavily regulated industries—banking, transport, energy and utilities—the SCC previously noted that there can only be a relatively low expectation of privacy since these activities are subject to state regulation as a matter of course. That said, the Court of Appeal in Binance clarified that compliance powers are broad, but not boundless. Investigators can compel records without the criminal-law thresholds, but their requests must be targeted to what the regulator has a foundation to believe may be relevant to the investigation.
This finding has practical consequences across sectors where sensitive data and complex systems are the norm. Regulators will need to ensure that requests are not overly broad or untethered to a clear purpose.
Key takeaways
- Reasonableness still rules. Even in a regulatory context, where standards are flexible, a production order must be tethered to records that may reasonably be relevant to the live inquiry. Broad, untargeted demands may result in Charter breaches.
- Lower privacy does not mean no privacy. Operating in a regulated industry reduces expectations of privacy in business records, but it does not obviate section 8 protections.
- Scope and specificity matter. Demands should be framed by subject, time period, and geography that match the investigation. Overbreadth can render a summons unconstitutional.
- Practical result: return and redo. If a summons is set aside as unconstitutional, regulators may have to return already-produced documents and start over with a narrower, better-justified request.
Looking ahead
The SCC granted leave to appeal in Binance demonstrating the national importance of the case. The SCC’s review is significant because it will set the national standard for how far regulators can go when seeking to compel business records. A clear rule on how to craft targeted production demands will affect investigations across securities, competition, finance, energy, and beyond. If the Court of Appeal’s decision is upheld, it may give companies greater leverage to challenge overly expansive summonses at an earlier stage.
Conversely, if the SCC overturns the decision, regulators may emerge with broader constitutional latitude. Until then, organizations should expect regulators to be intentional with the scope of their summonses and tailor requests to articulate why the categories sought are reasonably connected to the investigation’s purpose
Footnotes
-
Binance Holdings Limited v. Ontario Securities Commission, 2025 ONCA 751. [Binance]
-
R. v. Duarte, [1990] 1 S.C.R. 30 at 45.
-
Hunter v. Southam Inc., [1984] 2 S.C.R. 145 at 156. [Hunter]
-
R. v. Tessling, 2004 SCC 67 at para. 32.
-
R. v. Collins, [1987] 1 S.C.R. 265.
-
British Columbia Securities Commission v. Branch, [1995] 2 S.C.R. 3 at para. 52.
-
Ibid.