On June 10, 2026, the UK’s Competition Appeal Tribunal (Tribunal) handed down a written judgment and made an Order approving its first ‘drop hands’ collective settlement in Which? v Qualcomm, bringing to an end nearly five years of litigation and resulting in Which? discontinuing a £480 million claim with no payment by Qualcomm.

The parties’ settlement application – and the Tribunal’s resulting decision – follow a five-week trial and reflect the settlement Tribunal’s independent assessment that the claim had “no realistic prospect of success”. It marks an important development in the UK collective proceedings regime, confirming that claims which do not withstand scrutiny at trial can be brought to an efficient end, as well as providing guidance on how the Tribunal will assess such outcomes.

Which?’s case against Qualcomm

In 2021, Which? brought an ‘opt‑out’ collective action against Qualcomm seeking over £480 million in damages on behalf of an estimated 29 million UK smartphone owners. Which? alleged that Qualcomm’s chipset supply and licensing practices enabled it to leverage a dominant position in the supply of certain baseband chipsets – namely, by extracting supra‑competitive royalties from Apple and Samsung LTE‑enabled mobile phones, which it alleged increased the cost of those mobile phones sold to UK consumers.

A five‑week trial of the claim took place between October and November 2025, during which the Tribunal heard evidence from Qualcomm’s senior executives, industry participants, and expert economists. Following trial, the parties reached agreement that Which? would apply to the Tribunal for permission to withdraw the proceedings, without any payment by Qualcomm.

This is because Which? had concluded, based on the evidence and the arguments at trial, that the Tribunal would find that, among other things, Qualcomm’s licensing and chipset practices did not infringe competition laws, did not result in inflated royalties, and did not lead to an increase in prices consumers paid for their mobile phones.

On that basis, Which? concluded that the claim was unlikely to succeed. The settlement Tribunal accepted that view and independently assessed that Which?’s remaining prospects were only about “10-15 per cent”.

Statutory framework for collective settlements

The Tribunal may approve a settlement in collective proceedings only if satisfied that the terms are “just and reasonable” (section 49A(5) Competition Act 1998 and Rule 94 of the Tribunal Rules 2015). In carrying out that assessment, the Tribunal must consider the factors set out in Rule 94(9), which reflect the dual objectives of encouraging settlement while protecting the interests of the class.

The Tribunal must therefore conduct a broad and holistic assessment, considering “all the circumstances of the case”, and the extent to which the settlement delivers any “meaningful benefit to class members”. In this regard, however, neither the Competition Act nor the Tribunal Rules 2015 provide any specific guidance on the approval of settlements with no monetary award of damages. Given that this was the first time that parties to collective proceedings had ever proposed a ‘drop hands’ settlement under the UK regime, the Tribunal was required to apply these established principles in a materially novel context.

Key takeaways from the Tribunal’s judgment

Against this background, a specially constituted Tribunal, chaired by Hodge Malek KC, heard the parties’ settlement application on May 18, 2026. The resulting judgment provides important clarification on the application of Rule 94 in the context of ‘drop hands’ settlements, particularly as regards merits assessment, stakeholder interests and procedural oversight. The key takeaways of the Tribunal’s decision are set out below:

  1. A post-trial merits assessment indicated that Which?’s claim had “no realistic prospects of success”

    1. Firstly, and centrally, the decision underscores the determinative role of post‑trial merits assessment in a ‘drop hands’ context. The Tribunal made clear that its approval turned on its own independent assessment that, at the end of trial, the claim had “no realistic prospect of success”. In particular, the Tribunal acknowledged that Which? had “encountered real difficulty” with its theory of harm and the underlying facts on abuse, pointing to “substantial evidential problems”.
    2. This provides important guidance for the application of Rule 94. It demonstrates that a settlement involving no monetary recovery may nonetheless be “just and reasonable” where the claim has, in substance, low prospects of success. Although the Tribunal acknowledges that an evaluation of the merits is not in itself conclusive, “there comes a point at which the prospects [of success] are so low” that the value of the claim is materially reduced, if not extinguished altogether.
  2. The interests of defendants and other stakeholders are an important part of the Tribunal’s “just and reasonable” assessment

    1. Secondly, the settlement Tribunal shifted emphasis from earlier authorities such as Merricks v Mastercard1 and subsequent Tribunal decisions, which framed the Rule 94 inquiry as primarily concerned with the interests of the class.
    2. While the Tribunal’s judgment has reaffirmed that “the statutory focus is on the interests of class members”, it clarifies that this does not render the interests of other stakeholders “irrelevant”. The Tribunal therefore undertook a detailed assessment of incentives and outcomes for all participants in the litigation ecosystem, including Which? as the class representative, Qualcomm as the defendant, the funders, ATE insurers and the parties’ lawyers.
    3. In doing so, the Tribunal has expressly recognised that the interests of class members in any given case cannot be considered in isolation from the interests of the collective proceedings regime as a whole – namely., one which enables redress and contributes to deterrence of anti-competitive conduct. In this regard, “it is important that collective proceedings – both present and future – are adequately funded, which requires the involvement of lawyers, funders and ATE insurers”.
    4. Accordingly, the Tribunal moved beyond the class‑centric framing in Merricks, and also aligned itself more closely with the Supreme Court’s guidance – by indicating that the regime must balance access to justice with protection against unmeritorious claims.
  3. Close scrutiny of stakeholder dynamics is critical

    1. Thirdly, the settlement Tribunal stressed the need for a detailed examination of the differing incentives of funders, ATE insurers, lawyers and the class representative, including the risk that financial or commercial pressures from other stakeholders might favour settlement, even where the class representative would otherwise prefer to continue.
    2. The settlement Tribunal, however, found no evidence of improper influence. Notably, the alignment of stakeholders – particularly those with material downside exposure (namely substantial deferred fees incurred by Which?’s lawyers) – was treated as consistent with a genuine, merits‑based reassessment of the claim. The fact that stakeholders stood to lose financially if the case settled reinforced the conclusion that the decision to settle was not driven by commercial pressure.
    3. This confirms that aligned commercial incentives will not undermine a settlement where they reflect a credible assessment that the claim no longer has substantive value, rather than external pressure on the class representative.
  4. The Tribunal emphasised its supervisory and iterative role in collective settlements

    1. Fourthly, the judgment reinforces the Tribunal’s active “supervisory and iterative” role in the settlement process. Approval is not binary: the Tribunal may identify issues and indicate that modifications are required before concluding that a settlement is capable of approval. In this case, prior to the hearing, the Tribunal corresponded with the parties as regards the scope of the claims being compromised and the binding effect on all UK-domiciled class members. Following that correspondence, the parties agreed to amend the terms of the settlement agreement which enabled approval, described by the Tribunal as “exactly how the system is meant to work”.
    2. This confirms that collective settlements are subject to active judicial scrutiny, rather than passive endorsement. Consistent with that role, the settlement Tribunal also provided guidance as to provisions in a settlement agreement that may be implemented prior to the Tribunal’s formal approval of the settlement overall. Even where there is a legitimate rationale for such provisions, parties should first raise them with the Tribunal, and should not seek to implement the provisions unless and until the Tribunal has indicated an appropriate way forward.
  5. Importance of transparency vis-à-vis the public

    1. Finally, and although not a feature of the judgment itself, the settlement Tribunal underscored the importance of transparency, particularly in a zero‑recovery outcome affecting a large class.
    2. At the hearing, Hodge Malek KC stressed that class members must be able to “fully understand why this case is being settled” on a ‘drop hands’ basis. In that context, the Chair indicated that he may even be willing to override confidentiality claims to ensure that the basis for extinguishing claims is adequately justified.

What this means

The Tribunal’s decision in Which? v Qualcomm is a significant milestone in the development of the UK collective proceedings regime.

The judgment clarifies the circumstances in which ‘drop hands’ settlements may be approved, in particular where a post‑trial assessment shows that a claim no longer has a realistic prospect of success.  It also confirms that the Tribunal will adopt a holistic approach under Rule 94, including careful scrutiny of stakeholder dynamics and a willingness to intervene to ensure settlements are fair and properly explained.

For defendants, the ruling offers guidance on when ‘drop hands’ settlements may be achievable – particularly following trial – and underlines the importance of a robust trial strategy and ongoing merits reassessment.

Norton Rose Fulbright LLP represented Qualcomm in these proceedings, including at trial and during the settlement proceedings.

Footnotes

  1. 1

    Merricks v Mastercard [2025] CAT 28.

Contact