Whistleblowing can take many different forms, can encompass a wide range of different concerns and can vary in terms of seriousness. However, there is at least one constant: knowing when to report and dealing with concerns raised both require careful handling and consideration if regulated firms and individuals are not to create additional problems for themselves. We set out below some of the key developments in this area and some considerations for those either reporting or responding.
1. Developments
- Whistleblowing data: The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) encourages individuals working in financial services to report potential wrongdoing to the FCA (and senior managers have an individual reporting responsibility). On a quarterly basis, the FCA publishes data in relation to whistleblowing reports received. Each report can raise a number of allegations. Earlier this month, the FCA published its data for Q1 2026. The total number of new reports was 355, up from 281 reports in Q4 2025. These reports contained 906 allegations in total. In January 2026, the FCA refined its reportable allegation subject headings with the intention of improving clarity and becoming more informative with the detail it can provide. Following on from this, the top three allegations reported by whistleblowers in Q1 2026 were: the Consumer Duty (210 reports); leadership & senior managers (173 reports); and systems and controls (113 reports). In a small number of cases, the FCA may take significant action (such as enforcement action, a skilled person review or imposing restrictions on a firm or individual) but less serious steps can arise in a higher proportion of cases, such as writing to or visiting a firm or asking it to attest to compliance. The FCA closed 265 whistleblowing reports between January and March 2026, with significant action to manage harm in only 23 reports.
- Non-financial misconduct: In implementing new guidance on non-financial misconduct, the FCA has emphasised the importance of fostering “psychologically safe workplaces that nurture creativity and promote innovation in consumers’ interests”. In particular, the new guidance, which is due to come into effect on 1 September 2026, confirms that subjecting a fellow member of the workforce to significant detriment for whistleblowing would lack integrity and be in breach of Individual Conduct Rule 1 which requires conduct rules staff to act with integrity (Code of Conduct (COCON) 4.1.1G(20)) and that senior managers could be failing to act with skill, care and diligence if they fail to take seriously or deal appropriately with misconduct complaints or fail to take reasonable steps to provide a safe environment for people to raise concerns (COCON 4.1.8-BG). Of note, the FCA’s culture and non-financial misconduct survey, published in October 2024, highlighted that, as at that time, not all firms surveyed had in place whistleblowing policies. In the FCA’s view, whistleblowing remains an important means for staff to raise concerns at firms as, where behaviour like bullying or harassment goes unchallenged, this is ‘one of the reddest flags’ which may raise questions about a firm’s decision making and risk management. The FCA has in the past been critical of both failures by individuals to escalate their concerns within their firm or to the regulator and also the handling of and response to alerts or red flags. Firms should ensure they have appropriate procedures which meet FCA expectations (including complying with the relevant provisions in the Senior Management Arrangements, Systems and Controls sourcebook where applicable) and that they keep these under review. Also of note in this context is the inclusion of sexual harassment as a qualifying disclosure under UK whistleblowing law which came into force on 6 April 2026. This may encourage more employees to come forward and make complaints and firms need to be ready to deal with these.
- Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SMCR) reporting: The FCA’s recent policy statement relating to reform of the SMCR regime included reference to SMF responsibilities to make notifications to the regulator and confirmed that senior managers could be in breach of the Conduct Rules for failing to take reasonable steps to ensure that the firm complies with its reporting obligations or to ensure that other staff members in their area of responsibility escalate relevant matters so they can be disclosed promptly. The new guidance also provides that the duty to report to the FCA applies even if the matter is also the subject of legally privileged communications within or for the firm (COCON 4.2.16G (9) and (10)).
- In-house solicitors: Guidance on reporting concerns about wrongdoing when working in-house and also conducting investigations was issued by the Solicitors Regulation Authority in March 2024 (see our briefing). Following up on this, in October 2025, the Law Society consulted on draft guidance on whistleblowing as an in-house solicitor as part of its in-house ethics framework (see our blog). The consultation closed on 25 January 2026 and the Law Society has indicated that it will share an update soon.
2. Key considerations for reporters
Whether and how to escalate concerns within the organisation or externally to a regulator is often the subject of considerable deliberation and weighing of the various factors for and against. Each decision will clearly turn very much on its own specific facts and taking independent legal advice on the particular circumstances can be beneficial in bringing some objectivity and more detached analysis. Some of the considerations may include:
- Professional/ legal obligations: In addition to the firm’s usual reporting obligations, professionals and other employees may be subject to individual reporting requirements and could face personal sanctions for failing to raise issues. In some cases, their reporting obligations may override any duty of confidentiality to their employer or other organisation but careful consideration is required to ensure they follow the right procedures and balance all interests appropriately.
- Internal procedures: Using a firm’s own internal reporting process can provide benefits such as affording the reporter some anonymity and ensuring that their concerns are identified and handled appropriately internally, and that internal escalation processes have been followed as may be required before matters are raised externally. Reporting internally also means that the disclosure made is more likely to be protected from an individual’s perspective.
- Recipient: In some instances, it may be appropriate to depart from the normal process and to raise concerns with a particular group or individual, but this should be considered carefully including with a view to avoiding any conflicts of interest or breach of protocol.
- Record-keeping: Whatever the outcome of the decision on whether to report, careful records should be made of the information on which the decision was based and the rationale as this may be helpful if they need to justify their actions later.
- Independent advice: Consulting an independent legal or other adviser can be helpful. Where advice is sought from a lawyer, this can benefit from legal advice privilege which may be useful in protecting the discussion from disclosure to the regulator or other third party.
- Legal privilege belonging to a third party: Depending on the circumstances, consideration may need to be given to whether concerns can be raised without damaging any legal privilege belonging to a third party (such as an employer). If this is not possible, there may be ways of limiting the impact and minimising any potential criticism further down the line.
3. Key initial considerations for responders
Regulators expect senior managers and their firms to have adequate procedures in place for individuals to raise concerns and for them to be taken seriously and actioned appropriately. Some considerations include:
- Identifying a protected disclosure: It may not be immediately obvious whether a report or general complaint constitutes a protected disclosure. Some initial analysis may be required to determine this and also to assess which relevant internal process and stakeholders should be involved. However, before involving anyone else internally or externally in such analysis, the recipient of the report should give some thought to confidentiality and conflicts as below.
- Internal procedures: Any report that is raised should be considered and handled in accordance with relevant procedures and FCA requirements so all those who may receive and deal with reports should be familiar with and trained on the internal guidance and FCA expectations. Given whistleblowers may deviate from the regular escalation route, consideration should also be given to providing guidance and training to members of the senior management team who may receive reports including on how to recognise a whistle blow when it is not described as one. Internal speak up/ whistleblowing processes and guidance should be regularly reviewed to ensure they are up to date and adequately cover the potential scenarios in which a report could be made including in light of any issues raised. Any lessons learned from an incident may suggest enhancements to procedures, additional training needs or other remediation.
- Triage: Not all concerns raised will necessarily require an investigation. A triage process may be needed internally to establish the level of review needed. If a decision is made that there is no substance in the concerns and/ or that an investigation is not needed, a particularly careful record should be made of the basis for this.
- Governance: If an investigation or other internal process is required, implementing some governance arrangements may be useful. For example, a working group may be needed with some terms of reference and communication, escalation and reporting protocol.
- Confidentiality: Protected disclosures should be treated in confidence and steps may need to be taken to protect the identity of the whistleblower. Any communications regarding the report and steps taken to review the concerns raised including fact-finding discussions with employees need to be conducted consistent with any confidentiality requirements. Consideration should also be given to how personal data and privacy concerns will be handled in accordance with the relevant legislation.
- Conflicts: On receipt of a report, consideration should be given to the extent to which individuals are interested and potentially conflicted. Any internal group established to handle the response should not include any interested persons and they should be appropriately distanced from the process. It may be necessary to remind relevant individuals not to take any steps themselves and to provide them with guidance on how to conduct themselves.
- Privilege: Legal advice can be taken on a whistle blow with the benefit of privilege and protection from disclosure so the internal working group may wish to consider taking advice on both the process including internal governance and also on the substance of the issues. Involving external support can also assist in reassuring the whistleblower that their concerns are being taken seriously and the investigation involves those who approach the matter with a degree of independence.
- Document preservation: As with litigation and other internal investigations, taking steps at the outset to secure internal evidence that may be relevant can assist with the subsequent fact-finding and also avoid criticism if it later transpires that data or other material has been lost. It is worth thinking broadly about both the subject matter and the sources of evidence, including personal devices and hard copy materials. It is usual to review documents before speaking with employees, but a potential interviewee list may also require prioritisation with regards to anyone who may soon be leaving the firm.
- Whistleblower meeting and support: An initial meeting with the whistleblower if they are known and amenable can assist with ensuring that all concerns are well articulated and understood and also in ensuring the whistleblower knows that the firm is taking steps to consider the issues and that their expectations are managed appropriately. More broadly, it should be clear what support is available to the whistleblower, including who will provide it and how it will be delivered.
- Notifications: A range of potential notifications will need to be considered, both internal and external. In particular, regulatory notifications may be triggered before the firm is in a position to determine whether there is any substance in the concerns and so it is not necessarily safe to defer communicating with the FCA/ PRA until further information has been obtained and /or the investigation completed. At the very least a record should be made of the reasons not to notify. If the firm decides to let the regulator know that a disclosure has been received, it is often helpful to provide an indication of next steps and timing for an update to be provided. When considering notifications, bear in mind that the whistleblower may themselves contact the regulator.
- Record-keeping: From the outset and throughout the process of handling a whistle blow, a firm should keep records of the steps taken, decisions made and individuals involved. This log can be used for reference in the event that any enquires are received about what the firm has done and why.
We regularly advise regulated firms on escalations, notifications and whistleblowing. Our experienced response team can discuss matters with you in confidence and help you navigate the complexities of reporting and responding. Please get in touch if a conversation would be helpful.