Introduction

The United States is widely considered a preferred jurisdiction for the enforcement of arbitral awards against sovereigns – with good reason. For decades, a unique constellation of structural advantages and legal tools has made the US an effective forum for converting “paper awards” against award debtors – including sovereign ones – into tangible recovery. No capital’s capital is untouchable in the US.

The US’s standing as the world’s preeminent enforcer of arbitral awards against sovereigns has gotten only stronger in the past year. Recent judicial rulings have rejected arguments that states had hoped would shield them in certain cases from the long arm of US courts. With these rulings in place, the path in the US for enforcing awards against sovereigns is now all the smoother.

Why international award creditors choose to enforce in the US

Even before the recent court rulings, the US had long been a “magnet forum” for international award creditors. A staunch pro-enforcement philosophy, deeply entrenched in American jurisprudence, is only one reason for the US’s appeal. Additional structural and procedural advantages that few other jurisdictions can match set the US apart.

To start with a somewhat obvious advantage, the US in many cases is simply where the money is. As the world’s primary financial hub, the US is a repository for vast amounts of wealth belonging to sovereigns and their state-owned enterprises. Additionally, because many global exchanges are US dollar-denominated, sovereign funds that pass through New York correspondent banks are potentially vulnerable to seizure by international award creditors.

In tandem with this structural reality, a comprehensive federal statute – the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act (FSIA) – facilitates the seizure of state property to satisfy international arbitral awards.  A commonly asserted ground for overcoming the sovereign immunity defense is that state property is used for a commercial activity in the United States. Because commercial activity is an expansive concept, award creditors can ask US courts to seize an airplane of a national airline landing at JFK airport, shipments of state-owned oil passing through the Port of Houston, or a commercial building in New York owned by a sovereign wealth fund.

Award creditors in US courts also have access to a fearsome discovery kit to locate state assets.  Since 2014, the US Supreme Court has made clear that award creditors can wield against states a “quite permissive” federal procedural rule that authorizes discovery from literally “any person” – including both the states themselves and other persons who might know where to find state property. Sovereign states do not enjoy immunity from such discovery, even when the property itself may be held outside the US. Thus, information about state assets gathered in a US proceeding can be used to execute against state assets elsewhere, such as Singapore, London, or Luxembourg.

In addition, in key state-level jurisdictions like New York and Texas, courts can order third parties – such as banks holding sovereign assets – to turn over the debtor’s assets wherever in the world they are held, including outside the US. This allows a creditor to reach, for instance, funds sitting in a foreign branch whenever the bank’s headquarters or a major branch is within the court’s reach.

The US legal system is also well equipped to overcome “shell games” that states may play. Leveraging alter ego theory and similar doctrines, creditors may be able to seize the assets of state-owned enterprises to satisfy the parent state’s debts. Additionally, fraudulent transfer laws and the potential application of RICO (Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act) in the enforcement context may enable creditors to overcome efforts by states and their accomplices to thwart lawful award enforcement efforts.

Recent rulings make enforcement easier than ever against states

Noteworthy judicial rulings rendered in the past year have further fortified the US as an advantageous forum for aggrieved creditors. These rulings have removed a traditional legal hurdle for establishing jurisdiction over state defendants, while also positioning the US as an antidote to anti-investment-arbitration trends in Europe.

In the first of these rulings, the US Supreme Court issued in June 2025 in CC/Devas (Mauritius) Ltd. v. Antrix Corp. a unanimous, 9-0 decision that eliminated a posited constitutional requirement for enforcing international arbitral awards against foreign states and their instrumentalities. As legal background, non-state defendants in US courts may be able to avoid US jurisdiction by asserting an age-old constitutional defense: that they lack sufficient contacts with the specific US state where the suit is brought. Leveraging this defense, several foreign sovereigns facing enforcement efforts had tried to evade US jurisdiction, some with success.

In Devas, however, the Supreme Court ended that line of argument for state defendants. It held that jurisdiction over a foreign state and its instrumentalities exists automatically whenever there is an applicable exception to sovereign immunity under the FSIA and service of process was properly done. These are usually low bars, since under the FSIA a state effectively consents to enforcement in the US just by agreeing to international arbitration governed by treaty (such as the New York and ICSID Conventions), and the procedures for serving process on foreign states are straightforward. By rejecting this potential constitutional defense, the Supreme Court left the doors of US courts wide open to post-award enforcement actions against sovereigns, even when the underlying dispute and arbitration have no connection to the US.

Not long after the Supreme Court’s Devas ruling, in August and September 2025, multiple federal district (first-instance) courts in Washington, DC confirmed a series of investment arbitration awards rendered against Spain under the Energy Charter Treaty (ECT). For background, this string of rulings were enabled by a key jurisdictional ruling that the Court of Appeals for the DC Circuit rendered in the prior year. In that appeal, Spain argued that its consent to arbitrate disputes with EU private investors under the ECT had been ruled unlawful by the Court of Justice of the European Union in a pair of landmark rulings – widely known as the Achmea and Komstroy decisions. Spain argued, in effect, that EU law vitiated its consent to arbitrate under the ECT, and that it therefore enjoyed full sovereign immunity under the FSIA.

That argument did not succeed with the DC Court of Appeals, however. It held that under US law, Spain’s consent to arbitration reflected in the ECT was an effective waiver of its immunity to post-award enforcement actions before the US courts. With this appellate ruling confirming the jurisdiction of US courts over Spain, the DC district courts proceeded to confirm one after another the underlying arbitral awards. In doing so, they consistently rejected Spain’s attempted reframing of its EU-law arguments as a substantive defense to enforcement. This series of recent judgments, among others rejecting the Achmea/Komstroy arguments of other EU state defendants, has elevated the federal DC courts as a global destination for EU investors who may find their investment awards against EU states to be otherwise unenforceable in European cities like Brussels, Paris and Berlin.

Outlook

In 2026, the United States remains the world’s preferred forum for enforcing arbitral awards against sovereigns. By combining robust enforcement tools with a pro-enforcement judiciary, the US legal system aims to ensure that an arbitral award is not just a symbolic victory but a precursor to real compensation.

Issue 24

  • content-type:insights/publication
  • nrf-migrated:article-categories/hubs/international-arbitration-report/issue-24
card-grid-item, aem-sourced
International arbitration report
/en/insights/publications/international-arbitration-report-hub

Contact