In Pridewell Properties (London) Ltd v Spirit Pub Company (Managed) Ltd [2026] EWHC 953 (Ch), the High Court has provided important guidance on what constitutes a “reasonable time” for a landlord to commence redevelopment works after obtaining possession under ground (f) of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1954 (the “1954 Act”).
Factual Background
The case concerned The Railway Bell, a public house in South Woodford, London. The landlord, Pridewell Properties (London) Limited (the “Landlord”) was an SPV formed to exploit the development potential of the premises by constructing three mews houses in the pub’s beer garden and reconstructing the existing building to provide a ground floor pub with six self-contained flats above. The tenant, Spirit Pub Company (Managed) Limited (the “Tenant”), had occupied the premises since 2007.
The Landlord opposed the Tenant’s application for a new tenancy using ground (f) (intention to demolish and re-develop) but had not applied for, or even been in a position to apply for, planning permission in respect of its proposed redevelopment by the date of trial. This was because the Landlord’s reserved rights under the lease did not allow for access to carry out the acoustic surveys and intrusive investigations necessary to support a planning application, and the Tenant had declined to grant access voluntarily.
At first instance, the trial judge rejected the Landlord’s opposition, finding that it had failed to demonstrate a reasonable prospect of obtaining funding for the scheme. While the judge accepted there was a real prospect that a lender would be satisfied with the mortgage security offered by the premises, no evidence had been adduced of the directors’ personal finances to support the personal guarantees that any lender to an SPV would require. The judge did, however, find in the Landlord’s favour on other issues including planning prospects and on the question of timing, concluding that an estimated 10-14 month delay before works could commence was, in the circumstances, a “reasonable time” for the purposes of commencing the works after termination of the tenancy.
The Appeal
The Landlord appealed on the funding issue alone, which was dismissed by Fancourt J on the basis that the trial judge’s assessment of funding was a composite evaluation; the adequacy of mortgage security was a separate question to directors’ personal guarantees but both were relevant components of whether there was a real prospect of obtaining funding for the development, and the Landlord’s grounds of appeal did not challenge the finding that guarantees of substantial value would be required.
Although not necessary for the disposal of the appeal, Fancourt J went on to consider the question of timing that had been raised by the Tenant in response to the Landlord’s appeal notice. Fancourt J described the question as raising “an important general question on the operation of the 1954 Act, where there appears to have been a misunderstanding of the relevant test.” After reviewing the leading authorities, Fancourt J clarified that the expression “within a reasonable time” is only a paraphrase of the statutory requirement that the landlord intends to carry out works “on the termination of the current tenancy.” It does therefore not establish a freestanding test of what period might be justified in all the circumstances.
The key distinction drawn by Fancourt J was between (i) a landlord who intends to “set about the works on recovering possession” which falls within the statutory tolerance even with some modest delay for practical steps such as clearing and securing the property and mobilising contractors, and (ii) a landlord who “cannot yet set about the works because there is something else that needs to be done first.” In this case, the Landlord intended to apply for a likely contentious planning permission only six to seven months after obtaining possession, with works commencing only some 10-14 months later. Fancourt J considered this was “not just ‘after a time’ but after a substantial time.” Importantly, the fact that the Landlord could not progress matters because the Tenant refused access for surveys was “neither here nor there”, and that such limited access rights were a consequences of the parties’ contractual bargain. Fancourt J concluded that the 1954 Act already provides mechanisms for landlords not yet ready to develop, including the ability to seek a short new lease term, or a redevelopment break clause.
Key Takeaways
The decision is an important clarification of the law on timing under ground (f) and will be of significant practical interest to both landlords and tenants. Landlords contemplating a ground (f) opposition should ensure that, by the date of trial, they have progressed all preparatory steps including planning applications as far as possible, and should not assume that the court will accommodate lengthy post-possession timelines, even where delays are attributable to the tenant’s lack of co-operation.
Where a landlord is not in a position to commence works promptly after obtaining possession, the statutory alternatives, such as a short new lease or a redevelopment break option, remain the appropriate routes. The decision also serves as a reminder that SPV landlords must be prepared to adduce evidence of their directors’ personal financial means where lender guarantees will be required to fund a redevelopment scheme.