A year ago, this column explored a number of cases where plaintiffs who had suffered losses from fraud or terrorism brought suits seeking redress against certain digital asset platforms, or individuals involved in developing or running those platforms. See R. Schwinger, “No Virtual Causation for Virtual Assets?”, N.Y.L.J., May 27, 2025.
These lawsuits were premised upon the theory that the actual wrongdoers had utilized these platforms to accomplish or support their illegal activities, and that the defendants who were being sued either knew or should have known enough about the wrongdoers’ activities on and off the platform to make it appropriate to hold these defendants legally responsible under common law and/or statutory law for the injuries claimed by the plaintiffs.
In most but not all of the cases explored last year, the claims failed. The courts, largely applying traditional proximate cause principles, cited the attenuated causal link between the harms suffered and the conduct of the defendants with respect to the platforms, particularly given the decentralized nature of blockchain-based systems. Whether such judicial thinking might evolve to become more permissive in at least some such cases remained to be seen.
Over the past year, these issues have remained active and the caselaw continues to develop. While courts are not disagreeing much on basic principles, outcomes continue to be highly fact-specific.
The factual variations encountered across the range of lawsuits help illustrate where claims may be viable and where not. And some courts have shown a willingness to allow plaintiffs multiple opportunities to refine their claims in fraud- and terrorism-related crypto claims, to see if they ultimately might be able meet their burden of plausibly alleging causation in such cases against crypto platform defendants.
Robert A. Schwinger explores recent developments in this edition of his New York Law Journal Blockchain law column.
Download the full New York Law Journal article, "Crypto, terror, fraud and causation—a witch’s brew."
The bimonthly Blockchain Law column is written by FinTech lawyer, Robert A. Schwinger, and explores recent developments in the ever-evolving digital transactions arena.