Every patent practitioner knows the sting: you open an office action and find your claims rejected as "obvious." But not all obviousness rejections are created equal. Some are particularly hard to dislodge by resting on deceptively simple logic that masks fundamental errors.
We recently overcame such rejections across different technology areas. Below, we share the strategies that worked — distilled into technology-agnostic takeaways.
The “design choice” rejection – show it’s not arbitrary
Under this rationale, the patent office contends a claimed feature is merely a design choice—one that offers no particular advantage or function. However, this allegation can be rebutted by demonstrating that the feature is linked to a specific advantage or function and was not selected arbitrarily.
For instance, in a recent case, the patent office alleged the particular geometric shape of a claimed structural component was merely a design choice. In response, we successfully demonstrated that the claimed shape was deliberately chosen to achieve a specific technical function—and that distinction made all the difference.
Hence, the key to overcoming a design choice rejection lies upstream in the process by drafting a specification tying all features to an advantage or functional distinction. Explaining why a particular design was selected, what problems it solves, and how it differs functionally from alternatives is key.
Simply put, the more robust the specification's treatment of the reasons underlying a design decision, the stronger the applicant's position will be when confronting this type of rejection.
Lack of criticality
Closely related to the design choice argument is the assertion a claimed feature is not "critical." In our experience, this rejection often arises when the patent office acknowledges a structural distinction but dismisses it as inconsequential.
In one such case, a particular structural taper in the claimed component was deemed not critical as variations in shape involved only "routine skill in the art." To overcome this, we mounted a two-pronged attack.
First, we demonstrated that the specification explicitly tied the claimed feature to a specific and desirable technical effect, supported by passages in the specification that unequivocally linked the claimed shape to improvements in load reduction and the component's expected service life.
Second, we demonstrated that the modifications proposed by the patent office would have been counterproductive for the objective sought by this reference.
Together, these arguments contradicted the patent office and supported a finding the feature has, in fact, criticality while also showing the motivation to modify the prior art was flawed.
Cherry-picking features
A particularly insidious form of obviousness rejection arises when the patent office selectively extracts individual features from multiple prior art references and recombines them. This "cherry-picking" approach can produce superficially plausible rejections that, upon closer analysis, lack the rational underpinning required by law.
In one of our cases, the examiner combined four separate references extracting isolated features from each while ignoring the broader context in which those features appeared.
We successfully argued this approach was impermissible, relying on the widely accepted principle that it is improper to pick and choose from any one reference only so much of it as will support a given position, to the exclusion of other parts necessary to the full appreciation of what such reference fairly suggests to one of ordinary skill in the art.
Our strategy involved a systematic dismantling of each reference's alleged contribution to the rejection. For each reference, we demonstrated that the feature extracted served a fundamentally different purpose in the reference than it did in the claimed invention. We further showed the reconstruction was clearly based on a hindsight bias.
The lesson here is to resist the temptation to address each reference in isolation. Instead, one should show that the references would not lead the skilled person down the path proposed by the patent office.
Result-effective variable
Perhaps the most technically nuanced category of obviousness rejection is the assertion a claimed parameter is a "result-effective variable" that a skilled artisan would optimize through routine experimentation.
In our case, a parameter was deemed a result-effective variable that could be optimized to obtain the claimed value. We overcame this rejection through several complementary arguments.
In such a case, one must determine if the parameter is, indeed, a result-effective variable. The question here is: does the prior art recognize that modifying this variable has an impact on the result? In our case, we demonstrated that the prior art failed to modify this parameter. We further argued that modifying this parameter would have no effect on solving the problem addressed by the prior art. Thus, the skilled person would have no reason to modify the parameter to solve this problem.
Second, we showed that modifying the parameter in the prior art would have the opposite effect to that recited in the claims. Thus, the teachings of the prior art would never lead the skilled person to take the corrective claimed step as doing so would be counterproductive.
To overcome a result-effective variable rejection, agents should demonstrate that the variable in the prior art does not produce a predictable result, and a skilled person would never be motivated to adjust the variable in the direction claimed.
Key takeaways
Each of these four rejection types demands a tailored prosecution strategy, but several common threads emerge. A well-drafted specification detailing the reasons behind design decisions and the technical advantages of claimed features is the segue to successfully overcoming these rejections.
During prosecution, patent agents should look beyond the surface to examine the patent office’s underlying logic: Does the proposed modification actually achieve the same goal as the claimed invention? Would the skilled artisan truly be motivated to combine the cited references? Are the references being read selectively, or as a whole?
When argument alone may not suffice, strategic claim amendments can tip the balance decisively in the applicant's favour. By understanding and leveraging these strategies, patent agents can navigate even the most challenging obviousness rejections – and work towards securing their clients’ innovations.