Introduction
The Staff of the Division of Trading and Markets (Staff) of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) recently issued guidance (Guidance)1 permitting entities to offer user interfaces (UI) that assist in preparing transactions in crypto asset securities2 without registering as a broker-dealer under Section 15(a) of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (Exchange Act). The Guidance applies to “Covered User Interface Providers” that meet twelve conditions, as described further below.3 The SEC considers the Guidance to be an “interim step” in the formulation of a regulatory regime for crypto asset securities, and the Guidance will be withdrawn five years from the date of its issuance absent further SEC action.4
This article analyzes the Guidance, including each of the twelve conditions set out therein. In addition, this article considers the practical implications of the Guidance for those crypto asset trading interfaces that may seek to avail themselves of the relief provided by the Guidance.
Definition of “Covered User Interface”
Scope of “Covered User Interface”
The Guidance defines a “Covered User Interface” as an interface “provided by a website, browser extension, or other software application (e.g., mobile application) that may be embedded in a wallet or separately available for download, designed to assist users engaging in user-initiated crypto asset securities transactions on blockchain protocols (or blockchain-based smart contracts) utilizing the user’s self-custodial wallet.”5 In other words, a Covered User Interface is a software tool that, among other things, enables users to formulate and submit orders for transactions in crypto asset securities. The Guidance reflects the Staff’s understanding that Covered User Interfaces involve one or more of the following activities:
- Preparation of code facilitating interaction with blockchain protocols or smart contracts through the “conver[sion] [of] user-identified crypto asset securities transaction parameters (e.g., buy/sell, volume, crypto asset security and price or price range) into blockchain-legible commands for signature and transmission via [the relevant] user’s self-custodial wallet.”
- Provision of users with market data for crypto asset securities transactions (for example, potential execution routes, asset prices and estimated transaction costs or “gas” fees).
- Presentation of educational material to enable users to develop and establish crypto asset securities transaction parameters on a transaction-by-transaction or default basis.
- Solicitation of investors to use a Covered User Interface.
- Charging fees based on a fixed percentage per crypto asset securities transaction.6
Only self-custodial interfaces qualify:
For purposes of the Guidance, a “wallet” is “self-custodial” where “neither the provider of the wallet nor its associated Covered User Interface has custody of, or access to, the user’s encrypted or decrypted private key.”7 Importantly, the Staff expressly excludes from the scope of the Guidance “persons that create, operate, and/or offer custodial wallets held on behalf of an investor with an associated Covered User Interface.”8 Accordingly, custodial front-ends, and hybrid products that move funds into provider-controlled wallets at any point in the flow, fall outside the scope of the Guidance.
Prohibited brokerage functions:
Entities performing any of the following functions fall outside the scope of the Guidance: (i) negotiating transaction terms; (ii) soliciting specific securities transactions; (iii) making investment recommendations or providing advice; (iv) arranging for financing; (v) processing trade documentation; (vi) conducting independent asset valuations; (vii) holding, having access to, handling, managing or possessing user funds, securities or stablecoins; (viii) executing or settling transactions; or (ix) taking or routing orders.9
Conditions of the Guidance
In order to fall within the scope of the Guidance, a Covered User Interface Provider must comply with conditions that govern: (i) the relationship between a Covered User Interface and its execution venues and users; (ii) permitted compensation for a Covered User Interface Provider; and (iii) a Covered User Interface Provider’s compliance and supervisory infrastructure.10
Relationships between a Covered User Interface and its execution venues and users
Customization of default parameters and provision of educational material to users
A Covered User Interface must permit users to customize default transaction parameters (for example, parameters regarding “price slippage,” transaction costs, such as maximum gas fees and priority fees and transaction time) and may provide educational material to users to help users set transaction parameters.11
Selection of default trading venues or distributed ledger trading systems
A Covered User Interface Provider must select one or more default trading venues (for example, limit order book matching systems, request-for-quote systems) or distributed ledger trading systems (for example, automated market maker liquidity pools and/or liquidity aggregators) with which to connect. The Staff does not appear to view the selection of trading venues as constituting brokerage activity.
Requirements for affiliated trading venues
If a Covered User Interface connects with a trading venue or distributed ledger trading system that is operated by the Covered User Interface Provider or its affiliates, the Covered User Interface Provider must (i) clearly disclose such affiliation to users, and (ii) connect with any such trading venue or distributed ledger trading system on the same terms and conditions as any unaffiliated trading venue or trading system. For the purposes of the Guidance, the term “affiliate” is defined to mean “any person or entity who directly, or indirectly through one or more intermediaries, controls or, is controlled by, or is under common control with the Covered User Interface Provider.”12 Under the Guidance it appears that a Covered User Interface may connect solely with affiliated trading venues, but if it also connects with a third-party venue, it must provide access to both affiliated and unaffiliated venues on the same terms.
Provision of potential execution routes
If a Covered User Interface displays only one potential execution route to a user, it must provide the user with “the ability to see additional routes, if applicable.”13
Filtering/sorting of execution routes
To the extent more than one potential execution route is displayed to a user, a Covered User Interface must provide filtering or sorting mechanisms displaying potential routing designations based on objective factors (for example, lowest/highest price, speed, alphabetically) and allow the user to sort based on such factors.14
No editorializing regarding potential execution routes
A Covered User Interface Provider must not provide commentary on any potential execution route(s) displayed to a user (for example, indicating an execution route provides a “best price” or is the “most reliable”).
Software requirements regarding trading instructions and display of market data
With respect to preparation of a user’s trading instructions and display of market data regarding potential execution routes, a Covered User Interface must only use software that operates on the basis of “pre-disclosed and objective parameters that are independently verifiable.”15
No discretion over market information or securities transactions
A Covered User Interface must not exercise control or discretion over, or engage in any decision-making with respect to, either market information provided or securities transactions.16
Permitted compensation
A Covered User Interface Provider must limit its compensation associated with the Covered User Interface to a fixed charge to the user either on a per-transaction basis (for example, flat fee or percentage of the crypto asset securities transaction) or as a flat fee, based on “objective factors, applied consistently.”17 Such fixed charge must also be “product, execution route, execution venue and counterparty agnostic.”18 Importantly, a Covered User Interface Provider that receives payments for order flow or any compensation based on the size, value or occurrence of a crypto asset securities transaction from any person other than the user would not satisfy the requirements of the Guidance and would be subject to broker-dealer registration.19
Conditions governing supervisory infrastructure and disclosure of material facts
The remaining two conditions established in the Guidance concern a Covered User Interface Provider’s supervisory infrastructure and required disclosures of material facts concerning various aspects of a Covered User Interface Provider’s operations, fees and conflicts of interest.
Supervisory policies, procedures and controls
A Covered User Interface Provider must establish policies, procedures and controls reasonably designed to: (A) evaluate, onboard and audit, on the basis of objective factors trading venues and distributed ledger trading systems that the Covered User Interface will connect to for market data;20 and (B) evaluate and periodically reassess, on the basis of objective factors, any default crypto asset security transaction parameters, as well as any associated conflicts of interest or risks. The Guidance expressly acknowledges that “[e]stablishing, maintaining, and enforcing policies and procedures relating to the operation of the Covered User Interface and maintaining books and record…may be helpful to a Covered User Interface Provider in demonstrating that it is creating, offering, and/or operating a Covered User Interface as described in this statement.”21
Disclosure of certain material facts
A Covered User Interface Provider must “prominently disclose” to a user, and promptly update as necessary, all material facts relating to:
- Its role relating to its creation, offering or operation of a Covered User Interface, including a prominent disclaimer stating that the Covered User Interface Provider is not registered with or regulated by the SEC relating to its creation, offering or operation of a Covered User Interface.
- Fees associated with use of the Covered User Interface, including their structure and calculation.
- Material conflicts of interest associated with a crypto asset securities transaction and use of users’ trading information by the Covered User Interface Provider or its affiliates.
- Any limitations associated with use of the Covered User Interface (for example, limitations regarding specific crypto asset securities, market data and trading venues or distributed ledger trading systems).
- Parameters used in the interface’s software regarding preparation of a user’s trading instructions and display of market data regarding potential execution routes.
- Current cybersecurity policies, procedures and controls for the Covered User Interface.
- Policies, procedures and controls to protect user trading information, including from potential fraud or manipulation (for example, involving maximal extractable value strategies).
- Integration of the Covered User Interface with trading venues or distributed ledger trading systems.
- Any default crypto asset security transaction parameters, including how they are determined, the associated risks, and conflicts of interest and the Covered User Interface Provider’s related policies, procedures and controls.22
Transaction-based compensation revisited? Commissioner Peirce’s statement
SEC Commissioner Hester Peirce issued a statement generally expressing her support for the Staff’s issuance of the Guidance. However, Commissioner Peirce emphasized that her preference is for a “more permanent regulatory approach that addresses the broker definition in light of current market circumstances.”23
Citing a 2024 ruling in the US District for the Southern District of New York in the SEC’s litigation against Coinbase, Commissioner Peirce stated that “the law is already clear” that wallets and interfaces do not fall within the scope of the term “broker” as defined in Section 3(a)(4) of the Exchange Act.24 Accordingly, Commissioner Peirce noted that crypto “is forcing the [SEC] to confront its inner demons that have driven it toward ever more expansive readings of the securities laws” and stated that the SEC “needs public feedback to inform future rulemaking to assess terms like ‘broker’ against the backdrop of new technologies,” particularly as “[r]ecent history is littered with a patchwork of no-action letters and enforcement actions that have contorted the term ‘broker’ beyond recognition.”25
Commissioner Peirce’s statement regarding the Guidance also invoked the SEC’s 2021 enforcement action against Neovest, Inc. (Neovest) and her related dissent.26 In the Neovest Order, the SEC ultimately determined that Neovest violated Section 15(a) of the Exchange Act by acting as an unregistered broker-dealer through (i) its operation of an order and execution management system (OEMS) and receipt of transaction fees from customer-selected broker-dealers for executed equity and option orders routed through the OEMS and (ii) Neovest’s related solicitation efforts.27
In her dissenting statement regarding the Neovest Order, Commissioner Peirce argued that “[r]eceiving transaction-based compensation and soliciting customers are relevant to determining that an entity is a broker only to the extent that they occur in connection with broker activity,” and that “Neovest’s receipt of transaction-based compensation cannot be used to bootstrap it into an otherwise inapt broker status.”28
As the Guidance effectively permits a Covered User Interface Provider to receive “a fixed charge to the user, which may be charged per crypto asset securities transaction (as a flat fee or percentage of the transaction29 the Guidance may be indicative of a shift in the Staff’s view of receipt of transaction-based compensation from being nearly dispositive of the question of broker status under the Exchange Act, to being evaluated as one factor among others in the broker analysis.
Practical considerations
As a result of the Guidance, Covered User Interface Providers will need to consider:
- How to appropriately implement, with respect to Covered User Interfaces, the supervisory policies, procedures and controls required by the Guidance.
- How to provide users with the required material disclosures.
- The relationship between the Covered User Interface and its execution venues and users.
- The Covered User Interface Provider's business model.
- Whether the operation of a Covered User Interface implicates other regulatory requirements not covered under the Guidance.
In addition, as the Guidance applies with respect to crypto asset securities transactions, providers must still evaluate whether crypto assets are “securities” under the Supreme Court’s investment contract test articulated in SEC v. W.J. Howey, as well as the recently issued joint interpretation from the SEC and CFTC addressing how the federal securities laws apply to certain “crypto assets” and related transactions.30
Footnotes
-
Statement, Staff of the Division of Trading and Markets, Securities and Exchange Commission, Staff Statement Regarding Broker-Dealer Registration of Certain User Interfaces Utilized to Prepare Transactions in Crypto Asset Securities, SEC Division of Trading and Markets (Apr. 13, 2026).
-
For purposes of the Guidance, a “crypto asset” is defined to have the same meaning as “Digital Asset” under Section 2(6) of the Guiding and Establishing National Innovation for U.S. Stablecoins Act (GENIUS Act). See GENIUS Act Section 2(6), Pub. L. No. 119-27, 139 Stat. 419 (2025). That is, a “crypto asset” is any digital representation of value recorded on a cryptographically secured distributed ledger. See Guidance at n. 3.
-
Guidance at § II.
-
Guidance.
-
Guidance at § I.
-
Guidance at § I. Note that the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) recently provided no-action relief from the introducing broker registration requirements under the Commodity Exchange Act and CFTC Rules with respect to a developer of self-custodial crypto asset wallet software engaged in similar activities as the activities of Covered User Interfaces under the Guidance. See CFTC Letter No. 26-09, No-Action Position Regarding Introducing Broker Registration Requirement under Section 4d(g) and Associated Person Registration Requirement Under Section 4(k) of the Commodity Exchange Act (March 17, 2026) (CFTC Letter No. 26-09). More specifically, the developer that is the subject of such no-action relief is “involved in the development and distribution of self-custodial crypto asset wallet software applications for use on several major blockchains…[and] does not provide custody services for crypto assets,” but “enables users to generate and manage cryptographic credentials for viewing, storing, and conducting self-directed crypto asset transactions,” and “provides a user interface for customers to transmit transaction instructions to crypto asset trading protocols and other decentralized applications.” CFTC Letter No. 26-09 at 3. Among other things, the self-custodial crypto asset software developer proposed to “develop and distribute front-end interface software for [u]sers to review market data and aggregate position information, view information about product offerings, and submit orders for [CFTC]-regulated derivative products directly to [designated contract markets or CFTC-registered futures commission merchants or introducing brokers” without any affirmative involvement with any particular orders. CFTC Letter No. 26-09 at 3-4.
While the general scope of services discussed in CFTC Letter No. 26-09 are similar to the scope of services engaged in by those considered “Covered User Interface Providers” under the Guidance, the conditions imposed by the CFTC under CFTC Letter No. 26-09 are substantively different from the twelve conditions detailed in the Guidance. Covered User Interface Providers seeking to provide access to CFTC-regulated products will need to conduct a separate analysis to evaluate how their activities implicate CFTC regulatory requirements and such no-action relief.
-
Guidance at n. 6. The Guidance defines a “wallet” to mean “software or hardware that is used to store a crypto asset security investor’s private key, which is used to engage in crypto asset securities transactions.”
-
Guidance at n. 9.
-
Guidance at § II.
-
Guidance at § II.
-
The Guidance states that the Staff understands the term “price slippage” to refer to “the difference between the quoted price of a transaction and the final price of the transaction at the time of execution.” Guidance at n. 10.
-
Guidance at n. 11.
-
While the terms “execution routes” and “execution pathways” are not specifically defined in the Guidance, the Staff cites to a letter from the DeFi Education Fund to the SEC’s Crypto Task Force which provides discussion of routing software and its functions with respect to decentralized exchange protocols. See Letter from DeFi Education Fund and Andreessen Horowitz to Commissioner Hester M. Peirce, Securities and Exchange Commission, Recommendations Regarding a Safe Harbor for Applications from the Broker Registration Requirements of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (August 13, 2025) (DeFi Education Fund Letter). The DeFi Education Letter states: “Routers [defined as optimization and routing software] typically function offchain and are often integrated with a [decentralized finance (DeFi)] [a]pp’s backend. When used by DeFi [a]pps that provide access to decentralized exchange…protocols, routers identify the most efficient paths for token swaps or other transactions. Routers achieve this by automatically and autonomously analyzing onchain data—such as liquidity pool reserves, token prices, and gas costs—across a [decentralized exchange’s] smart contracts to compute the optimal trade route that minimizes slippage or fees…Critically, optimization software like routers…does not necessarily introduce discretion into the execution of a trade. Rather, they typically automatically and autonomously identify potential execution routes based on a number of transaction parameters (e.g., pool addresses, amounts) based on a logic contained in software’s code. Apps then display these routes to users based on objective and transparent criteria, which users review, select, and execute. The user executes the transaction by communicating such parameters to a [decentralized exchange’s] smart contracts by authorizing and signing the transaction utilizing the wallet software functionality. By automating and standardizing these processes, optimization software makes possible efficient, transparent transactions, without enabling any third party to exercise control of user funds or a given transaction, and without altering the underlying protocol’s decentralized logic.” DeFi Education Fund Letter at 9.
-
Guidance at § II.
-
Guidance at § II.
-
In relation to this condition, query whether the requirement to limit display of information based on objective factors precludes systems showing multiple execution routes that incorporate discretion within the algorithm (e.g., aggregator interfaces that query multiple decentralized protocols, identify execution routes, and present consolidated execution options).
-
Guidance at § II.
-
Guidance at § II.
-
Guidance at n. 12.
-
Relevant objective factors include liquidity, latency, transparency, verifiability, neutrality, auditability, and security. See Guidance at § II.\
-
Guidance at § II.\
-
Guidance at § II. The Staff noted in the Guidance that “altered sequencing of transactions may be abused to the detriment of other users in certain so-called [maximum extractable value] strategies (e.g., in front running).” Guidance at n. 13.
-
Statement of SEC Commissioner Hester M. Peirce, Interfacing with our Inner Demons: Comments on the Division of Trading and Markets' Statement on Certain User Interfaces (April 13, 2026) (Peirce Statement).\
-
See Peirce Statement (citing SEC v. Coinbase Inc. et. al., 726 F. Supp. 3d. 260, 304-07 (S.D.N.Y. 2024) (rejecting arguments that a wallet service that charged a 1 percent transaction fee was a securities “broker”)).
-
Peirce Statement.
-
See Exchange Act Release No. 92285, Securities and Exchange Commission, In re Neovest, Inc. (June 29, 2021) (Neovest Order); Statement of Commissioner Hester M. Peirce, Securities and Exchange Commission, Statement Regarding Neovest, Inc. (June 29, 2021) (Peirce Neovest Dissent).
-
Neovest Order at 3-6. Prior to being acquired by JPMorgan Chase, Neovest engaged in its activities through a registered broker-dealer, Neovest Trading Inc. Neovest Order at 3. Neovest withdrew its broker-dealer registration after it was acquired, but, according to the Neovest Order, continued to operate the OEMS by, among other things, “participating in the order-taking and order-routing process and soliciting customers and destination brokers through the firm’s website and direct outreach at industry conferences and trade shows…[as well as playing] a role in determining the routing options that were available to its customers by entering into agreements with destination brokers.” See Press Release, Securities and Exchange Commission, SEC Charges Electronic Trading Platform for Operating as an Unregistered Broker-Dealer (June 29, 2021). In her dissent, Commissioner Peirce argued that “[t]he fact that Neovest, the technology platform, went from being affiliated with one broker-dealer to being affiliated with another broker-dealer does not seem relevant to the question of whether the technology platform itself needed to register.” Peirce Neovest Dissent.
-
Peirce Neovest Dissent. Commissioner Peirce argued further that the Neovest Order “fails to explain how and why the particular services Neovest provided—facilitating the transmission of orders created by customers, including routing instructions, from customers to the customer’s own broker—causes Neovest to effect securities transactions in the accounts of others, which is an essential requirement to meet the statutory definition of a broker.” Peirce Neovest Dissent. She noted that the Neovest Order “makes no finding that Neovest made any recommendations regarding general trading strategies or specific securities, or that it exercised any discretion over any routing decision; it also makes no finding that Neovest held or handled customer funds in connection with any securities transactions or that it negotiated or executed trades.” Peirce Neovest Dissent. Importantly, Commissioner Peirce highlighted that firms offering “a service that provides information and allows customers to transmit messages (including orders) to specific brokers may be ‘facilitating’ securities transactions, but by this measure, so is any other data services vendor, such as an internet service provider or a vendor that provides direct connectivity to an exchange,” and emphasized that the “relevant question here…is whether the activity that the firm is ‘engaged in the business of’ is broker activity, in other words, whether the firm is engaged in the business of effecting transactions in securities on behalf of others.” Peirce Neovest Dissent.
-
Guidance at § II.\
-
See Final Rule, Interpretation, and Guidance, Application of the Federal Securities Laws to Certain Types of Crypto Assets and Certain Transactions Involving Crypto Assets, 91 Fed. Reg. 13714 (March 23, 2026). For in-depth analysis of SEC and CFTC’s joint interpretation, please see our related client alert. See M. Highman et al., SEC and CFTC Issue Joint Interpretation on Crypto Asset Regulation: The Agencies Clarify Application of Federal Securities Laws to Crypto Assets, Norton Rose Fulbright Client Alert (April 2026).\