Introduction
In the four articles of this venture capital series, we discuss some of the most commonly used equity and equity-like instruments used by emerging companies in the UK, the US and Canada. Last week we discussed SAFEs and ASAs.1
In previous weeks we discussed:
- Priced equity rounds
- SAFEs and ASAs
In the coming week we will discuss:
- Token issuances and warrants
Up this week: Convertible debt and warrants
Convertible Debt
Our last article discussed SAFEs and ASAs which are, in essence, a pre-paid right to acquire shares at a future date subject to certain conditions precedent.
Convertible debt (known variously as a “convertible loan note”, “convertible debenture”, “convertible promissory note” and similar phrases), includes a right to acquire shares at a future date, subject to certain conditions precedent, but with one key difference: convertible debt is a loan with an interest rate that, in some cases, may need to be repaid in cash.
Convertible debt (CD) or venture debt may also be issued accompanied by a “sweetener” or “kicker” in the form of a warrant that enables the holder to acquire shares of the company at a pre-determined exercise price for a period of time.
As we noted in our previous article on SAFEs and ASAs, CD is both straightforward and challenging at the same time.
- Straightforward: Generally, one agreement, market standard terms, valuation is determined at a later date.
- Challenging: Ensuring that different investors who invest at different times have the same terms and keeping strict control of the cap table.
Considerations include:
-
Interest rate: CDs carry an interest rate, usually between 5%-10% (although the interest rate tends to vary over time as interest rates change)
-
Valuation: While the company receives the funds on day one, the issuance of shares is deferred to the next specified liquidity event (usually a qualifying funding round in which a certain amount is raised and equity shares are issued), a specified termination or longstop date, or an insolvency event.
- Advantages: may postpone a valuation discussion
- Considerations: many CDs contain a “valuation cap” which means that the price of the shares into which the CD may convert will be the lower of a discounted price per share (usually a 10%-20% discount) and the price per share on a valuation cap.
-
Conversion to equity:
- Automatic conversion to equity will usually happen on a trigger event such as an exit (for example, IPO), a qualifying funding round, change of control or M&A transaction.
- There is usually an optional conversion where a certain majority threshold of noteholders can decide to convert at a particular time or on the occurrence of a particular event (such as a change of control).
-
Control: CD holders are not shareholders of the company, so will not have any rights as shareholders
- Advantages: no lengthy investor documents
- Considerations: investors may request a side letter which contains some typical shareholder rights, including director appointment rights, specific approval rights, information rights, or any regulatory rights and the company may be required to undertake that such rights will be included in any shareholders agreement and amended articles adopted at the conversion event.
-
Ranking: If carefully drafted, the CD is treated as debt (albeit subordinated and unsecured) and in the event of insolvency, debt ranks higher than equity in the liquidation preference waterfall, which is an advantage over other convertible equity instruments.
Cautionary note: The treatment of CDs from a tax and bankruptcy perspective can vary from jurisdiction to jurisdiction. -
Unique to the United Kingdom: Tax relief such as SEIS and EIS are not available for CDs as the tax relief only applies to equity and not to loans even if the loan converts to equity at a later date.
Warrants
A warrant is a contractual financial instrument which gives an investor the right, but not the obligation, to subscribe for shares at a specific time in future for a predetermined price (or a price based on a valuation in a future funding round (usually discounted)).
- Compared to a CD, ASA or SAFE, typically no funds are invested on issue and so an equity warrant is usually granted alongside other forms of investment.
- For example, in venture debt structures, it is typical for warrants to be granted to give lenders additional upside in addition to the repayment of principal and interest.
Warrants can also be tied to satisfaction by strategic investors of certain milestones (e.g. completing a pilot relationship with the investee company as a commercial partner).
Quick Summary
Below is a table comparing the key features of a priced equity round, ASA, SAFE and CD.
| Funding structure | Time consuming / long form documents | Valuation of company or price per share decided at a later date? | Repayable? | Maturity date? |
| Priced equity round | Yes | No | No | No |
| ASA | No | Yes | No | No |
| SAFE | No | Yes | No | No |
| CD | No | Yes | Yes (plus interest) | Yes |
| Equity Warrant | No | Yes | No | Yes |