Fire and rehire has long acted as the final lever when employee agreement cannot be reached on changes to employee terms and conditions. From January 2027 an employer’s ability to use this lever will be severely restricted: using fire and rehire to change core contractual terms, including pension terms, will constitute automatic unfair dismissal.

Refresher: Fire and rehire

Fire and rehire is where an employer dismisses an employee and then rehires them back on new (often worse) terms.

Employers have often used it as a backstop where employees will not agree to changes to their terms and conditions. A new Code of Practice on dismissal and re-engagement came into effect in July 2024 encouraging employers to only use this practice as a “last resort”.

In a pensions context, it can be a tool to implement closure to future accrual where a scheme’s amendment power is restrictive or where employees have contractual entitlements to remain in a scheme. Where this is the case, employees, with whom a direct agreement cannot be reached, are dismissed and then rehired on contracts that give effect to closure to future accrual.

From January 2027: Fire and rehire will usually be unlawful

From January 2027 (or other date the government confirms), fire and rehire will be an automatically unfair dismissal where the change relates to a ‘restricted variation’.

‘Restricted variations’ include changes relating to pensions, pay, hours, holiday, expenses and benefits and changes to shift patterns (the extent of these two restricted variations are currently subject to consultation) or introducing a clause enabling one of these restricted areas to be amended. It catches written, implied and verbal terms.

There is an exception for employers in serious trouble

There is an exception, but it has a very high bar to meet. An employer must show that:

  • It is in severe financial difficulty.
  • Those difficulties are likely to affect its ability to continue as a going concern in the immediate future.

The government expects this to apply only in rare cases.

Even where the exception is met, it’s not a free pass. The employer must still show that the dismissal was fair in all the circumstances.

Getting it wrong can be costly

Where dismissal is unfair, the Employment Tribunal may award compensation to the employee. Compensation may increase by up to 25 per cent if the employer fails to follow the statutory Code of Practice on dismissal and re-engagement. It is also important to be aware that from January 1, 2027, the government is proposing to remove the cap on unfair dismissal compensation.

Comment

Fire and rehire has been a useful, but increasingly controversial, backstop for employers.

For defined benefit schemes, it has sometimes been a helpful option to consider, where the amendment power is limited and/or agreement cannot be reached with either a scheme’s trustees or the employees themselves. This option is about to be shut off.

If your scheme is thinking about closing to accrual you should examine your scheme’s powers (and employee terms) to understand whether this change in the law may affect your proposals. Depending on that you may want to consider bringing your timetable forward (bearing in mind that closure to accrual would also necessitate a statutory consultation period of at least 60 days).

The impact is not limited to pension changes. Fire and rehire has been used to force through changes to other core contractual terms including pay, hours, holidays and shift patterns where employees do not agree.

For all changes, the message is clear: the days of pushing through hard changes to employment terms by fire and rehire are coming to an end. Schemes may want to think about steps to take now and review how to implement any changes to pension arrangements.

Other changes to employment rights

If you would like to see the other changes being introduced by the Employment Rights Act 2025, our roadmap highlights the key developments and when they will take effect.

Contact