The Fifteenth Court of Appeals (The Fifteenth Court) in In re ColossusBets Ltd., et al., No. 15-25-00150-CV (Tex. App.—15th 2026) addressed an important jurisdictional question the Fifteenth Court stated “will occur repeatedly if not answered.” Can a plaintiff amend itself out of jurisdiction in the Texas Business Court (Business Court) post-removal?1
The Fifteenth Court ruled that—yes—a plaintiff could amend its petition after removal to divest the Texas Business Court of subject-matter jurisdiction. But the Fifteenth Court was careful to note its ruling was not an invitation for plaintiffs to engage in gamesmanship through artful pleading.
Reed v. Rook, LP , et al: If at first you don’t succeed, try try again
As discussed in our prior coverage of Reed v. Rook TX, LP, et al., the proceeding giving rise to this mandamus appeal involves a unique fact pattern and procedural history that set the stage for the Fifteenth Court’s rulings.
After winning US$7.5 million through the Lotto Texas jackpot, Reed filed suit against Rook TX, LP and other defendants for allegedly rigging a prior lottery and reducing Reed’s winnings.2 Two defendants removed, arguing Reed’s allegations related to entity formation and internal affairs fell within the Business Court’s jurisdiction pursuant to Section 25A.004(b)(2) of the Texas Government Code.3
Reed initially challenged removal by amending his petition and filing a motion to remand, which the Business Court denied, and held jurisdiction in the Business Court was proper.4 But Reed didn’t stop there, amending his petition twice more in an apparent effort to divest the Business Court of jurisdiction.
In his Fourth Amended Petition, Reed asserted only a money had and received claim and “expressly disclaim[ed] any allegation, legal theory, or request for relief that requires th[e] [Business] Court to interpret, apply, or enforce the governance, internal affairs, or governing documents of any Defendant entity.”5
Reed also filed a renewed motion to remand. In response, defendants conceded the Business Court no longer had jurisdiction under Section 25A.004(b)(2) but asserted new jurisdictional grounds, each of which were rejected, and the case was remanded to Travis County District Court.
The Business Court has jurisdiction to review its prior decisions
Following remand, one of the defendants (ColossusBets Limited) sought mandamus relief in the Fifteenth Court of Appeals.6 ColossusBets’s mandamus petition solely focused “on the procedural question whether jurisdiction, once exercised, can be lost.”7
ColossusBets argued remand was improper because the Texas Government Code demands a “one-time, prompt and final determination” of the Business Court’s jurisdiction.8 Once the court denied Reed’s first motion to remand, ColossusBets contended the Business Court lacked authority to reconsider that decision in light of Reed’s subsequent amended petitions.
The Fifteenth Court disagreed, holding that the Business Court not only has the authority, but also the responsibility to review any of its pre-trial orders, including a denial of remand, upon proper motion, regardless of whether jurisdiction was previously confirmed.9
ColossusBets relied on Texas Rule of Civil Procedure 355(f), which provides that the Business Court must remand an action if it determines removal was “improper.” ColossusBets argued the reference to “improper” removal in this rule prevents remand in all other situations, including when removal was initially proper.
The Business Court rejected this interpretation by reference to Rule 354, which requires dismissal or transfer if the court “determines, on a party’s motion or its own initiative, that it does not have the authority to hear the action.”10 Because dismissal or transfer is required regardless of whether the initial filing was proper, the Fifteenth Court reasoned the Business Court had jurisdiction to reconsider its remand order.
Live petition controls for purposes of Business Court jurisdiction
The Fifteenth Court also addressed an issue raised in ColossusBets’s mandamus petition that a plaintiff may divest the Business Court of jurisdiction through “later, forum-shopping pleading amendments.”11 Acknowledging the concern, the Fifteenth Court determined Reed had removed any forum-shopping “risk” by expressly disclaiming any allegation, theory or request for relief that would fall within the Business Court’s jurisdiction.12
The disclaimer, according to the Fifteenth Court, operated as an irrevocable implied waiver of any claims that would grant the Business Court jurisdiction.13 The Fifteenth Court’s holding indicates that once a Business Court plaintiff conclusively and affirmatively abandons its allegations or claims conferring the Business Court jurisdiction, that bell cannot be unrung.
Implications for Business Court practice
Consistent with the long-held and often quoted belief that plaintiffs are the masters of their own petitions, the Fifteenth Court’s decision in In re ColossusBets Ltd., et al. confirmed that jurisdiction in the Business Court is not set in stone even if it initially exists.
The remand and removal framework established by the Fifteenth Court is similar to that of the federal system. In Royal Canin U.S.A., Inc. v. Wullschleger, 604 U.S. 22 (2025), the United States Supreme Court held that once a case has been removed to federal district court, the court must remand the matter to state court if the plaintiff amends his or her complaint to delete all federal claims, thereby depriving the federal court of federal question jurisdiction.14
In line with this reasoning, federal courts have upheld remands to state court where the plaintiff has comprehensively disclaimed any right to relief under federal law, similar to Reed’s disclaimer of claims, allegations and relief within Business Court jurisdiction.15
The Fifteenth Court did note that “allowing Reed to continue to add or delete pleadings to manipulate Business Court jurisdiction would prejudice” ColossusBets,16 potentially leaving the door open for future litigants to argue prejudice if a litigant amends out of Business Court jurisdiction without disclaiming its ability to later add claims that fall within the court’s jurisdiction.
Footnotes
-
In re ColossusBets Ltd., et al., No. 15-25-00150-CV, 2026 WL 392034, at *1 (Tex. App. [15th Dist.] Feb. 12, 2026).
-
See Pl.’s Original Pet., Reed v. Rook TX LP et al., No. D-1-GN-25-002446, 353rd Judicial District, Travis County.
-
Notice of Removal to Business Court, Reed, No. D-1-GN-25-002446.
-
See Pl.’s Mot. to Remand, Reed v. Rook TX LP et al., No. 25-BC03A-0007, Division 3A, Business Court, Travis County.
-
Pl.’s Fourth Am. Pet., Reed, No. 25-BC03A-0007, at ¶ 84.
-
Pet. for Writ of Mandamus (“Mandamus Pet.”), In re ColossusBets Ltd. et al, No. 15-25-00150-CV, Fifteenth Court of Appeals.
-
Id. at 4.
-
See id. at 23–28.
-
ColossusBets Ltd., 2026 WL 392034, at *2–3.
-
Id. at *3.
-
Mandamus Pet., ColossusBets Ltd., No. 15-25-00150-CV, at 4.
-
ColossusBets Ltd., 2026 WL 392034, at *3.
-
Id.
-
Royal Canin, 604 U.S. at 43–44.
-
See, e.g., California v. Express Scripts, Inc., 154 F.4th 1069, 1077–90 (9th Cir. 2025).
-
ColossusBets Ltd., 2026 WL 392034, at *3 n.24.
Tracking activities of the Texas Business Court and beyond