Introduction
In February 2026, prediction markets came under scrutiny from both Congress and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). On February 23, six Senate Democrats issued a letter to CFTC Chairman Michael Selig urging the CFTC to prohibit prediction contracts that may correlate with or incentivize death, war, terrorism, assassination and other geopolitical outcomes (the Senators’ Letter). Two days later, on February 25, the CFTC’s Enforcement Division issued an advisory (the Prediction Markets Advisory) following the release of two enforcement actions involving misuse of non‑public information and fraud in prediction markets. The Prediction Markets Advisory emphasized that all trading practices prohibited under the Commodity Exchange Act (the CEA) and CFTC Rules apply equally to transactions involving prediction contracts. Finally, on March 9, CFTC Chairman Selig announced that he had instructed CFTC Staff to prepare an advanced notice of proposed rulemaking on prediction markets.
Taken together, these actions highlight a growing regulatory focus on:
- The permissibility of political event contracts.
- Compliance with insider trading, fraud and related prohibited trading practices in prediction markets.
This legal update outlines these developments and provides key takeaways for market participants.
Background on prediction market
Prediction markets are platforms on which participants may trade contracts tied to the occurrence or non-occurrence of future events. These contracts (referred to here as “event contracts” or “prediction contracts”) typically provide a payout based on whether the specified outcome occurs, with contract prices tied to the market’s assessment of the probability of such event. Prediction market contracts have been made with reference to a range of events, including political, financial, cultural and sporting events.
As prediction markets have expanded in scope and interest, their status under US law has increasingly attracted attention from regulators, policy makers and the public. In particular, as the events traded on prediction markets have evolved, their correlation to controversial subject matter such as war, death, assassination and terrorism, has raised public policy and national security concerns, while raising practical questions about the potential for insider trading where outcomes may be influenced by market participants.
Regulatory framework
The following statutory and regulatory provisions address the authority of the CFTC to determine the permissibility of event contracts to be listed for trading on CFTC-designated contract markets (DCMs):
Section 5c(c)(5)(C)(i) of the CEA states that the CFTC “may determine” that event contracts are “contrary to the public interest” if the contracts involve:
- “activity that is unlawful under any Federal or State law;
- terrorism;
- assassination;
- war;
- gaming; or
- other similar activity determined by the Commission, by rule or regulation, to be contrary to the public interest.”
Section 5c(c)(5)(C)(ii) of the CEA states that no contract determined by the CFTC to be contrary to the public interest under clause (i) above may be listed for trading on a DCM.
CFTC Rule 40.11(a) prohibits a DCM from listing for trading:
- A contract that “involves, relates to, or references terrorism, assassination, war, gaming, or an activity that is unlawful under any State or Federal law;” or
- A contract that [i] “involves, relates to, or references an activity that is similar to an activity” in CFTC Rule 40.11 (a)(1) above and [ii] the CFTC determines to be contrary to the public interest.
Senators’ Letter
On February 23, 2026, six Senate Democrats (Senators Adam Schiff (D-CA), Catherine Cortez Masto (D-NV), Richard Blumenthal (D-CT), Cory Booker (D-NJ), Tim Kaine (D-VA) and Jacky Rosen (D-NV)) issued a letter to CFTC Chairman Michael Selig “expressing strong concern with prediction contracts that incentivize physical injury or death,” and calling upon the CFTC to prohibit “any contract that resolves upon or closely correlates to an individual’s death.” The Senators’ Letter claimed such prediction contracts “present dangerous national security risks” by creating incentives to “incite violence, foment geopolitical conflicts and disclose classified information.”
The Senators’ Letter posed seven detailed questions to the CFTC Chairman, including whether the CFTC will interpret contracts that resolve upon death as contrary to the public interest, how the CFTC currently defines the prohibited categories of war, terrorism and assassination, and whether the CFTC will call in contracts related to geopolitical conflicts for review. The Senators demanded responses no later than March 9, 2026.
To illustrate the Senators’ concerns, the Senators’ Letter focused on three specific contracts posted on Polymarket.1 The Senators claimed that a “reasonable individual would interpret” these contracts “as likely prohibited” under CEA Section 5c(c)(5)(C)(i).
“Artemis II explodes?”
The first contract addressed in the Senators’ Letter was Polymarket’s “Artemis II explodes?” contract, for which “YES” traded as high as 8 percent before the contract was ultimately withdrawn due to public backlash. The Senators argued that this contract was directly correlated with crewmember death and “incentivized the failure of the mission and potential insider sabotage.” Although Polymarket posted on X.com that the contract was intended to reference a potential “booster-stage rupture” (rather than the safety of the Orion crew) the Senators argued that a booster-stage rupture on Artemis II “would very strongly correlate with crewmember injury or loss of life.”
“Maduro out by…”
The second contract addressed in the Senators’ Letter was Polymarket’s “Maduro out by...” contract, which would pay out if Venezuelan President Nicolás Maduro was “removed from power for any length of time” within the applicable timeframe. On January 5, 2026, reports indicated that an unknown trader placed US$20,000 in bets on this contract when Polymarket’s market price for the contract was US$0.08, approximately two hours before President Trump ordered a military strike on Venezuela; ultimately netting the unknown trader more than US$400,000 in profits. The Senators claimed this occurrence illustrates how government officials, regulated entities, consultants and other parties can capitalize on confidential or operationally sensitive information for personal profit in markets that operate with, what the Senators claim to be, “minimal oversight or transparency.”
“Will Russia capture Myrnohad by…”
The third contract addressed in the Senators’ Letter was a Polymarket contract on whether the Ukrainian town of Myrnohad would be captured by Russian forces by November 15, 2025. When the contract resolved as “YES” it resulted in profits of as much as 33,000 percent for those who bet correctly, though subsequent public reporting indicated that a staffer at an authoritative think tank had edited its map to show that Russia had taken control of a key intersection in the town “despite the lack of indications that Russia had made any such advance.” The Senators characterized this as a contract that unambiguously “involves, relates to or references” war, and highlights the dangers of listing such contracts.
CFTC Prediction Markets Advisory
On February 25, 2026, the CFTC’s Division of Enforcement issued an advisory following the public release of two enforcement cases involving “misuse of nonpublic information and fraud” with respect to event contracts traded on KalshiEX (Kalshi), a CFTC-Designated Contract Market (DCM). While Kalshi’s enforcement program had addressed these matters internally, the CFTC Division of Enforcement issued the Prediction Markets Advisory to assert that under the CEA, the CFTC retains full authority to police illegal trading practices occurring on any DCM.
The Prediction Markets Advisory enumerated several categories of prohibited practices subject to CFTC enforcement, including:
- Misappropriation of confidential information in breach of a pre-existing duty of trust and confidence (commonly known as “insider trading”)
- Pre-arranged, noncompetitive trading and wash sales
- Disruptive trading practices
- Fraud and manipulation under various sections of the CEA
The advisory further noted that DCMs have an “independent duty pursuant to the core principles of the [CEA] to maintain audit trails, conduct surveillance and enforce rules against prohibited practices,” and that the Division will investigate and prosecute violations in appropriate cases.
Cases addressed in the Prediction Markets Advisory
Political candidate trading on his own candidacy
The first case noted by the CFTC arose in May 2025, when a political candidate traded on his own candidacy on Kalshi in violation of Kalshi’s rules which prohibit trading in a contract over which the trader has direct or indirect influence over the outcome. Kalshi fined the trader US$2,246.36 (consisting of disgorgement of US$246.36 in trading profits plus a US$2,000.00 penalty) and a five-year suspension from the exchange. The CFTC Division of Enforcement noted that, based on the underlying facts, the trader potentially violated Section 6(c)(1) of the CEA and Regulation 180.1(a)(1) and (3), which prohibit “use of a manipulative scheme or artifice to defraud, or engaging or attempting to engage in an act, practice or course of business that operates as a fraud on any other person.”
Insider trading
The second case arose in August and September 2025, when an individual traded a prediction contract related to a YouTube channel with which the trader was employed or affiliated, giving the trader access to relevant non-public information. Following Kalshi’s investigation of the trader’s “highly successful trades,” Kalshi fined the trader US$20,397.58 (consisting of disgorgement of US$5,397.58 in trading profits plus a US$15,000.00 penalty) and a two-year suspension from the exchange. The CFTC Division of Enforcement noted that, based on the underlying facts, the trader potentially violated “prohibitions on misappropriation of confidential information in breach of a pre-existing duty of trust and confidence to the source of the information” (also known as “insider trading”) pursuant to Section 6(c)(1) of the CEA and Regulation 180.1(a)(1) and (3).
Key takeaways and recommendations
Heightened regulatory scrutiny
The Senators’ Letter and CFTC Prediction Markets Advisory signal efforts by both legislators and the CFTC to enhance regulatory oversight of prediction markets. While the Senators’ Letter focuses on contracts implicating war, death and national security, the CFTC Advisory focuses on insider trading, fraud and market manipulation. Together, these initiatives reflect heightened focus on prediction markets and an increased willingness by the CFTC to pursue enforcement where violations occur.
CFTC forthcoming rulemaking
In a speech on March 9, CFTC Chairman Selig announced that he directed CFTC staff to “draft guidance addressing how event contracts may be listed and traded” and noted that “the CFTC will be an active and vigilant overseer of these markets.” In addition, he noted that he had “asked staff to prepare an advanced notice of proposed rulemaking so that the agency can solicit critical feedback on important issues permeating throughout this market.” 2
Insider trading and information barriers
The CFTC’s advisory makes clear that traditional prohibitions on misappropriation of confidential information apply with full force to prediction contracts. Market participants that may be the subject of prediction contracts, or whose employees may have access to material non-public information as to the subject matter of prediction contracts should implement robust personal trading and compliance protocols to mitigate the risk of enforcement action.
Prohibited contract categories
Market operators should carefully assess whether prediction contracts could be viewed as “involving, relating to or referencing” terrorism, assassination, war or similar activity prohibited under CEA Section 5c(c)(5)(C) and CFTC Rule 40.11. The Senators’ Letter urged the CFTC to adopt an expansive interpretation of these provisions, arguing that contracts that closely correlate with death, physical harm or geopolitical violence (even if not expressly framed in those terms) should be deemed contrary to the public interest. To date, however, the CFTC has not formally endorsed this “correlation‑based” standard and has instead emphasized enforcement of existing prohibitions on insider trading, fraud and market manipulation, while signaling that broader questions regarding the permissible scope of event contracts may be addressed through forthcoming rulemaking.
Offshore platforms with US nexus
The Senate letter’s focus on Polymarket, a US-headquartered company operating an offshore exchange, highlights the risk that US regulatory authority may be asserted over platforms with a US nexus, even where US users are nominally restricted from access. Entities operating prediction markets from the United States or with significant US connections should assess their regulatory exposure accordingly. Notably, the three Polymarket contracts cited in the Senators’ Letter appear to have been listed after Polymarket received CFTC approval in November 2025, suggesting that the CFTC would have clear jurisdictional authority over those contracts under existing frameworks. However, the Senators’ broader focus on Polymarket’s US headquarters and operations underscores the risk that regulators may look beyond formal exchange registration status to assert authority over platforms with significant US connections, particularly where US-based personnel, infrastructure or capital are involved.
DCM compliance obligations
The CFTC’s advisory reaffirmed that DCMs bear an independent obligation under the CEA’s core principles to maintain audit trails, conduct surveillance and enforce rules against prohibited trading practices. DCMs operating prediction markets should review and, where necessary, enhance their compliance and surveillance programs to detect and address the types of violations identified in the advisory.
We will continue to monitor these developments closely. For questions regarding the implications of these regulatory actions for your business, please contact Mark Highman, Stephan Ariyan or Matthew Melbourn.
Footnotes
-
Polymarket is a US company headquartered in New York City that recently acquired QCEZ, a CFTC-registered DCM. See CFTC Amended Designation Order issued to QCX LLC d/b/a Polymarket US, November 24, 2025.
-
See CFTC Chairman Michael Selig, Speech at the FIA Global Cleared Markets Conference, March 9, 2026.