By making partial payments under an insurance policy and issuing a reservation of rights letter after advising the insured that defence counsel would be appointed, insurers were not permitted to deny coverage.

In August 2019, Neil Borgatti’s vessel collided with another vessel in the dark, resulting in Borgatti’s death and injuries to passengers on both vessels. Earlier that evening, the vessel’s navigation lights were not functioning, so Borgatti relied on improvised lighting (putting an illuminated fish finder at the bow) to make his vessel visible.

The vessel was insured through the Elite Insurance Company d.b.a. Aviva. Aviva paid the Borgatti estate for damage to the vessel in May 2020 and paid the accidental death benefit in June 2020. Beginning in November 2020, five lawsuits were filed against the estate. Aviva advised the estate it would appoint defence counsel in those proceedings and a waiver to file defences had been obtained in the meantime.

Shortly before actually appointing defence counsel, Aviva wrote to the estate indicating that Borgatti may have breached the policy and Aviva was reserving its rights in relation to coverage for the lawsuits.

Insurer’s position

Aviva’s policy contained both suspensive conditions and warranties. A breach of a suspensive condition suspends coverage from the date of the breach until the breach is remedied, whereas a breach of a warranty terminates coverage without the option for reinstatement. The policy included a warranty regarding safety equipment stating (emphasis in original):

Warranted that the insured watercraft is equipped with all of the safety equipment, including fire extinguishers, required by law and that all of the equipment is kept in good and efficient working order at all times.

In March 2021, the estate’s administrator filed an action in the Federal Court, seeking a declaration that the estate’s liability for the personal injury claims arising from the collision was limited to $1 million under the Marine Liability Act. The Federal Court subsequently stayed all other proceedings relating to the collision.

Aviva then filed an action in Federal Court against Borgatti, the estate, and the estate’s administrator leading to this summary judgment motion. In March 2025, Aviva brought the motion seeking:

  1. A declaration that claims made against the estate in relation to the collision were not covered by the Aviva policy.
  2. A declaration that Aviva owed no contractual indemnity to the defendants under the terms and conditions of the Aviva policy and no defence was required.

Issues before the court

One issue was whether Borgatti had breached the warranty, thereby relieving Aviva of its obligation to indemnify. Aviva argued the warranty was breached because the vessel’s navigation lights were not functioning at the time of the collision, and coverage had ceased. The defendants argued the warranty did not apply to navigation lights, or alternatively, the Marine Insurance Act prevented Aviva from denying coverage on that basis.

The court declined to decide this issue, holding it would not be in the interests of justice to make findings that could prejudice the defendant (the estate) in the ongoing tort litigation. Determining whether the warranty was breached would require findings regarding the operability of the vessel’s lights, which could be relevant to the estate’s liability in related actions.

A second issue raised was whether Aviva was barred from relying on the warranty by the operation of waiver, laches, and/or estoppel. The court found that both waiver and laches were inapplicable but considered whether Aviva was estopped from denying coverage. Estoppel requires:

  1. The parties were in a legal relationship at the time of the promise or assurance giving rise to the estoppel.
  2. The promise or assurance was intended to affect that relationship and was acted upon.
  3. The other party relied on the promise or assurance to their detriment.

The first element was satisfied by the policy’s existence. Regarding the second element, the court noted an insurer cannot be said to have promised coverage if it lacked knowledge of the facts leading to the alleged breach. The defendants pointed to Aviva’s payment of the damage claim and accidental death benefit as representing a promise or implication that the claim was covered. Aviva argued it lacked sufficient information at the time of payment to know of any potential breach.

The court rejected Aviva’s position. Aviva was found to have obtained evidence from the surviving vessel passenger in September 2019 and from a third-party investigation in February 2020 that the navigation lights were malfunctioning at the time of the collision. On this basis, the court found that paying the vessel damages and death benefit claims satisfied the second element of the estoppel test.

Regarding the third element, the defendants pointed to Aviva’s disposal of the Borgatti vessel in August 2020, after making the damage and accidental death benefit payments, but before issuing its first reservation of rights letter. The court agreed this deprived the defendants of access to physical evidence that could have been used to challenge Aviva’s later denial of coverage. The court found that these circumstances constituted detrimental reliance sufficient to satisfy the third element of the estoppel test.

In keeping with these findings, the court granted summary judgment in favour of the defendants, holding that Aviva was estopped from denying coverage under the Aviva policy. No appeal was filed.

Takeaway

Insurers may be estopped from later denying coverage after making any payments under a policy to an insured if they knew, or should have known, that coverage is questionable. If the insurer proceeds to make payments without a non-waiver agreement or an adequate reservation of rights letter, it risks being estopped from later denying coverage. Furthermore, the court will not make premature findings of fact on a coverage dispute if doing so will prejudice the insured’s defence on a liability claim.

The author would like to thank Alex Harrison, articling student, for her contribution to preparing this legal update.

Contact