The Texas Business Court recently clarified its jurisdiction in Alamo Title Company v. WFG National Title Company. Although Alamo Title did not plead an amount in controversy, any intellectual property claims or any claims against managers, its allegations of employee raiding and misuse of confidential information satisfied jurisdictional statutes related to intellectual property and breaches of a managerial officer's duties.

The allegations: A coordinated raid

Alamo Title sued WFG National Title Company in Bexar County District Court, claiming WFG raided its employees and customers by misappropriating Alamo's salary details, customer lists and other sensitive business information. Alamo accused WFG of tortiously interfering with current and prospective customer contracts, conspiracy to tortiously interfere and aiding and abetting Alamo's former president and employees in breaching fiduciary duties.

WFG removed the case to the Business Court, claiming that the amount in controversy threshold was met and that the case involved a managerial official's duties and intellectual property issues. Alamo moved to remand, claiming insufficient damages and emphasizing the lack of intellectual property claims and claims against individuals. The Court rejected Alamo's arguments and denied Alamo's motion to remand.

Amount in controversy: Burden-shifting framework

The Court applied a burden-shifting framework to analyze jurisdiction when a petition is silent on the amount in controversy. If the removal notice pleads an amount meeting the threshold, the movant bears the burden to present evidence that the “amount-in-controversy pleadings are fraudulent . . . or that the amount in controversy is readily established as US$5 million or less.”

WFG's removal notice pleaded the amount in controversy exceeded US$5 million, excluding statutory exceptions. WFG relied on Alamo's discovery responses, which disclosed US$4.7 million in damages for 2025 alone. These damages were ongoing and increasing during litigation, and WFG identified additional unjust enrichment amounts.

The Court determined that Alamo presented no rebutting evidence and that it had admitted to a US$4.7 million minimum amount in controversy. Alamo also acknowledged future damages, avoided-cost restitution and incalculable harm to its business, reputation, goodwill and competitive ability.

The Court rejected Alamo's argument that future damages should be excluded from the calculation. The Court held that when pleaded at removal, future damages are included by Texas and federal courts in determining the amount in controversy. With nothing controverting WFG's pleading, the Court held the amount-in-controversy requirement was satisfied.

Had the Court found an insufficient amount in controversy, it could not have exercised jurisdiction over the case. But having cleared that hurdle, the Court was next tasked with determining whether the case satisfied other prongs of the relevant jurisdictional provisions.

Managerial officials: "By reason of" clarification

Where the amount in controversy threshold is met, Texas Government Code Section 25A.004(b)(5) grants jurisdiction over actions alleging an owner, controlling person or managerial official breached a duty owed to an organization “by reason of” the person's status. This includes breaches of loyalty or good faith owed to the organization by such persons.

Alamo's petition pleaded that its former president, Edward Hall, agreed with WFG to tortiously interfere with customer contracts. Alamo alleged Hall used his position to solicit Alamo's employees to depart for WFG. Alamo did not bring causes of action against Hall, but it expressly pleaded that WFG aided and abetted Hall and others in breaching fiduciary duties to Alamo Title.

The Court determined that these allegations implicated Hall’s duties "by reason of" his status as a managerial official per Section 25A.004(b). Although Alamo noted that nonofficer employees might owe narrower fiduciary duties, Alamo did not concede it was merely holding Hall to the standard of a nonofficer employee.

The Court concluded that Alamo's pleading alleged a managerial official's breach of duties owed by reason of his status, providing an independent basis for jurisdiction over the entire action. This analysis clarified how Section 25A.004(b)(5) applies to aiding-and-abetting claims brought against third parties, when the managerial official himself or herself is not a party.

Intellectual property: Broad "relating to" standard

The Court also analyzed whether Alamo's claims satisfied Section 25A.004(d)(4), which grants jurisdiction over actions satisfying the amount in controversy requirement if they “aris[e] out of or relat[e] to the ownership, use, licensing, lease, installation or performance of intellectual property. . . .” The statute explicitly includes trade secrets in the meaning of “intellectual property.”

Alamo's petition did not plead a cause of action for misappropriating intellectual property, but Alamo alleged that WFG misappropriated its sensitive business information, including customer lists and employee compensation details, and transferred this information to WFG for competitive use. The petition claimed Alamo's employee handbook contained confidential-information standards that evidenced the proprietary nature of the information.

Alamo argued the statute required a “stronger connection” between intellectual property allegations and the lawsuit to invoke the Court’s jurisdiction, but the Court held that the phrase “relating to” is broad and does not require a causal link. The Court determined that Alamo’s claims and the suit as a whole “unquestionably” related to Alamo's allegedly confidential information.

Jurisdiction over the entire action

Finally, the Court addressed the scope of its jurisdiction, analyzing statutory language that gives the Court jurisdiction over “an action” that satisfies the relevant statutory subsections. The Court determined that "action" meant the entire case, subject only to statutory exclusions not relevant here. Therefore, the Court held that each prong granted jurisdiction over the entire action, not just specific claims.

Implications for Business Court practice

Alamo Title demonstrates that the Texas Business Court can exercise jurisdiction in the absence of a pleaded amount in controversy, a managerial official as a party and a cause of action for misappropriating intellectual property—as long as the factual allegations themselves satisfy a subsection of the jurisdictional statute. This ruling underscores the Court's broad jurisdictional reach over business litigation.

card-grid-item, aem-sourced
Visit Texas Business Court Insider

Tracking activities of the Texas Business Court and beyond

/en/insights/publications/texas-business-court-insider
card-grid-item
Watch our Texas Business Court Insider video series
https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLlsj6t9wp-1OU2Ffz9kgS2eZvGOowQCw_

Contact