When something looks wrong, how a member raises it matters as much as raising it at all.
Mr L retired at 52 and expected pension increases from age 55, backdated to the date payment began. When his pension more than doubled at age 55 he queried it several times by telephone. Each time the administrator confirmed the amount was correct. The administrator later uncovered a mistake and sought recovery of an overpayment of £53,125. Mr L accepted the reduction to the correct level but argued the scheme should not recover the overpayments because he had acted in good faith and relied on the reassurances he had been given.
The Ombudsman accepted that Mr L had made enquiries but found that these enquiries were too vague to trigger a proper review. If Mr L had highlighted the size of the increase, the administrator would likely have checked the records and identified the error. In practice the administrator appears to have only checked that an increase was due, and not the amount of the increase. Mr L’s verbal enquiries, on their own, did not establish a good faith defence and the full overpayment remained recoverable. The Ombudsman also noted that there was no evidence of financial hardship that would prevent repayment.
Commentary
The case is fact specific but does have broader application. When figures appear unusual a member stating they queried something verbally may not be enough. Setting concerns out in writing, with figures, creates a proper audit trail and enables a meaningful review.
For schemes, the decision underlines the importance of keeping detailed notes of member interactions. Administrators may also wish to tell members who raise verbal concerns to follow up in writing with the relevant details.