Download report

As we begin 2026 and look back on a year of substantial regulatory developments in the Canadian financial services sector, it has become increasingly evident that managing general agent (MGA) regulation is gaining prominence among insurance regulators, driven by efforts to close oversight gaps and strengthen consumer protection measures.

Current situation: MGA licensing and regulation

Currently, Saskatchewan and New Brunswick are the only jurisdictions where the respective insurance regulators issue MGA licences, where application of licensing requirements is based on regulated activities. In Ontario, the Registered Insurance Brokers of Ontario licenses property and casualty MGAs, although on a voluntary, opt-in basis.

In the remaining common law provinces, MGAs are generally regulated as agencies or brokerages under the existing insurance licensing frameworks, given they do not issue licences applicable for MGAs specifically.

Proposed rule 2025-001: Life and health managing general agents

On November 19, 2025, the Financial Services Regulatory Authority of Ontario (FSRA) closed its second consultation for the Proposed Rule 2025-001, following a revised draft released on October 20, 2025, that was meant to address industry feedback received during the first consultation in January and March 2025.

Key highlights of the proposed rule

Key highlights of the proposed rule apply to entities that, under agreement with a life insurer, perform defined functions such as recruiting, screening, training and supervising agents, or transmitting applications. Sub-MGAs and certain third-party administrators are included, while property and casualty (P&C) MGAs and entities limited to accident
and sickness (A&S) business underwritten by P&C insurers are excluded.

Licensed MGAs must:

  • Maintain proportionate compliance systems
  • Appoint a designated compliance representative independent from sales
  • Carry errors and omissions plus liability insurance

Insurers remain accountable for distribution conduct and must monitor MGA compliance, notify the FSRA of agreements and material changes, and maintain continuity plans.

FSRA adopts an MGA tiered system to address disproportionality in compliance burdens

A key innovation in Ontario’s revised draft is the three-tier structure, designed to relate obligations based on an MGA’s role:

  • Tier 1 MGAs contract directly with life insurers and bear the most extensive compliance responsibilities, including robust systems for agent screening, training, and monitoring
  • Tier 2 MGAs operate as sub MGAs, contracting with other MGAs or agents rather than insurers. Their obligations are lighter but still include oversight of delegated activities and reporting
  • Tier 3 MGAs form a residual category for entities performing specified functions without direct insurer contracts, such as training or recruitment support

While the tiered system aims to clarify expectations, it introduces certain complexities. For example, MGAs with diverse arrangements may fall into multiple tiers simultaneously, requiring them to comply with obligations across products and counterparties.

Issues and challenges

The FSRA’s revisions to the proposed rule are welcome developments; however, there remain certain outstanding challenges:

  1. Breadth of Capture and Overlap
    The statutory definition of “managing general agent” and the residual Tier 3 category are so broad that entities not traditionally considered MGAs (such as national account structures, training providers, and certain third-party administrators) could be swept in. FSRA has acknowledged that some organizations may need to comply with both the new MGA licensing regime and the existing agent licensing framework, creating duplication and uncertainty.
  2. Scope Split and Competitive Distortion
    The rule applies only to life and A&S products underwritten by life insurers, excluding A&S products underwritten by P&C carriers. This creates an uneven playing field and may incentivize distributors to shift A&S business to P&C insurers to avoid the new regime, potentially disadvantaging life carriers and reducing consumer choice.
  3. Complexity of Tiering
    While tiering was introduced to improve proportionality, it adds operational complexity. MGAs with multiple business lines may fall into different tiers simultaneously, requiring them to map obligations across products and counterparties. This could lead to fragmented compliance systems and higher administrative costs.
  4. Consultation Process
    The second consultation period was limited to 30 days despite significant revisions, a sharp departure from FSRA’s usual 60-day practice. Stakeholders argue this timeframe was insufficient for meaningful feedback on a rule of this scope and impact, particularly given the need to plan and resource compliance changes.
  5. Harmonization Challenges
    Industry groups have urged FSRA to align more closely with Saskatchewan and New Brunswick’s activity-based models, which have proven effective without imposing undue burden. Ontario’s prescriptive approach risks creating regulatory friction for intermediaries operating nationally and may undermine efforts to harmonize licensing standards across provinces.

Comparing MGA regulatory frameworks

Ontario’s framework appears somewhat complicated relative to those in Saskatchewan and New Brunswick. These provinces use simple, activity-based systems with proportional oversight and a designated compliance contact. Saskatchewan applies one activity list across four licence types, while New Brunswick adjusts its lists by insurance segment (life/A&S vs general/travel).

Saskatchewan New Brunswick Ontario Comments
Regulatory basis MGA licensing regime (since 2020) Rule INS-001 (effective early 2023) FSRA Rule 2025-001 (effective June 2026) Ontario is newest and most prescriptive
Scope of products Life, A&S, crop hail, P&C Life, A&S, general, travel Life and A&S underwritten by life insurers SK and NB cover broader product classes
Licensing approach Activity-based; single activity list Activity-based; lists tailored by segment Broad statutory definition + tiered obligations Ontario introduces structural tiering
Compliance and reporting Compliance aligned with insurer obligations Same as SK Mandatory compliance system; annual return Ontario adds formal annual reporting

Looking ahead

The timeline for implementation underscores the need for early action. FSRA has set June 1, 2026, as the effective date, giving the industry a limited window to prepare before the proposed rule comes into force.

While the two-year transition period ending November 30, 2027, is intended to ease onboarding, it should not be viewed as a grace period. Firms that delay implementation risk bottlenecks in application processing and disruption to distribution arrangements.

Starting preparations now will help organizations meet the new requirements efficiently and maintain continuity in their distribution networks.

Next steps for compliance readiness

To prepare for compliance under the revised L&H MGA Rule, MGAs should:

  • Assess tier classification: Determine whether your organization falls under Tier 1, Tier 2, or Tier 3 for each product line or insurer relationship
  • Map compliance obligations: Review the rule’s requirements for your tier and identify any overlapping obligations with existing FSRA licensing regimes
  • Update internal processes: Implement systems to manage tier-specific compliance, including documentation, reporting, and training
  • Engage early with FSRA: Seek clarification on ambiguous provisions and monitor FSRA’s consultation updates and FAQs
  • Plan for dual licensing: If your activities overlap with other licensing regimes, ensure you have the necessary licences and compliance frameworks in place
card-grid-item, aem-sourced
Financial services in focus

Volume 1: Looking back on key insights from 2025

/en-ca/topics/financial-services-in-focus

Contact