On March 3, 2026, the United States Bankruptcy Court for the Southern District of New York (“US Bankruptcy Court”) issued an opinion denying Xinyuan Real Estate Company Limited’s (“Debtor”) motion to dismiss an involuntary chapter 11 petition (“Chapter 11 Case”). As a result, a Cayman Islands debtor, with minimal contact to the US but meaningful connections to the People’s Republic of China (“PRC”) that was attempting to restructure its debts in the Cayman Islands, remained a debtor in a US Chapter 11 case.

Formed in 2007, the Debtor is a Cayman Islands exempted company serving as the parent company of numerous subsidiaries engaged in real estate and property development primarily in the PRC. As an “exempted company,” the Debtor was not permitted to carry out business in the Cayman Islands except as necessary to carry out its international operations.  The Debtor’s operations were directed and overseen principally from the PRC, where its chairman, CEO and other officers and members of the Debtor’s board resided. Following the downturn of the real estate market in the PRC, the Debtor attempted to restructure billions in funded debt. In January 2025, US$170 million of certain US denominated senior notes governed by New York law (“Senior Notes”) became due and payable and the Debtor commenced restructuring negotiations with the holders of the Senior Notes that same month.

Apparently dissatisfied with the restructuring negotiations, on April 14, 2025, three creditors holding approximately US$65 million in principal amount of the Senior Notes filed an involuntary chapter 11 petition against the Debtor in the US Bankruptcy Court. Thereafter, on June 25, 2025, the Debtor filed a petition in the Cayman Islands (“Cayman Proceeding”) for an order sanctioning a scheme of arrangement, which is akin to a chapter 11 plan, to restructure the Senior Notes under Cayman law (“Scheme”). The Scheme placed all of the Senior Notes into a single class and sought to exchange the Senior Notes for a combination of new notes and perpetual securities and shares issued by the Debtor.

The Debtor sought to dismiss the Chapter 11 Case in deference to the Cayman Proceeding, arguing that creditors and the Debtor would be best served by dismissal. The Debtor emphasized that principles of comity also supported dismissal of the Chapter 11 case in deference to the Cayman Proceeding.

Courts in the US have traditionally dismissed pending US bankruptcy cases in deference to foreign insolvency proceedings. Those courts generally consider whether dismissal or abstention would facilitate a successful resolution in another forum and the purpose for which the US bankruptcy case was filed. In this case, however, the US Bankruptcy Court determined that the Debtor had not shown that dismissal would benefit creditors.

First, the US Bankruptcy Court found that the Debtors did not demonstrate sufficient progress in the Cayman Proceeding, finding that there had been no activity in the Cayman Proceeding since the Scheme was filed and the Debtor had not made any progress in obtaining the support necessary to approve the Scheme. Specifically, while the threshold requirement for approval of the Scheme under Cayman law is 75 percent, the Debtor had only obtained 31 percent of creditor support. Moreover, there had been no hearings in furtherance of the Cayman Proceeding.

Second, in addition to the lack of tangible progress in the Cayman Proceeding, the US Bankruptcy Court did not see a reasonable likelihood of successfully restructuring the Senior Notes under the Scheme because the US Bankruptcy Court was not convinced that placing the Senior Notes in a single class was proper under Cayman law given their varying terms and interest rates.

Third, the US Bankruptcy Court noted that even if the Scheme was ultimately sanctioned in the Cayman Proceeding, the Debtor would need to obtain an order granting recognition to the Cayman Proceeding and enforcing the Scheme in the US under chapter 15 of the Bankruptcy Code. Absent such an order, holders of Senior Notes could exercise their remedies in the US and attempt to collect their claims notwithstanding the terms of the Scheme. The US Bankruptcy Court’s view was that the Debtor would “face significant challenges” in obtaining such an order. In particular, the Debtor would likely not be able to demonstrate that the Cayman Proceeding is a foreign main proceeding or a foreign nonmain proceeding. To establish a foreign main proceeding, the US Bankruptcy Court would have to find that the Cayman Islands is the Debtor’s “center of main interests,” or COMI, which lies where the Debtor conducts its regular business, so that the place is reasonably ascertainable by third parties.1 And, to establish a foreign non-main proceeding, the foreign proceeding must be pending in a country where the debtor has an “establishment,” which is where the debtor conducts nontransitory economic activity.2 While not before it, the US Bankruptcy Court observed that the Debtor’s lack of business operations in the Cayman Islands and continued management in PRC would neither support the finding of COMI nor an establishment in the Cayman Islands. In light of these infirmities, the US Bankruptcy Court denied the motion to dismiss the Chapter 11 Case.

This ruling highlights that a foreign debtor with minimal assets in the US may be the target of an involuntary petition in a US bankruptcy court as a defensive measure to a proposed restructuring in a foreign jurisdiction. Although general principles of comity call for deference to foreign proceedings, a US court may be reluctant to defer if the foreign proceeding is not at a stage where it is comfortable that the interests of all stakeholders are sufficiently protected, or if, in the opinion of the US court, the foreign proceeding is unlikely to be successful. At minimum, a foreign debtor should be prepared to demonstrate the foreign proceeding will limit delay and demonstrate a reasonable likelihood of success.

Recent articles

  • content-type:insights/blog
  • content-type:generic
  • nrf-migrated:article-categories/inside-disputes/type/blog-post