In Anheuser-Busch International Inc and another v Commonwealth Brewery Ltd [2026] UKPC 8, the Privy Council identified a non-exhaustive set of seven principal factors that may guide courts when determining the length of a "reasonable" notice period for termination where an obligation to give reasonable notice is to be implied into a distribution agreement.

The judgment provides an authoritative review of English and Commonwealth case law and reflects a restrained, fact-sensitive approach. The decision centres on the premise that commercial relationships involve risk-taking, and therefore that a period of notice is not intended to protect the notice recipient from all financial loss, but rather to enable a sensible “period for adjustment”.

If commercial parties want greater certainty regarding the length of notice on termination, they can agree a notice period as part of any written agreement.

Background

Anheuser-Busch International Inc (ABI) and Burns House Limited (BHL) entered into an oral contract in 1975, giving BHL the exclusive right to distribute products supplied by ABI’s parent company, Anheuser-Busch InBev NV (AB InBev) in the Bahamas (the Distribution Agreement). These products were provided to BHL by Cerveceria Nacional Dominicana SA (CND), which itself was indirectly controlled by AB InBev. Despite continuing for almost 40 years, the Distribution Agreement was never formalised in writing. No express provisions relating to a notice period in the event of termination were ever agreed.

On 12 August 2015, ABI and CND issued a termination letter to BHL which provided for three months’ notice, suggesting that this was a reasonable notice period in the context of the Distribution Agreement. BHL rejected this, and instead argued that a reasonable notice period would be three and a half years (representing one month for each year of the Distribution Agreement).

This progressed to a dispute, with ABI and CND commencing proceedings against BHL in the Bahamas in 2016. In 2022, the first instance judge held that a reasonable notice period would have been 15 months. The Bahamas Court of Appeal rejected this, holding that a range of three to six months was reasonable and that the notice actually given by ABI and CND fell within that range. BHL’s parent company, Commonwealth Brewery Ltd, subsequently appealed to the Privy Council.

The non-exhaustive seven-factor framework

The Privy Council ultimately dismissed the appeal, finding that the Bahamas Court of Appeal was entitled to conclude that the three months’ notice given by ABI and CND was a reasonable period of notice.

The Board identified from case law a non-exhaustive seven-factor framework to apply when assessing the length of a reasonable notice period to be implied into a distribution agreement. The Board noted that the key focus is to ensure that the notice period (i) allows for the orderly winding up of the business relationship; and (ii) provides the notice recipient the opportunity to make “substantial progress” towards alternative arrangements – thereby “cushioning” it from the effect of the termination. Importantly, these factors are not a mechanical checklist: they matter only insofar as they bear on what is a reasonable period for orderly termination and adjustment of the parties’ commercial businesses.

(1) Formality of the contract: A well-established, regular relationship (rather than an ad hoc or occasional arrangement) may point to a longer notice period where it makes post-termination adjustment more difficult for the notice recipient. However, even where the relationship is well-established, the specific absence of a written contract may be relevant to this factor: it shows that the parties did not choose to protect themselves by agreeing a fixed notice period, which may point against a long notice period if other factors are equal. In this case, the Distribution Agreement was not ad hoc or ephemeral, but the fact that it was not reduced to writing meant that this did not itself justify a lengthy notice period.

(2) Length of the relationship: This factor should not be considered in isolation and feeds into factor (3) below. A long relationship which also represents a high proportion of the notice recipient’s turnover will be much more significant than a long relationship that only amounts to a small proportion of the notice recipient’s business.

(3) Significance of the relationship: The Board noted that this factor was of “central importance” in considering whether the notice recipient can adjust to the termination with ease or with difficulty. Factors (1) and (2) above also feed into the assessment of significance. In this case, the distribution of AB InBev products represented less than 10% of BHLs total turnover, and BHL was not restricted from distributing competing products – as such, adjustment post-termination was likely to be easier.

(4) Extent of investment in resources: The extent of investment of financial, management and personnel resources into the relationship is also a relevant factor. If a large proportion of the notice recipient’s workforce is deployed in relation to the distribution agreement, this will point towards a more difficult adjustment post-termination (and, subsequently, towards a longer notice period). In this case, the Board considered that the evidence did not show BHL’s brand manager and other dedicated staff costs were anything other than normal distributorship expenditure, or that those staff could not be promptly redeployed.

(5) Extraordinary capital expenditure: Extraordinary capital expenditure which relates specifically to the business relationship being terminated and which would not otherwise have been incurred (particularly if this expenditure is incurred shortly before termination) will point towards a longer notice period. This must be distinguished from ordinary capital expenditure – in this case, BHL had upgraded its plant and refrigeration facilities, but this upgrade benefitted all of the refrigerated products it distributed and did not appear to be extraordinary expenditure attributable only or principally to the Distribution Agreement.

(6) Third-party commitments: Commitments entered into primarily for the purpose of servicing the business relationship (and which may themselves be difficult to terminate) will operate in favour of a longer notice period.

(7) Ongoing performance obligations during notice: If both parties must continue to perform onerous contractual obligations during the notice period, this can give rise to practical difficulties. The Board held that the existence of such obligations points strongly against a long period of notice. In this case, BHL would have been required to use its staff to promote ABI’s products during the notice period, whilst simultaneously trying to adjust its own business in response to the termination. Similarly, ABI would be obliged to continue supplying to BHL despite actively seeking a new distributor. This required consideration of both parties’ interests, because a longer notice period would have tied ABI and BHL into an unwanted relationship while each was trying to plan for its end.

Key takeaways

Ultimately, the Board stressed that the reasonable notice period is not intended to protect the notice recipient from all potential losses arising from the termination of the relationship. If the parties had wanted greater certainty or a fixed period of protection, they could have stated this expressly at the time of contracting; by leaving the position to an implied term, the parties accepted the ordinary commercial risk that some loss of turnover or profit may result while the recipient adjusts.

Whilst the judgment provides welcome clarity for businesses operating under informal or unwritten distribution arrangements, it also operates as a reminder that there is no substitute for a written contract with an agreed notice period when it comes to certainty (and, subsequently, mitigating the risk of disputes). It also demonstrates that courts will assess reasonableness by reference to the practical ability of both parties to wind down and adjust, rather than by asking how long it would take the notice recipient to replace all lost profits.

With thanks to Emily Simpson for her assistance in preparing this post.

Subscribe to our Inside Disputes blog to receive regular expert insights into banking and commercial litigation in the English courts and issues relevant to investigations.

Recent articles

  • content-type:insights/blog
  • content-type:generic
  • nrf-migrated:article-categories/inside-disputes/type/blog-post