In White & Ors v Uber London Ltd & Ors [2025] EWHC 2972 (Comm), the Commercial Court ordered that costs budgeting should apply to a group action against Uber despite the value of the claims (at £340 million) being “very significantly in excess of” the £10 million threshold at which costs budgeting would normally cease to apply. The decision will be of interest to parties to large claims, particularly group claims, as where approved costs budgets are ordered they will limit exposure to adverse costs orders, which may assist claimants in bringing such claims.
Background
In summary, the group action comprises claims by some 13,000 London black cab drivers against three parts of the Uber group for unlawful means conspiracy. The claims arise out of Uber’s application for a private hire vehicle operators licence for London. The claimants allege that Uber misrepresented the nature of its business operating model, and the licence should not have been granted as it enabled Uber to make a profit at the expense of the claimants.
At a case management conference, the Court ordered the determination of a preliminary issue on limitation that focused on when the claimants discovered, or could with reasonable diligence have discovered, the alleged fraud or deliberate concealment. The judgment deals with various issues including the sampling approach to the preliminary issue, but this article focuses on the defendants’ application for an order that CPR 3.12 and PD 3D on costs budgeting should not apply to the claim. The application was required because the claim forms as served did not contain a statement that the claims were valued at more than £10 million, the threshold at which costs budgeting normally ceases to apply, although on the pleadings the value of the claims is about £340 million.
Decision
The Court summarised the principles it should consider when deciding whether to order costs budgeting in this situation, namely:
- The court has discretion to do what it thinks is just and appropriate and in accordance with the overriding objective.
- There is no presumption for or against requiring costs budgets for claims that exceed the normal threshold of £10 million. The court's discretion is wholly unfettered.
- The threshold at which costs budgeting normally ceases to apply is in part because the higher the value of the claim, the less likely it is that issues of proportionality will be important or even relevant.
- The court must weigh the advantages and disadvantages of costs budgeting when deciding whether to exercise its discretion in all the circumstances of the case.
In support of their application, the defendants argued that it was not appropriate for the Court to order costs management for a number of reasons:
- the very high value of the claim was a “very relevant consideration” in assessing whether costs management was necessary to ensure that costs were proportionate to the case as a whole;
- there was no basis for suggesting the defendants had incurred or would likely incur disproportionate costs defending the claim;
- the claimants did not require a costs management order for the purposes of obtaining litigation funding or after the event (ATE) insurance to cover adverse costs orders as these were already in place;
- the defendants had offered to provide updates on their total expenditure; and
- the costs budgeting process would add to the costs of the proceedings and divert resources.
In response, the claimants argued that costs budgeting would further the overriding objective, in particular, that parties should be placed on an equal footing and litigation should be conducted at proportionate cost. The claimants focused on the fact that they are private individuals whose individual claims are for modest amounts of approximately £15,000 per claimant. As such, it was important for them to be able to understand and manage their exposure to future adverse costs orders. A reliable view of their costs exposure at an early stage of the case would enable them to maintain an appropriate level of ATE insurance: if they were required to top it up later, it could be prohibitively expensive. Further, as approved costs budgets usually act as a cap on what will be recovered at detailed assessment, they would enable the claimants to understand what they could reasonably draw down from their own funding for their costs and the level of ATE required to meet the defendants’ costs.
The Court ordered the parties to prepare costs budgets in respect of the period up to the preliminary issue trial, holding that the burden of costs budgeting would be outweighed by the advantage of having visibility as to the estimates of costs.
The Court acknowledged the very high value of the claim and that the parties’ agreement to the trial of a preliminary issue indicated that they were adopting a sensible approach to the management of the dispute. However, the Court noted that it “has to consider a range of factors in terms of proportionality, not just the amount of money that is at stake.” The Court was persuaded by the claimants’ argument that costs budgeting would give them visibility over their exposure in respect of the defendants’ costs, noting that the individual claims are modest.
The Court had to consider the position if the litigation continued beyond the preliminary issue trial and noted the Claimants’ concern that by that stage there may have been too much eaten into their funding and ATE insurance, which could impact on their ability to continue. The Judge concluded: “This is a case where the individual claimants are entitled to carry out their own cost-benefit analysis of the proceedings at each stage. That will involve, not only tracking their own costs exposure through the percentage of damages, if any, that they might have to forego, but also in tracking the funding and ATE that gets eaten up by their own costs and by exposure to the other side's costs in terms of the wider funding for the litigation in general.”
Key takeaways
This decision illustrates how the court’s discretion in relation to ordering costs budgeting is unfettered: there is no presumption for or against budgeting where claims are for more than £10 million. Indeed, although not common in large commercial disputes, we have experience of cases in which the courts have used their discretion to implement costs management where the claim value exceeded the £10 million threshold. Conversely, we have seen cases where the courts have disapplied costs management in claims valued under the threshold.
Claimants or defendants may seek such costs management, for example, if one party is particularly concerned about the level of the other’s anticipated costs. Group actions involving a large number of individual claimants can give rise to different and more complex dynamics. Defendants to such class actions should be prepared for claimants to seek costs management even where claims far exceed the £10 million threshold for costs budgeting, especially where the claimant cohort is large but the individual claims are small, and funding and ATE play a key role.
Where costs management is ordered, parties will be required to prepare costs budgets, which will be subject to the courts’ scrutiny and approval. Such costs budgets will also limit the parties’ adverse costs exposure, thereby potentially making it easier for claimants in this type of group claim to bring an action and prosecute it through trial. In contrast, for defendants, the impact of such a cost budgeting order might affect the economics of defending such claims and so promote earlier settlement.
This post was co-authored by Gary Ginnaw, Senior Costs Draftsperson and Mark Kennard-Dwyer, Costs Draftsperson.