Norton Rose Fulbright secured a successful appellate outcome before the US Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, obtaining affirmance of a Southern District of Texas summary judgment in favor of clients Brenner Tank Services, L.L.C. (Brenner) and Bulk Solutions, L.L.C. (Bulk) in George v. SI Group, Inc., et al., No. 25-40286. In a July 9, 2026 opinion, the Fifth Circuit upheld the district court’s decision on all claims.

The case arose from an accident in which a tanker trailer carrying hot water was placed on gravel without industry-standard stabilizing matting and tipped over and spilled hot water, causing severe injuries to the plaintiff. The plaintiff asserted products liability claims against Brenner and Bulk and premises liability claims against co-defendant SI Group.

The Fifth Circuit concluded that Bulk was entitled to summary judgment because the plaintiff did not challenge the conclusion that Bulk was a non-manufacturing seller under Chapter 82 of the Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code. The court also affirmed summary judgment for Brenner on the plaintiff’s failure-to-warn and design defect claims.

The panel agreed that the risk of placing a loaded tanker trailer on gravel without stabilizing matting would be commonly known and obvious to foreseeable users, citing evidence regarding commercial driver training, licensing requirements and industry practices. The court further concluded that the plaintiff failed to present sufficient evidence supporting proposed safer alternative designs and that the applicable risk-utility factors weighed in favor of Brenner.

“The Fifth Circuit’s decision provides important guidance on several recurring product liability issues,” said Kristina Williams, who led the matter for Norton Rose Fulbright. “The opinion confirms the application of Texas law governing non-manufacturing sellers, failure-to-warn claims involving obvious risks and the evidentiary requirements for design defect claims based on proposed safer alternative designs.”

The appeal was argued before a Fifth Circuit panel consisting of Judges Catharina Haynes, Stephen Higginson and James Ho. Judge Higginson concurred in the judgment.

Norton Rose Fulbright’s team was led by Kristina Williams (Dallas) and included David Kearns (Washington, DC) and Charlotte Kelly (San Antonio). The firm’s appellate lawyers provide experienced, high-quality and cost-effective appellate legal services to clients worldwide.

Contact