The next phase: Making pricing data usable

Key takeaways

  • The Final Rules are intended to make payer pricing data easier to compare, analyze and use.
  • Greater visibility into negotiated rates, network relationships and reimbursement patterns may increase scrutiny of publicly‑disclosed pricing information.
  • Closer alignment between Transparency in Coverage and Hospital Price Transparency requirements may make pricing discrepancies easier to identify.
  • Although the Final Rules apply to non-grandfathered group health plans and health insurance issuers offering non-grandfathered group or individual coverage, they may have important implications for provider contracting, benchmarking and reimbursement strategy.

From disclosure to usability: The next phase of healthcare price transparency

On October 6, 2026, the Internal Revenue Service of the Department of the Treasury, the Employee Benefits Security Administration of the Department of Labor and the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services of the Department of Health and Human Services (collectively, the Departments) issued amendments to the Transparency in Coverage (TiC) rules governing non-grandfathered group health plans and health insurance issuers offering non-grandfathered group or individual health insurance coverage (Final Rules).

The Final Rules reflect the maturation of federal healthcare price transparency policy. The original TiC rules, finalized in 2020, brought negotiated pricing information into the public domain. In practice, however, the resulting files were often difficult to locate, compare and analyze. The Final Rules seek to address those limitations by improving the accessibility, standardization and reliability of plan and issuer pricing disclosures.

Although the Final Rules do not impose new reporting obligations on providers, they may make information about provider reimbursement, network relationships and contracting arrangements easier to analyze. As a result, payer transparency data may become more useful for benchmarking, market analysis, reimbursement negotiations and other strategic purposes.

Network-level reporting may reveal more about provider network relationships

Under the Final Rules, plans and issuers must prepare one In-network Rate File for each provider network they maintain or contract with rather than a separate file for each plan or policy. Each file must identify the network by its common name and network identifier and include the product types, such as Health Maintenance Organization (HMO) or Preferred Provider Organization (PPO), that use it. Reporting at the network level may make it easier to trace how provider rates are accessed across insurance products and through leased, rental or shared-network arrangements.

Because the Final Rules do not prescribe a standardized national network-identification system, practical comparability across payers will depend on each payer’s network naming conventions and identifiers. Providers may therefore wish to examine not only the rates they negotiated, but also how those rates may be accessed through other network relationships.

New contextual files target “ghost rates”

The Final Rules target so-called “ghost rates,” meaning negotiated rates for items and services for which a provider would be unlikely to be reimbursed given the provider’s specialty. Plans and issuers must then disclose those mappings in a new Taxonomy File, which relies on the same specialty taxonomy codes providers report with their NPIs. A separate Utilization File must identify covered items and services for which an in-network provider submitted at least one claim and received reimbursement, in whole or in part, or would have received reimbursement but for the participant’s cost-sharing liability, during the applicable reporting period. The file will identify providers by NPI, TIN and place-of-service code, but will not disclose claim counts.

For providers, these requirements increase the importance of accurate specialty classifications, taxonomy codes and enrollment records within each payer’s systems. Because plans and issuers will rely on their the internal taxonomy or other specialty-based rules use in claims-adjudication when identifying and excluding “ghost rates,” providers may have a greater interest in understanding how they are classified within payer systems. The Taxonomy and Utilization Files may also make it easier to identify situations in which a payer’s classification or reporting appears inconsistent with the provider’s records.

Greater alignment may make discrepancies more visible

One of the Departments’ principal objectives is to make TiC disclosures easier to compare with disclosures required under the Hospital Price Transparency rules. The Departments identified misalignment between the two frameworks as a significant barrier to the effective use of available pricing data. Network-level reporting, new contextual files and standardized data elements are intended to facilitate comparisons between payer and provider disclosures.

For hospitals and health systems, the practical consequence may be that discrepancies between payer and provider disclosures become easier to identify and investigate. Those differences may stem from legitimate variations in methodology, coding, attribution, contract interpretation or timing. Nevertheless, organizations should be prepared for the possibility of greater scrutiny of pricing information that appears inconsistent across the two datasets.

Expanded out-of-network reporting may increase market visibility

The Final Rules lower the minimum reporting threshold from 20 claims to 11 claims, extend the reporting period from 90 days to six months and the lookback period from 180 days to nine months and require aggregation by market type. The Departments expect these changes to increase the amount of publicly available out-of-network payment information. Although the data will still require careful interpretation and may not reflect comparable services, provider circumstances, case complexity or negotiating positions, it may enhance visibility into reimbursement patterns and pricing variation across markets.

As the volume of available information grows, employers, researchers, consultants, technology companies and providers may increasingly use this data for benchmarking, market analysis and contracting strategy.

New accountability measures may improve data reliability

The Final Rules require plans and issuers to attest, to the best of their knowledge and belief, that each required file includes all applicable information and that the encoded information is true, accurate and complete as of the date in the file. The files also must encode the name of the chief executive officer, president or designated senior official who oversees the accuracy of the data. Additional requirements are intended to make pricing files easier to locate, including a plain-text file containing file-location and monitored contact information, and a homepage footer link labeled “Price Transparency” or “Transparency in Coverage” that directs users to the disclosures.

While these measures will not eliminate inaccuracies, they may make it easier for providers to raise concerns about rates that appear inaccurate, outdated or incorrectly attributed.

Consumer access to cost information continues to expand

Beginning with plan or policy years starting on or after January 1, 2027, plans and issuers must provide personalized cost-sharing information upon request by telephone in addition to existing online and paper-based options. Compliance with this requirement also satisfies the No Surprises Act price comparison tool requirement, including for grandfathered plans and coverage that are not otherwise subject to the TiC rules, but does not displace independent state-law disclosure obligations.

Although this requirement applies to plans and issuers, providers may experience its practical effects as patients obtain cost estimates through additional channels and seek explanations for differences between payer-generated estimates, provider estimates and ultimate financial responsibility.

Timing and other key changes

The Final Rules are effective December 7, 2026, but most requirements apply later:

  • Amendments to the In-network Rate and Out-of-network Allowed Amount Files apply beginning March 6, 2027.
  • The Taxonomy File, Text File and website-footer requirements apply beginning September 6, 2027, with the first Taxonomy and Text Files due October 1, 2027. The Utilization File requirement applies on the same date, but plans and issuers must first post the file on July 1, 2028, and update it annually after that. As a result, providers should not expect to see payer Utilization File data until mid-2028.
  • Consumer cost-sharing provisions apply for plan or policy years beginning on or after January 1, 2027.
  • The Final Rules also move In-network Rate and Out-of-network Allowed Amount Files from monthly to quarterly updates. Separately, the Departments’ October 7, 2026 implementation FAQs state that plans and issuers are expected to begin publishing the previously deferred prescription-drug file in December 2027 and monthly thereafter. In-network rates generally must be reported as dollar amounts, subject to a limited exception for certain percentage of billed charges arrangements.

Implications for providers and next steps

The Final Rules add new contextual disclosures and expand out-of-network reporting, but their principal effect is to change how payer pricing information is organized, contextualized and presented. Through network-level reporting, Taxonomy and Utilization Files, expanded out-of-network reporting and additional data elements, the Departments seek to make payer transparency data easier to compare, analyze and use.

As this data becomes more usable, providers may have a greater interest in understanding how plans and issuers classify, organize and publicly report information regarding provider rates, specialties, network participation and reimbursement arrangements.

The following considerations may help organizations assess how their information may appear in revised payer disclosures and prepare for greater use of transparency data by employers, researchers, consultants, regulators and other market participants.

  • Validate payer records. Confirm the accuracy of NPI, TIN, place-of-service, specialty, taxonomy, credentialing and enrollment information in each payer’s systems.
  • Review network-access provisions. Identify leased, rental and shared-network arrangements that may affect how negotiated rates appear across payer products and files.
  • Prepare for cross-file comparisons. Consider how hospital price-transparency disclosures will be compared with revised payer files and how material differences will be investigated and explained.
  • Assign monitoring responsibility. Determine which legal, contracting, revenue-cycle, compliance or data teams will monitor payer disclosures and address rates that appear inaccurate, outdated or incorrectly attributed.

Our team of experienced lawyers and professionals at Norton Rose Fulbright has the capacity to assist providers in navigating the evolving price transparency landscape. Please let us know if we can be of assistance.

Contact