A federal judge in Maryland has stayed eight provisions of a 2027 Notice of Benefit and Payment Parameters Final Rule (2027 Final Rule) that sought to make significant changes to the Affordable Care Act (ACA) individual insurance market, including changes to subsidized coverage eligibility and plan design requirements, holding that the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) overstepped or failed to justify the changes in granting the stay. The complaint described the challenged provisions as likely to reduce enrollment, increase premiums for some consumers and raise out-of-pocket costs. In City of Columbus et al. v. Kennedy et al., the Court found that HHS likely exceeded its authority or failed to adequately justify the changes and granted a stay.
Congress enacted the ACA in 2010 to expand coverage and reduce the cost of healthcare care. The ACA has been contested almost continuously since the law took effect, through litigation, legislative repeal efforts and administrative rollbacks. Notably, the case follows earlier litigation before the same court and judge over the 2025 Marketplace Integrity and Affordability final rule. Many of the same plaintiffs returned in the 2027 case, and Pima County joined the newer suit.
Impacted policies
In briefing before the Court, the government argued that Congress's passage of the Working Families Tax Cuts Act (WFTCA), commonly referred to as the "One Big Beautiful Bill Act," supported HHS’s approach, but the Court evaluated the 2027 Final Rule under the ACA as currently written and in force. With that framework in mind, the stayed provisions addressed a series of marketplace eligibility, verification and plan design policies.
Failure to file and reconcile
Individuals who receive advance premium tax credits (APTCs), the federal subsidies that lower monthly premiums, must file an annual tax return to reconcile those credits against their actual household income. Under current policy, individuals generally become ineligible for APTCs only after failing to file and reconcile for two consecutive years. The 2027 Final Rule would have reimposed a one-year standard for plan year 2027, reviving a policy the Court previously stayed in litigation over the 2025 Marketplace Integrity and Affordability Final Rule. For now, because this provision is stayed, the existing two-year framework remains in place.
Applicants projecting household income above the federal poverty line
If an individual projects annual household income above the federal poverty line for the applicable plan year, but available records show income below that level for the prior year, existing rules generally allow the exchange to accept the applicant's attestation without requiring additional documentation. The 2027 Final Rule would have required applicants to provide documentation to resolve that discrepancy.
Similar income-verification requirements have been challenged before, but the Court focused here on whether HHS adequately justified this version of the policy. The Court concluded that HHS had not adequately connected the documented enrollment-integrity concerns in the administrative record to the additional burden the rule imposed on applicants.
Income verification when the IRS has no data
Under current rules, when the IRS has no income data for an applicant, the exchange may rely on the applicant’s self-attestation of household income. The 2027 Final Rule would have required those applicants to go through the standard income verification process rather than relying on self-attestation. HHS justified this change as a response to fraudulent or unauthorized enrollments, but the Court found that HHS had not adequately explained how imposing additional verification requirements on applicants addressed the enrollment-integrity concerns identified in the administrative record.
Pre-enrollment verification for Special Enrollment Periods
Special Enrollment Periods (SEPs) allow individuals to enroll outside open enrollment after a qualifying life event, such as a move, marriage or loss of coverage. Current rules require pre-enrollment eligibility verification only for SEPs based on loss of minimum essential coverage. The 2027 Final Rule would have extended that requirement to other SEP categories and required exchanges to verify at least 75 percent of new SEP enrollees before coverage began. The Court found HHS’s rationale insufficient, concluding that higher enrollment in SEP categories without verification requirements did not, standing alone, establish fraud or abuse or justify the added verification burden.
Higher out-of-pocket caps for bronze plans
The ACA caps the amount enrollees may be required to pay out of pocket each year. The 2027 Final Rule would have allowed individual-market bronze plans to exceed that annual cost-sharing limit by up to 130 percent if the issuer also offered at least one bronze plan within the ordinary limit. The Court found that provision likely contrary to the statute.
Broader eligibility for catastrophic plans
Catastrophic plans are high-deductible plans sold on the exchanges and are generally limited to people under age 30 or those who qualify for a hardship exemption. The 2027 Final Rule would have expanded hardship-exemption eligibility to people who are ineligible for APTCs or cost-sharing reductions because their projected household income is below 100 percent or above 250 percent of the federal poverty level, thereby broadening access to catastrophic coverage for adults age 30 and older. The Court found that plaintiffs were likely to succeed in challenging this provision, concluding that HHS had not adequately explained how the income-based expansion fit within the ACA’s hardship-exemption standard.
Relaxed network adequacy review standards
Current rules require state-based exchanges, including those using the federal platform, to apply quantitative network-adequacy standards at least as stringent as the federal marketplace baseline. The 2027 Final Rule would have allowed states meeting specified certification criteria to conduct network-adequacy reviews without applying that federal floor. Commenters raised concerns that some state oversight regimes provide limited enforcement and may not provide sufficient review. The Court stayed those provisions, finding that HHS had not sufficiently addressed commenters’ concerns about state oversight and that plaintiffs were likely to succeed in challenging the changes.
Elimination of standardized plans
Standardized plans are intended to make it easier for consumers to compare coverage options across insurers by using more uniform cost-sharing structures. Current rules require insurers to offer at least one standardized plan at each metal level and limit the number of non-standardized plans they may offer. The 2027 Final Rule would have eliminated both requirements. The Court stayed the provision, finding that plaintiffs were likely to succeed because HHS had not adequately explained its departure from prior policy.
What this means for hospitals and health systems
However, it does not resolve broader coverage changes that may affect the individual market in the coming years that are occurring in tandem to these rules. Hospitals and health systems should continue tracking how these developments may affect coverage levels, payer mix and patient financial responsibility.
Changes in coverage and cost-sharing can affect hospital finances through higher uninsured or underinsured volumes, increased uncompensated care and pressure on operating margins. The municipal plaintiffs in this case alleged that they would bear some of these costs through emergency services and other safety net obligations, which the Court found sufficient to support standing.
Several of the stayed provisions are relevant to provider financial planning. The bronze-plan cost-sharing and catastrophic-plan provisions would have increased access to coverage options with higher out-of-pocket exposure, while the network adequacy provisions could have affected provider participation and access in some states.
The ruling applies the ACA as currently written. Statutory and regulatory developments, including implementation of the WFTCA and related HHS guidance, could still affect coverage, payer mix and patient-responsibility balances in future plan years.