What defendants need to know

The bottom line

The Supreme Court unanimously ruled that the SEC does not need to prove that investors suffered any financial loss in order to obtain disgorgement of a defendant’s net profits.

The decision resolves a circuit split in the SEC’s favor and effectively closes off one of defendants’ key arguments for limiting or defeating disgorgement awards.

However, a notable concurrence by Justice Thomas signals that a significant fight over defendants’ right to a jury trial on disgorgement is likely coming—and that question remains very much alive. Sripetch v. Securities and Exchange Commission.

Background

Ongkaruck Sripetch ran fraudulent schemes involving at least 20 penny-stock companies, including classic pump-and-dump operations. The SEC charged him with six counts of securities fraud and one count of selling unregistered securities. Sripetch consented to judgment but challenged the disgorgement order, taking his case to the high court.2

Sripetch’s core argument, rooted in the Supreme Court’s 2020 decision in Liu v. SEC,3 was straightforward: disgorgement is an equitable remedy “awarded for victims,” and if the SEC cannot identify investors who actually suffered a financial loss, there are no victims on whose behalf disgorgement can be awarded. Because the SEC lacked evidence that his schemes caused investors any pecuniary loss, Sripetch argued the disgorgement order could not stand.

The SEC disagreed, arguing that investors could qualify as “victims” under Liu even if they lost no money, and separately asserted that its evidence demonstrated investors had suffered pecuniary loss as a result of Sripetch’s wrongdoing.

The district court accepted the Commission’s second argument, finding the SEC had done enough to show that Sripetch’s investors had suffered pecuniary loss and did not decide whether such a showing was required in the first place.

When Sripetch appealed, the Ninth Circuit held that a finding of pecuniary harm is not required before a court orders disgorgement, joining the First Circuit and deepening a split with the Second Circuit, which had required a showing of pecuniary harm.

The Court’s holding

Justice Gorsuch, writing for a unanimous Court, agreed with the SEC. The reasoning turns on the difference between a loss-based remedy and a gain-based one. Damages restore the plaintiff to the position they would have occupied but for the wrongdoing—they are backward-looking from the victim’s perspective. Disgorgement strips the defendant of the gain attributable to wrongdoing—it is forward-looking from the defendant’s perspective.4

The Court held defendants are not allowed to benefit from misconduct merely “because the plaintiff’s financial position has not changed.”5

The Court rejected each of Sripetch’s arguments. Liu’s “awarded for victims” language is drawn from equity, and equity does not define “victim” by reference to pecuniary loss.6 Investors can be victims of a fraudulent scheme even if they did not lose money.

On the argument that disgorgement must “restore the status quo,” the Court explained that when a defendant enriches himself without leaving the plaintiff worse off, a court must choose between two status quos. Equity prefers stripping the wrongdoer of his unjust gain over letting him keep it.7

On the concern that the SEC might use disgorgement to send funds to the Treasury rather than on behalf of investors, the Court acknowledged that this would raise further questions, including whether and to what degree the law permits departure from equitable principles, but did not resolve them.8

Justice Thomas joined the holding but wrote separately to flag what he sees as the more consequential question. In his view, the Court should recognize in a future case that disgorgement is now a legal remedy, which would carry a Seventh Amendment right to a jury trial.9 Justice Thomas reasoned that disgorgement has little footing in historical equity practice; that the statute now lists “disgorgement” separately from “equitable relief” and assigns it its own limitations period, implying it is not equitable; and that disgorgement resembles legal restitution more than equitable remedies.10 Justice Thomas also observed that the Courts of Appeals are already split on the legal-remedy question, comparing the Fifth Circuit’s decision in SEC v. Hallam11 with the Second Circuit’s in SEC v. Ahmed.12 This existing circuit conflict signals the Seventh Amendment jury trial question is likely headed back to the Supreme Court in short order.

Key takeaways for defendants

Defendants’ loss-based arguments foreclosed. The Court’s ruling limits defendants’ ability to resist disgorgement by arguing that the SEC must prove the same type of economic loss required in private securities-fraud suits. The focus remains on whether the defendant received unjust enrichment as a result of the securities-law violation and whether the disgorgement award is properly limited to that enrichment.

Contest the disgorgement calculation. Liu’s net-profits limitation remains intact.13 Defendants should aggressively push back on the SEC’s methodology and ensure only actual net gains are included.

Preserve the jury-trial argument. A jury trial on disgorgement would be a significant procedural advantage: juries can be more skeptical of government overreach, disgorgement calculations and the government’s framing of who qualifies as a victim. Defendants should consider preserving the jury-trial argument at every stage of litigation rather than conceding the court’s authority to resolve disgorgement in an equitable proceeding.

Strengthened enforcement posture. The decision preserves one of the SEC’s most powerful monetary remedies. The SEC may continue to seek disgorgement tied to a defendant’s net profits even where identifying individual investors or quantifying their losses would be difficult. The decision maintains the SEC’s ability to pursue disgorgement in more litigated cases and settlements. Expect the SEC to press disgorgement in matters where loss is hard to measure, such as pump-and-dump and unregistered-offering cases.

Significant open questions remain. The Court left open significant questions:

  1. Whether disgorgement may proceed when distribution to investors is infeasible
  2. As Justice Thomas’s concurrence argues, whether Congress has made SEC disgorgement a legal remedy, which triggers the Seventh Amendment right to a jury trial
  3. Whether the SEC is freed from Liu’s requirement that disgorgement be “awarded for victims,” which would potentially allow the government to resume its former practice of depositing disgorged funds with the US Treasury

How can we help

If you have questions about how Sripetch affects your enforcement risk, an ongoing SEC matter or your compliance program, please contact our team below or any member of our Financial Investigations and Disputes practice group.

Footnotes

  1. 1

    Sripetch v. SEC, 608 U.S. __ (June 4, 2026), at 6–8.

  2. 2

    Sripetch, at 4–5.

  3. 3

    Liu v. SEC, 591 U.S. 71 (2020).

  4. 4

    Sripetch, at 8–9.

  5. 5

    Id. at 12.

  6. 6

    Id. at 11.

  7. 7

    Id. at 11–12.

  8. 8

    Id. at 12–13.

  9. 9

    Id. at 5–8.

  10. 10

    SEC v. Hallam, 42 F.4th 316 (5th Cir. 2022).

  11. 11

    SEC v. Ahmed, 72 F.4th 379 (2d Cir. 2023); Sripetch, Thomas concurrence, at 10.

  12. 12

    Id. at 2.

Contact