A new final rule (Final Rule) revises the federal independent dispute resolution (IDR) process established under the No Surprises Act (NSA) to resolve out-of-network payment disputes between payors and providers of emergency services. The Final Rule reflects the efforts of the US Departments of Health and Human Services, Treasury and Labor (Departments) to address problems that have plagued the program since its rollout in early 2022.

Specifically, the Final Rule decreases the IDR administrative fee from the proposed US$150 to US$15 per dispute, creates new health plan and insurance issuer disclosure requirements that must accompany initial payments or denial notices, adds an additional step to the open negotiation process, revises batching rules and establishes a new IDR registry for plans and issuers. Taken together, these changes aim to promote administrative efficiency and to support both payers and providers in more equitable and informed negotiations.

Various parts of the Final Rule become effective over different timeframes. While the US$15 administrative fee goes into effect five business days after publication, many of the new operational provisions will not become operative until an undefined future date when additional guidance and program technical capabilities become available.

Lowered US$15 administrative fee

Every party to an IDR proceeding, including those where medical services are subsequently determined ineligible for the payment dispute process, pays a uniform flat administrative fee of US$15. This fee has been reduced from the current amount of US$115 per dispute and the originally proposed amount of US$150 per dispute. This decrease is the result of the number of disputes anticipated each year increasing by tenfold between the time the rule was initially proposed in 2023 to its final publication in 2026. This lowered fee is anticipated to increase access to the IDR process for medical providers with smaller amounts in dispute, such as providers of radiology or laboratory services. It is likewise anticipated that the lowered fee will increase the number of payment disputes going through the IDR process by 30 percent.

In addition to the administrative fee, for each IDR proceeding a fee is charged by the IDR entity (IDRE) that decides the payment dispute. The IDRE fee will remain payable by the losing party. If there is a split outcome for a batched dispute of multiple claims, the IDRE fee is split. To promote negotiation, if a settlement is reached before a decision is made, each party is responsible for one-half of the IDRE fee. Moreover, if settlement occurs before an eligibility determination has been made, no IDRE fee is owed.

New early disclosure requirements

Health plans and issuers will be required to use NSA-specific Claim Adjustment Reason Codes (CARCs) and Remittance Advice Remark Codes (RARCs) when issuing payments or denial notices to providers. In particular, explanations of payment or benefits (collectively “EOBs”) will include codes that advise providers whether a claim is eligible for the federal IDR program. Also, plans and issuers will be required to provide additional information on EOBs, such as the legal business names of the plan or issuer (and the plan sponsor, where applicable) and the plan or issuer's federal IDR registry registration number (once registration is required). Notably, the Departments have stated that plans and issuers will not be required to use CARCs and RARCs until a date to be established in future guidance.

Open negotiation process

Under the Final Rule, the open negotiation process will now take place through the federal IDR portal. A new requirement will be the submission of an “open negotiation response notice” by the non-initiating party (which is almost always the plan or issuer). The notice will require several pieces of information intended to inform the eligibility analysis, such as the legal business name of the plan or issuer and its current contact information (name, email address, phone number and mailing address), the plan type (for example, self-insured or fully-insured), and the contact information of any third party representing the plan or issuer in IDR proceedings.

The new “open negotiation response notice” must be submitted no later than the 15th business day of the 30-business-day open negotiation period. Notably, there is no impact to the IDR process if an open negotiation response notice is not submitted.

IDRE selection and information requests

The Final Rule makes changes to the IDRE selection process intended to end the ability of the non-initiating party to game the system and force the selection of its preferred IDRE. In particular, under the previous system, the parties had three business days to jointly select an IDRE. The initiating party would propose an IDRE when it initiated the dispute, and the non-initiating party had until the end of the third business day to reject the initiating party’s proposed IDRE. If rejected, the non-initiating party would propose another IDRE, which the initiating party could then reject, but only within the same third business day. Accordingly, the amount of time the initiating party had to consider the counter-proposal was directly tied to how much of the three-day period the non-initiating party took to respond to the initial IDRE proposal. If the initiating party did not affirmatively reject the non-initiating party’s counter-proposal by the end of the three-day deadline (no matter how little time was left to do so), the counter-proposed IDRE was considered jointly selected.

Accordingly, some non-initiating parties would delay their IDRE counter-proposal until late on the third day, effectively forcing their preferred IDRE on the initiating party, which had insufficient time to object to the counter proposed IDRE. Under the New Rule, if a counter-proposal is made on the third business day, the initiating party has an additional two business days to object to the counterproposal. If an objection is made, the Departments randomly select an IDRE for the dispute. This process also applies in cases where the parties exchange multiple IDRE proposals during the three-business-day selection period, with the party receiving the last offer by the end of the three-day deadline having additional time to accept or reject the offer.

During the proceeding, certified IDREs can request additional information from either party at any time. Parties are afforded five business days to respond through the federal IDR portal. The procedural timeline for IDR resolution is tolled for five business days or until a response is received, whichever is first. If, after five business days, no response has been filed, the adjudication can proceed without the requested information. Adjudication may proceed without the requested information where possible.

The Final Rule also explains that payment disputes may only be withdrawn by the parties if they agree. However, a non-initiating party may unilaterally move for withdrawal of a dispute, which will occur if the initiating party either affirmatively agrees or fails to submit a response within five business days. In addition, an IDRE may dismiss a dispute if it cannot determine eligibility because both parties are nonresponsive to information requests or fail to submit offers.

Batching claims

The Final Rule broadens the circumstances in which items and services can be batched in three ways. First, batching is permitted when all claims involve the same patient encounter, whether within the same day or consecutive days. Second, claims can be batched if they share the same or comparable service codes. Finally, batching applies to claims with the same CPT code range in four specialties: anesthesia, radiology, pathology and laboratory services. Within these specialties, batching is further limited to narrow modality or body-part groups, such as breast mammography, extremity diagnostic ultrasounds or heart and vascular imaging.

Batching remains limited to items and services furnished by the same provider to the same plan or issuer within a 30-day window. This is a key limitation to batching rules since a national insurer may process and pay claims under uniform methodologies for hundreds of group health plans, yet providers can only batch claims provided to a single group plan. In addition, the Final Rule caps batched claims at 50 line items.

To reduce operational complexity and preserve batching efficiencies, the Final Rule also shortens the “cooling off” period for batched disputes to 30 business days.

Federal IDR registry

The Final Rule requires the creation of a centralized registration system for group health plans, health insurance issuers and Federal Employees Health Benefits (FEHB) carriers. Each entity must register through the federal IDR portal and obtain a unique IDR registration number. The registry is designed to identify the correct payer, provide accurate contact information, identify applicable law and enable proper batching determinations. Parties must communicate through the portal, and insurers cannot require the use of private portals as a substitute.

Self-insured group plans must register individually and obtain a plan-specific registration number. Insurers need only register once for the fully insured products they offer. Third parties may register on behalf of plans and serve as a point of contact, but legal responsibility remains with the plan or issuer.

Failure to register effectively precludes meaningful participation in the IDR process. Non-registered entities may be unable to submit offers or respond to disputes, and the certified IDR entity will render its determination without regard to the non-registrant's offer. Registry compliance is required within 90 business days after the registry becomes available.

In closing

The Final Rule represents a significant step toward stabilizing and streamlining the federal IDR program. For providers, hospitals and health systems, the changes present mostly opportunities: reduced administrative fee, broadened batching criteria and a more structured negotiation framework create meaningful avenues to pursue and resolve out-of-network payment disputes more efficiently. For payors, the changes present mostly new obligations in the form of new disclosure requirements during open negotiation, new remark code requirements on EOBs, portal-based submission mandates and registration obligations that will demand prompt attention and operational preparation. Entities that fail to register, adapt their billing and notice workflows or monitor forthcoming implementation guidance on CARCs and RARCs risk being left at a significant disadvantage in the IDR process.

Norton Rose Fulbright will continue to monitor developments under the Final Rule, including the issuance of implementing guidance and the announcement of portal operational readiness, and stands ready to assist providers, hospitals and health systems in navigating these changes and protecting their interests in the IDR process.

Special thanks to summer associate Willa Scanlon for assisting in the preparation of this article.

Contact