A three-judge panel of the US Court of International Trade (CIT) has declared President Trump’s 10 percent universal tariffs issued under Section 122 of the Trade Act of 1974 to be unlawful. Specifically, the CIT, in a 2–1 opinion, granted summary judgment in favor of the plaintiffs in Burlap and Barrel, Inc. v. Trump, holding that the 10 percent ad valorem import surcharge imposed pursuant to Proclamation No. 11012 exceeded the President’s authority under Section 122 of the Trade Act of 1974.

Despite reaching the conclusion that the tariffs exceeded the President’s authority, the Court limited its remedies of a refund and injunction on future tariff collection to only the three named importer plaintiffs (the State of Washington, Burlap and Barrel, Inc. and Basic Fun, Inc.). In refusing to consider a nationwide injunction that would have prohibited further collection for all importers, the CIT referenced Trump v. CASA, Inc. in which the Supreme Court significantly limited the power of lower federal courts to issue such injunctions.

It is therefore possible, at least in the short term, that US Customs and Border Protection (CBP) will continue collecting Section 122 duties from all importers other than the named importer plaintiffs. It is also quite likely that the US government will appeal the decision to the US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit and seek a stay of the CIT’s decision pending the outcome of the appeal.

As such, the expectation is that, at least in the near term, most imports will remain subject to Section 122 duties at entry. Because, however, the opinion clearly held that imposing these tariffs exceeded the President’s authority, we recommend that impacted importers formally contest any continued imposition of the Section 122 tariffs by:

  • Submitting post-summary corrections (PSCs) for unliquidated entries;
  • Filing protests under 19 USC § 1514 for any entries that have already liquidated, subject to the applicable 180-day protest deadline; and
  • Considering piggy-backing off the Burlap and Barrel ruling and filing their own action at the CIT in order to directly secure injunctive relief and refund rights, particularly if their exposure is substantial.

Our team is monitoring these developments closely. Please do not hesitate to contact the Norton Rose Fulbright trade team if you have questions about your specific entries, exposure or whether filing a protest, PSC or CIT action makes sense for your situation.

Contact