Overview
Financial services firms operating at the intersection of the securities and derivatives markets have long grappled with the practical consequences of dual regulation by the SEC and CFTC (collectively, the Agencies). From trading venues and clearinghouses, to pooled investment vehicles and swap intermediaries, the overlap between the Agencies’ mandates touches nearly every corner of the modern financial landscape.1
A significant development on that front arrived on March 11, 2026, when SEC Chairman Paul S. Atkins and CFTC Chairman Michael S. Selig signed a joint Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) on regulatory harmonization—a move that signals a meaningful recalibration of how the Agencies intend to coordinate going forward.2 While the MOU does not carry the force of law, it signals a meaningful shift for dually-registered market participants by directly targeting the most persistent sources or regulatory friction, including duplicative examinations, parallel reporting regimes, inconsistent compliance standards and uncoordinated enforcement actions. Just as importantly, the Agencies have committed to deliver a more rational, predictable and proportionate oversight for dually-registered intermediaries.
This alert unpacks the key provisions of the MOU and offers our perspective on the practical impact on market participants, including dually-registered:
- Futures commission merchants (FCMs)/ introducing brokers (IBs) and securities broker-dealers
- Commodity pool operators (CPOs)/ commodity trading advisors (CTAs) and investment advisers
- Swap dealers (SDs) and security-based swap dealers (SBSDs)
- Swap execution facilities (SEFs) and security-based swap execution facilities (SBSEFs)
For each category, we identify the areas where the MOU is most likely to translate into concrete compliance relief and flag the open questions that firms should be monitoring as implementation unfolds.
Background
Market structure has evolved significantly since the Agencies last updated their coordination framework. Trading activity increasingly spans diverse asset classes and platforms, digital and on-chain infrastructure is reshaping market operations and risk transmission across historically siloed markets has accelerated, rendering traditional jurisdictional boundaries between the Agencies more porous and regulatory fragmentation more costly.3
Against this backdrop, the MOU reflects a shared acknowledgment by the Agencies that their existing coordination mechanisms have not kept pace with market evolution. The MOU signals a joint commitment to modernizing interagency collaboration with the dual objectives of supporting responsible innovation and maintaining robust investor and customer protections. From a practical standpoint, the Agencies intend that a more unified regulatory posture will lower compliance costs for market participants, create space for product and platform innovation and reinforce the global competitiveness of US capital markets.4
The new MOU formally replaces the prior 2018 coordination agreement between the Agencies.5 However, the separate 2004 MOU governing joint oversight of security futures products remains in effect and is expressly reaffirmed.6
Key highlights
Guiding principles
The MOU’s guiding principles provide important insight into how the Agencies intend to approach areas of overlapping jurisdiction and future coordination efforts.7
The MOU identifies five core principles that will guide the Agencies' collaboration:8
- Preserving existing authority: The Agencies emphasize that the MOU is not intended to redraw jurisdictional lines or alter either Agency's statutory mandate, while expressly committing to move beyond the historically entrenched interagency "turf war."9
- Promoting regulatory efficiency: The Agencies commit to addressing matters of shared jurisdiction in a timely, coordinated and effective manner, with the goal of reducing regulatory gaps, avoiding duplicative processes and providing greater certainty regarding regulatory responsibility in support of efficient markets and lawful innovation. Of particular note for market participants, the Agencies agree to process applications promptly. In addition, the Agencies acknowledge the importance of providing fair notice and reject regulation through enforcement.10
- Good faith collaboration: The Agencies commit to timely consultation, transparent communication and constructive engagement with one another to support effective day-to-day cooperation.11
- Delivering regulatory clarity: The Agencies seek to promote clear, consistent and predictable regulatory approaches recognizing that regulatory uncertainty itself imposes real costs on market participants. In addition, the Agencies acknowledge that a more coherent framework can foster greater competition without sacrificing market integrity.12
- Adopting a functional, risk-based approach: The Agencies intend to focus on economic substance, function and risk when coordinating their oversight. This includes commitments to strengthen information sharing, align surveillance priorities and develop complementary analytical tools to better monitor interconnected markets.13
Core areas of harmonization
The MOU identifies six substantive areas in which coordinated action is most likely to yield tangible benefits for dually-registered firms:14
- Product definitions: Joint interpretations and coordinated rulemakings are intended to reduce uncertainty at the boundary between securities and derivatives, providing firms with clearer guidance—an area where definitional ambiguity has generated significant compliance uncertainty.
- Clearing, margin and collateral: Coordinated modernization of clearing, margin and collateral frameworks is aimed at reducing overlapping and sometimes inconsistent requirements for firms that trade both securities and CFTC-regulated derivatives.
- Dually-registered entities: The Agencies seek to lessen the operational frictions experienced by exchanges, trading venues and intermediaries registered with the Agencies by aligning requirements that currently address similar regulatory objectives.
- Crypto assets and emerging technologies: Coordinated development of a fit-for-purpose regulatory framework for digital assets and other emerging technologies is intended to provide greater certainty for market participants in these evolving markets.
- Regulatory reporting: Streamlining trade data, funds and intermediary reporting obligations with the goal of eliminating duplicative filings and rationalizing the information each agency collects.
- Examinations, surveillance and enforcement: Greater coordination across examination programs, economic analyses, risk monitoring, surveillance activities and enforcement efforts intended to reduce the burden and disruption of overlapping regulatory reviews.
Alternative compliance framework
One of the more forward-looking aspects of the MOU is its embrace of what the Agencies describe as a "minimum effective dose" regulatory approach. The Agencies indicate that they intend to explore alternative compliance pathways that would permit firms, where appropriate, to satisfy one Agency's requirements by demonstrating compliance with comparable rules of the other.
The MOU also signals openness to enabling appropriately regulated "super-apps" (that is, integrated platforms that offer access to both securities and derivatives products) under a streamlined compliance framework. While the details remain to be worked out, this approach could represent a meaningful departure from the current paradigm of full, parallel compliance with each agency's distinct rulebook.15 Any such alternative frameworks would require rulemaking or formal guidance, and firms should expect implementation to be incremental rather than immediate.
Coordination mechanisms
Beyond substantive harmonization, the MOU establishes several operational mechanisms designed to embed interagency coordination into day-to-day operations, including:
- Ongoing dialogue: Senior representatives from the Agencies will meet on a regular basis to identify and discuss emerging regulatory issues at an early stage, while staff-level communications will continue on an ad hoc basis to facilitate day-to-day coordination. This structure is designed to ensure that potential areas of friction are surfaced and addressed before they become entrenched.16
- Cross-market data access: Subject to meeting applicable security standards, the Agencies agreed to share data regarding “matters and transactions of common regulatory interest.”17 In addition, the Agencies have committed to moving quickly to establish the confidentiality arrangements necessary for each Agency to access swap and security-based swap data directly from the relevant trade repositories. This is a critical step—without shared visibility into cross-market positions and activity, meaningful coordination on risk monitoring and surveillance is difficult to achieve.18
- Advance notice of significant developments: Each Agency will endeavor to give the other advance notice of matters that could affect the other's regulatory interests or impact jointly-regulated entities, products or markets. This includes supervisory developments, planned rulemakings, material adverse events, enforcement actions and proposals to list or trade novel derivative or digital asset products—a broad notification commitment that should help prevent the kind of uncoordinated regulatory surprises that have caught market participants off guard in the past.19
- Staff cross-training: The Agencies will implement cross-training programs, to deepen each Agency's institutional understanding of the other's mission, jurisdiction and regulatory approach. While this may seem like a modest commitment, building cross-agency fluency at the staff level is often where the practical success or failure of interagency coordination is determined.20
- Centralized coordination leadership: The Agencies will establish a senior-level coordination process, potentially including a formal interagency team, to serve as centralized points of contact for all activities under the MOU. This institutional anchor is important: without dedicated senior leadership driving the agenda, interagency MOUs have historically risked becoming aspirational documents that lose momentum over time.21
Impact on market participants
Dually-registered intermediaries
Across all categories of dually‑registered intermediaries, the MOU targets a common set of challenges, including duplicative examinations, parallel reporting regimes, inconsistent compliance standards and jurisdictional uncertainty. While the practical impact varies by firm type, the direction of travel towards regulatory harmonization is consistent.
CFTC-registered FCMs/ IBs and SEC-registered broker-dealers
Firms holding dual registrations as broker-dealers and FCMs or IBs fall squarely within the MOU's definition of "Covered Firms" (entities of common regulatory interest to the Agencies).22 These firms are no strangers to regulatory overlap; they have long contended with separate customer protection regimes, parallel recordkeeping and reporting obligations and redundant examination cycles under both the Exchange Act and the CEA.
As discussed further below, the MOU's examination coordination provisions may offer the most immediate practical relief for these firms. In practice, this could mean fewer document requests, consolidated interview schedules and streamlined on-site visits, all of which would represent a welcome reduction in the operational disruption that dually-registered firms routinely face.23
CFTC-registered CPOs/CTAs and SEC-registered investment advisers
Dually-registered investment advisers and CPOs/CTAs are also expressly included within the MOU's definition of “Covered Firms.”24 These firms, which typically manage a diverse mix of pooled vehicles, separately managed accounts and investment programs, spanning both securities and derivatives, are well acquainted with the burden of maintaining parallel disclosure, reporting, recordkeeping and compliance programs to satisfy each Agency's distinct requirements.
The MOU's focus on streamlining regulatory reporting for funds and intermediaries could yield meaningful relief in this area, particularly with respect to Form PF, Form CPO-PQR and related filing obligations.25 Equally significant are the examination coordination provisions, under which the Agencies' respective examination staffs will meet periodically to discuss risk assessment, exam planning, supervisory priorities and emerging trends affecting dually-registered firms, an approach designed to leverage each Agency's expertise while reducing the cumulative burden on registrants.26
CFTC-registered swap dealers and SEC-registered security-based swap dealers
Firms holding dual registrations as SDs and SBSDs are likewise designated as Covered Firms under the MOU.27 In practice, these dealers maintain books that span both CFTC-regulated swaps (such as interest rate or commodity swaps) and SEC-regulated security-based swaps (such as single-name credit default swaps or equity swaps on individual securities or narrow-based indices).
As a result, they must navigate two distinct regulatory frameworks, each with its own requirements regarding registration, cross-border application, business conduct, capital, margin and reporting and recordkeeping.
For these firms, the MOU's emphasis on clarifying product definitions through joint interpretations and rulemakings, together with its commitment to modernizing clearing, margin and collateral frameworks, should, over time, bring greater clarity and reduce the compliance friction inherent in operating under two parallel regulatory regimes.28
CFTC-registered swap execution facilities and SEC-registered security-based SEFs
Platforms holding dual registrations as SEFs and SBSEFs are also expressly designated as Covered Firms.29 For these venues, the MOU's stated objective of reducing frictions for dually-registered exchanges, trading venues and intermediaries speaks directly to the operational inefficiencies they face in maintaining compliance with two overlapping sets of trading platform requirements.30
Broad-based vs. narrow-based stock index futures and single stock futures
The jurisdictional divide between the CFTC and SEC over equity-linked futures products has been a persistent source of complexity since the enactment of the Commodity Futures Modernization Act of 2000. Futures on broad-based stock indices are exclusively CFTC-regulated, while security futures products (SFPs),encompassing single stock futures and futures on narrow-based security indices, fall under the joint oversight of the Agencies.31
The MOU expressly preserves the existing 2004 interagency framework governing joint oversight of SFPs, leaving that coordination structure intact.32 That said, the broader harmonization commitments in the new MOU, particularly around product definitions, reporting and examination processes, should gradually reduce the regulatory disparities between broad-based and narrow-based index futures and single stock futures, promoting more consistent treatment across these closely related product categories.
CFTC vs. SEC jurisdiction over swaps and security-based swaps
One of the most consequential features of the post-Dodd-Frank regulatory landscape is the split jurisdiction over swap products based on the nature of the underlying reference asset. The distinction between CFTC-regulated "swaps" and SEC-regulated "security-based swaps," each defined under both the CEA and the Exchange Act,33 drives much of the compliance complexity that dually-registered firms face. Generally the Agencies’ jurisdiction over such derivatives is as follows:
- CFTC jurisdiction: Swaps on interest rates, currencies, commodities and broad-based security indices are CFTC-regulated "swaps."
- SEC jurisdiction: Swaps on single securities, loans or narrow-based security indices, including single-name credit default swaps and equity swaps on individual stocks, are SEC-regulated "security-based swaps."
- Mixed swaps: Instruments with characteristics of both a swap and a security-based swap are subject to the jurisdiction of both Agencies.
The MOU addresses this fragmentation by committing both Agencies to expeditiously establish confidentiality arrangements that will enable each to access swap and security-based swap data directly from the relevant data repositories. Beyond raw data access, the Agencies intend to share analytical insights and monitoring capabilities derived from repository data, with the goal of improving cross-market visibility, strengthening coordination and supporting earlier identification of emerging risks.34
Enforcement coordination
The MOU also establishes a framework for coordinated enforcement activity. Recognizing the risks of duplicative investigations, inconsistent remedial orders and disproportionate outcomes, the Agencies have committed to consulting with one another on enforcement matters involving potential jurisdictional overlap, while preserving each Agency's independent statutory authority and any applicable legal privileges.35
As a practical matter, this means that when an investigation touches on areas of potential shared jurisdiction, the Agencies will flag the matter for interagency consultation at the outset.36 From there, they will confer on areas of mutual programmatic interest and jurisdictional overlap, including, where appropriate, before issuing any Wells notice or similar pre-charging communication.37 Where parallel enforcement actions are contemplated, the Agencies will coordinate on potential charges and relief, the sequencing and timing of filings, litigation strategy and public communications.38
Conclusion
The March 2026 SEC-CFTC MOU marks a substantial, notable shift toward more coordinated regulation of increasingly integrated securities and derivatives markets. While the MOU does not itself change any rules or create binding obligations, it establishes a clear commitment to reducing unnecessary duplication and bringing greater coherence to the US securities and derivatives regulatory frameworks. If the Agencies follow through on even a meaningful portion of the agenda outlined in the MOU, the practical benefits could be significant.
For dually-registered firms, the MOU should prompt a fresh look at existing compliance architectures. Now is an opportune time to take stock of where dual obligations create genuine redundancy, identify areas where streamlined or alternative compliance approaches may become available and begin positioning for engagement with both Agencies as the harmonization agenda moves from principle to practice.
In particular, dually-registered firms should consider:
- Mapping the full scope of overlapping SEC and CFTC obligations across the firm’s business—including registration and reporting, capital, margin, business conduct standards and examination preparedness—to identify where dual compliance is most burdensome
- Identifying specific areas where existing compliance efforts may be unnecessarily duplicative in light of the MOU's functional and risk-based harmonization principles, and assessing where regulatory relief is most likely to materialize
- Designing practical, compliance solutions that eliminate unnecessary overlap without compromising the investor protection and market integrity standards the Agencies expect
- Engaging with the Agencies as part of the harmonization initiative
We will continue to track the Agencies' progress in implementing the MOU. Please contact our financial services team with any questions.
Footnotes
-
See SEC and CFTC, Memorandum of Understanding Between the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission and the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission Regarding Harmonization in Areas of Common Regulatory Interest, Preamble (March 11, 2026) (“MOU”); see also SEC and CFTC, Fact Sheet – Memorandum of Understanding Between the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (March 11, 2026) (“Fact Sheet”).
-
MOU, at signature page (signed Mar. 11, 2026 by SEC Chairman Paul S. Atkins and CFTC Chairman Michael S. Selig).
-
MOU, Preamble.
-
MOU, Preamble.
-
MOU, Art. III, § 5(d); see SEC and CFTC, Memorandum of Understanding Between the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission and the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission Regarding Harmonization in Areas of Common Regulatory Interest (July 11, 2018).
-
MOU, Art. III, § 5(c); see also SEC and CFTC, Memorandum of Understanding Between the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission and the U.S. Commodity Futures Trading Commission Regarding the Oversight of Security Futures Product Trading and the Sharing of Security Futures Product Information (March 17, 2004).
-
MOU, Art. II.
-
MOU, Art. II, Guiding Principle 1.
-
MOU, Art. II, Guiding Principle 2.
-
MOU, Art. II, Guiding Principle 3.
-
MOU, Art. II, Guiding Principle 4.
-
MOU, Art. II, Guiding Principle 5.
-
MOU, Art. III, § 2; MOU, Art. III, §§ 2(a)–(f); Fact Sheet.
-
MOU, Art. III, § 3.
-
MOU, Art. IV, § 1.
-
MOU, Art. IV, § 2.
-
MOU, Art. IV, § 2.
-
MOU, Art. IV, § 3(a)–(d).
-
MOU, Art. IV, § 4.
-
MOU, Art. II (Senior-Level Coordination Process).
-
MOU, Art. I (Definition of "Covered Firms").
-
MOU, Art. V, § 1; Fact Sheet.
-
MOU, Art. I (Definition of "Covered Firms").
-
MOU, Art. III, § 2(e).
-
MOU, Art. V, § 1(b).
-
MOU, Art. I (Definition of "Covered Firms"); MOU, Art. I (Definitions of "Swap Dealer" and "Security-Based Swap Dealer").
-
MOU, Art. III, §§ 2(a)–(b).
-
MOU, Art. I (Definition of "Covered Firms"); MOU, Art. I (Definitions of "Swap Execution Facility" and "Security-Based Swap Execution Facility").
-
MOU, Art. III, § 2(c); Fact Sheet.
-
MOU, Art. I (Definition of "SFP").
-
MOU, MOU, Art. III, § 5(c). Art. III, § 5(c).
-
MOU, Art. I (Definition of "Swap"); MOU, Art. I (Definition of "Security-Based Swap").
-
MOU, Art. IV, § 2.
-
MOU, Art. V, § 2; Fact Sheet.
-
MOU, Art. V, § 2(a).
-
MOU, Art. V, § 2(b).
-
MOU, Art. V, § 2(d).
-
Fact Sheet.