The FTC's overhaul of merger reporting requirements suffered another blow on March 19, 2026, when the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals, in a one-sentence per curiam order, denied the agency's motion to stay a February 12 district court ruling that struck down the new rules. The underlying decision, issued by a federal judge in Texas, held that the FTC failed to show that the new Hart-Scott-Rodino (HSR) filing requirements—the first major overhaul in nearly 50 years—were justified by their benefits relative to the substantial costs imposed on merging parties. The ruling, which granted summary judgment to the US Chamber of Commerce and other business groups, invalidated the revamped HSR form that had taken effect in February 2025.

Following the Fifth Circuit's denial of the stay, the FTC announced on March 19, 2026, that the district court's judgment vacating the new form is effective immediately. The agency is now accepting HSR filings using the Form and Instructions that were in place before the February 10, 2025, effective date of the new rule. The FTC stated that it is in the process of updating its website to effectuate the court's order and will make relevant HSR filing materials available for filers soon. Notably, the agency will continue to accept HSR filings made pursuant to the February 10, 2025, Form and Instructions should filers voluntarily decide to submit them.

Background

The HSR form overhaul was approved in 2024 in a unanimous 5-0 bipartisan vote by the FTC, with the new requirements taking effect in February 2025. The changes dramatically expanded the volume and scope of information that merging parties are required to submit upfront when notifying antitrust enforcers of a proposed transaction.

Among the most significant new requirements, merging parties were obligated to submit:

  • A broader scope of transaction-related documents, including materials from deal team supervisors and any documents–even nonfinal drafts–shared with at least one board member
  • Ordinary course business documents in areas where the merging parties' operations overlap
  • Narrative descriptions of competitive overlaps between the parties' business lines
  • Disclosures identifying investors in the acquiring entity who hold influence over the transaction
  • Information about minority stakeholders in the merging companies, with a particular focus on private equity investors
  • Detailed information on vertical and other nonhorizontal dimensions of the deal, including supply chain relationships and products still in development

The FTC justified these changes by arguing that antitrust enforcers needed substantially more information at the outset to properly evaluate whether proposed transactions would violate antitrust law. The agency pointed to what it characterized as "significant gaps in the information generated for premerger review under the current HSR rules."

The district court's decision

In a detailed 34-page opinion, the district court concluded that the FTC's overhaul was unlawful on two independent grounds–one rooted in the HSR Act itself, the other in the Administrative Procedure Act (APA).

Exceeding statutory authority

First, the court held that the final rule exceeded the FTC's statutory authority. The HSR Act permits the agency to require only information that is "necessary and appropriate" to evaluate whether a transaction would violate antitrust law. Drawing on the Fifth Circuit's 2023 decision in Mexican Gulf Fishing Co. v. U.S. Department of Commerce, the district court concluded that the FTC failed to demonstrate that the rule's purported benefits would "reasonably outweigh" the significant and widespread compliance costs imposed on merging companies.

As the court put it: "Though the FTC asserts that the rule will detect illegal mergers and save agency resources, the FTC fails to substantiate these assertions." The rule, the district court concluded, was therefore not “necessary and appropriate."

Arbitrary and capricious under the APA

Second, the court found the rule "arbitrary and capricious" under the APA on closely related grounds: the FTC had not adequately weighed the rule's benefits against its costs. The district court was particularly critical of the agency's failure to explain why it rejected less costly and less burdensome alternatives that could have achieved similar objectives.

Key takeaways

  • The new HSR form has been struck down and the old form is back in effect. The district court's judgment striking down the comprehensive changes to the HSR premerger notification requirements that took effect in February 2025 is now effective immediately, and the FTC has confirmed it is accepting filings under the prior Form and Instructions.
  • Watch for further developments. The FTC is in the process of updating its website and will make relevant filing materials available soon. Companies that have already begun preparing filings under the new form may still submit them voluntarily, but are no longer required to do so. We will continue to monitor guidance from the FTC’s Premerger Notification Office as the transition unfolds.

Companies engaged in M&A activity should consult with antitrust counsel regarding the transition back to the prior HSR filing requirements and should monitor the FTC's website for updated filing materials and any further guidance.

Contact