As we reported last week, the old HSR form is back in effect after the Fifth Circuit refused to stay a Texas federal court ruling that struck down the FTC's 2025 overhaul of premerger notification requirements. Now, the FTC and the DOJ's Antitrust Division (together, the Agencies) have taken a significant next step: launching a joint public inquiry to assess the effectiveness of the vacated updated form and to shape what comes next.
What the RFI covers
In effect, the Agencies are using the vacatur of the 2025 HSR form as an opportunity not to retreat, but to repackage and potentially broaden several of the most consequential concepts in a new rulemaking. Before the vacatur order, the updated form was in place for more than a year, during which practitioners prepared, and Agency staff reviewed, over 3,000 filings across a wide range of transactions. The Agencies state that they are drawing on that body of experience, to understand whether the updated form's requirements effectively fulfilled their intended purpose: enabling the Agencies to identify potentially anticompetitive mergers more efficiently and to determine more swiftly whether a second request would be necessary to assess a transaction’s likely competitive effects.
The Agencies believe that the prior, nearly 50-year-old form is insufficient to review modern mergers and acquisitions, and regardless of the outcome of the pending appeal, are considering engaging in a new rulemaking process. The proposed changes, which we have highlighted below, are significant, particularly in light of the district court’s finding that the benefits of the updated form and its associated rules were not justified given the substantial burden they imposed on merging parties.
Topics on which the agencies seek comment
In addition to asking whether the updated form improves premerger review and whether its costs are justified by its benefits, the RFI asks whether safe harbors or materiality thresholds could reduce compliance complexity or uncertainty for transactions less likely to raise competitive concerns. It also seeks comment on a number of additional modifications, including:
- New disclosure around CFIUS and sovereign wealth funds. The Agencies are considering whether to require filers to disclose compliance with CFIUS‑related legal obligations and to evaluate whether the current form adequately captures information regarding sovereign wealth funds and their associated sovereigns.
- Expanded reporting for defense sector transactions. Under the 2025 form, parties were required to report contracts with the Department of War only for transactions with a horizontal competitive overlap between them. To facilitate closer coordination with the Department of War and to support a resilient and competitive defense supply chain, the Agencies are considering whether to expand those requirements to encompass contracts with, or direct and indirect sales to, the United States, irrespective of any existing horizontal overlap between the merging parties.
- Capturing non-traditional deal structures. The Agencies report that they have seen a growing number of transactions that fall outside current HSR reporting requirements but effectively eliminate a competitive market participant—such as licensing transactions coupled with “acquihires” or “reverse acquihires,” and investments involving convertible securities. In response, the Agencies are considering whether amendments to the updated form and HSR regulations are necessary to address these non‑traditional transaction structures.
- New or supplemental filings for late-stage remedy proposals. When parties propose changes to a transaction late in the review process, or even after enforcement litigation has commenced, the Agencies currently lack a mechanism to extend the waiting period to evaluate the revised transaction or proposed divestiture. The Agencies are therefore considering whether, and in what circumstances, such late‑stage remedy proposals should trigger new or supplemental HSR filing requirements.
- Single-family housing and real estate exemptions. Pursuant to a Presidential directive, the Agencies are considering whether to make changes to HSR regulations to address substantial acquisitions of single-family homes in local markets by large institutional investors.
- Scope of “solely for the purpose of investment” exemption: The Agencies are seeking comments on whether to provide updated guidance on the HSR Act’s Solely-for-the-Purpose-of-Investment Exemption and how the Agencies should balance the efficient allocation of capital in affected transactions against risks of creating loopholes that could facilitate HSR evasion.
- AI tools in HSR practice. The Agencies are also seeking input on the costs associated with requiring filers to disclose their use of artificial intelligence or generative AI tools in preparing HSR submissions, including in identifying and selecting documents and the extent to which the use of AI tools may mitigate the burden of complying with the vacated updated HSR form. This request appears to be motivated by a desire to demonstrate ways in which merging parties might reduce the burden associated with the proposed new rules—for example, to put the FTC in a better position should the proposed rules be challenged.
Key takeaways
- Comment deadline is May 26, 2026. Comments must be received no later than May 26, 2026, by 11:59 pm ET and can be submitted at Regulations.gov. The Agencies encourage members of the public—including consumers, legal practitioners, industry representatives, workers, businesses, startups, potential market entrants, investors and academics—to comment on any issues or concerns relevant to the Agencies' consideration.
- Further HSR changes are likely regardless of litigation outcome. The FTC's stated interest in new rulemaking signals that companies engaged in M&A activity should not assume the reinstatement of the old form represents a permanent return to the pre-2025 status quo.
- The RFI covers a broad range of deal types. The breadth of the topics under consideration suggests that the next iteration of HSR reform could affect a wide range of transactions and industries.
- Continue using the “old” HSR form for now. For the immediate future, parties should anticipate continuing to file on the HSR form that was in effect until February 2025. A ruling from the Fifth Circuit is not expected until at least the end of 2026 and it will take the FTC some number of months to propose and finalize any changes based on this new rulemaking.
- New rulemaking also could be subject to future challenge. Even assuming that the new rules are finalized, it is possible that private plaintiffs may seek to enjoin such rules based on what appears to be a significant potential burden that they may pose to merging parties.
Companies engaged in M&A activity should consult with antitrust counsel to assess whether to participate in the comment process and to monitor further developments as the Agencies consider their next steps.