Key takeaway
A foreign registered company in Australia may become subject to competing insolvency processes when creditors initiate a winding up in Australia as well as insolvency proceedings in the company’s place of incorporation. This can raise complex issues of comity, recognition, assistance, the authority of the company’s directors to contest the relevant insolvency filings and prejudice to creditors, requiring careful balancing of competing interests and obligations.
Even without an application for recognition and assistance under the UNCITRAL Model Law on Cross-Border Insolvency (Model Law), section 581 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (Act) provides a flexible pathway for court-to-court cooperation, including joint hearings and determinations, to resolve the substantive issues in dispute and enhance procedural efficiency.
The case
Mawson Infrastructure Group Inc, a Delaware-incorporated company now trading as Big Digital Energy Inc, ran modular data centres in the US and Australia. Mawson was also registered as a foreign entity under Part 5.7 of the Act. By late 2024, the Australian side of the business ceased trading. In October 2024, one of Mawson’s creditors obtained default judgment for unpaid debts and filed a winding up application, which was supported by a second creditor.
While the winding up application was adjourned, those same creditors filed an involuntary Chapter 11 petition in the US. Under section 362 of the US Bankruptcy Code, the filing of an involuntary petition is expressed to give rise to a worldwide automatic stay.
Following a contested winding up hearing, and despite the Chapter 11 petition, Mawson was ordered to be wound up in Australia in February 2025. The US proceedings were later dismissed with prejudice in November 2025, with Judge Walrath also ordering that “the Australian liquidation proceedings against Mawson … and any custodianship of the liquidator in connection therewith shall not be reinstated”. Although Mawson’s counsel argued before the US court that the Australian winding up was void ab initio for breach of the automatic stay, Judge Walrath did not formally determine that question and the US orders expressly left open “the propriety or effectiveness of the appointment of the liquidator”.
Mawson filed a US adversary complaint in January 2026, arguing the involuntary petition was brought in bad faith based on fictitious debts, and later also sought contempt orders against the Australian liquidator for continuing the Australian winding up.
In May 2026, the liquidator applied to terminate the Australian winding up, which was opposed by the creditors that had applied for the original winding up orders. Mawson was given leave to appear as an interested person in the hearing.
First judgment
On 30 June 2026, Justice Downes in the Federal Court declined to terminate the Australian winding up in Gray (liquidator) v Marshall Investments GCP Pty Ltd [2026] FCA 848. Material matters in support of that determination included:
- Mawson did not contend at the original winding up hearing that the winding up order could not be made due to the worldwide stay invoked under US law having extraterritorial effect;
- Mawson had in fact taken the opposite position before the US Bankruptcy Court, alleging the Australian winding up violated the automatic stay (which position led to the orders prohibiting reinstatement), and this may have misstated the position to the US Bankruptcy Court or meant that not all relevant facts were placed before it;
- the US proceeding had not been the subject of an application for recognition as a foreign main proceeding under the Model Law, nor had the US Bankruptcy Court sent a letter of request seeking assistance. Accordingly, no automatic stay of Australian proceedings had arisen from the US filing;
- there was evidence that Mawson appeared to be insolvent and Mawson had not adduced evidence to the contrary, and it was “contrary to commercial morality” for Mawson to have incurred debts in Australia and then ceased trading without paying those debts;
- in making the orders prohibiting reinstatement of the Australian liquidation, Judge Walrath expressly left open “the propriety or effectiveness of the appointment of the liquidator”; and
- the liquidator, as an officer of the court, remained obliged to perform his statutory obligations.
Second judgment
Mawson subsequently applied to the Federal Court seeking, among other things, to be joined as a plaintiff to the liquidator’s application to terminate the Australian winding up, effectively so Mawson could “re-enliven” the application on its own behalf rather than relying on the liquidator as its deemed agent.
The difficulty was that section 482(1A) of the Act limits standing to bring a termination application to creditors, contributories and the liquidator, while section 198G of the Act suspends the functions and powers of a company’s directors upon the appointment of a liquidator. Mawson argued that neither barrier applied to it, on the basis that:
- as a registered foreign company incorporated outside Australia (i.e., a Part 5.7 body under the Act), Mawson was not a “company” for the purpose of section 198G of the Act, meaning the powers and functions of Mawson's US-based directors were not suspended in Australia upon the appointment of the liquidator;
- Mawson could therefore bring an application in Australia to terminate its own winding up without needing the permission of the court; and
- alternatively, Mawson had sufficient standing under section 482 of the Act to bring an application terminating the winding up in its own right even though the right to commence such an application is expressed to be limited to creditors, contributories and a liquidator under section 482(1A). This was alleged to be on the basis that the winding up provisions of the Act are expressed by section 583 to apply to a Part 5.7 body “with such adaptations as are necessary”, and this was one such necessary adaptation.
Justice Downes rejected those arguments in Gray (liquidator) v Marshall Investments GCP Pty Ltd (No 2) [2026] FCA 1066, finding that:
- a registered foreign company wound up under Part 5.7 of the Act is a “company” for the purposes of the relevant provisions of the Act, including section 198G;
- further, section 198G prevents an officer of a company from performing or exercising functions or powers of that office while the company is “under external administration”, and the Insolvency Practice Schedule treats a company as being under external administration once a liquidator has been appointed;
- the powers and functions of Mawson's directors were accordingly suspended in Australia upon the liquidator's appointment;
- Mawson had not explained why it was a “necessary” adaptation to section 482(1A) of the Act to permit Mawson to have standing to bring or agitate the termination application;
- as Mawson had been granted leave to appear as an interested party, it was entitled to be heard on any application. Mawson could also assist the liquidator's application to terminate the winding up (e.g. by adducing evidence in support of the liquidator’s termination application), so that its interests were sufficiently protected; and
- the Part 5.7 winding up provisions operate only on the affairs of the body outside its place of origin (section 583(d) of the Act). Accordingly, section 198G suspended the directors’ functions and powers in Australia only, and did not affect their ability to continue acting on behalf of Mawson in its place of incorporation in the United States.
In the course of her decision, Justice Downes also noted that Judge Walrath had written to her “for the purposes of communicating so as to achieve potential cooperation between our courts”.
Further developments: court-to-court cooperation
A joint case management hearing was conducted between the Federal Court and the US Bankruptcy Court on 7 August 2026. Justice Downes made orders, among other things:
- inviting submissions from the parties on “any proposals as to whether a joint hearing proceeds, and if it does, the issues to be addressed”; and
- permitting Justice Downes and Judge Walrath to “discuss or correspond with one another in respect of the proposed orders and issues of case management in the absence of the parties”.
On 28 August 2026, Justice Downes wrote to Judge Walrath formally requesting cooperation and assistance to enable the continued winding up of Mawson in Australia. While the scope of the request is yet to be determined, and is the subject of ongoing submissions from the parties, this may lead to a further joint hearing between the Federal Court and the US Bankruptcy Court on substantive issues, including the validity of the Australian winding up, any conflict between the Australian and US orders and Mawson’s solvency position and scope of assets in Australia.
Final thoughts
The Mawson proceedings show that comity is by no means a “blank cheque” in cross-border insolvency matters. Foreign insolvency laws will not have automatic effect in Australia absent an application for recognition or a specific request for assistance and cooperation being issued to an Australian court.
Nevertheless, there is an established process under the Act for an Australian court to seek the assistance and cooperation of a foreign court to facilitate an Australian insolvency process, even absent an application from an Australian external administrator seeking recognition of that process in the foreign jurisdiction under applicable Model Law provisions.
This can provide a pathway for proactive cooperation and assistance between Australian and foreign courts, with a view to minimising the potential for inconsistent insolvency processes and orders and enhancing efficiency and fairness for creditors.
Read the judgments and orders
You can access (as at the time of publication of this post):