The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has published the final version of its rules and guidance setting out the conditions on which firms will be able to rely on the ancillary activity exemption (AAE) in the UK from 1 January 2027. This is a key exemption on which many companies that enter into commodity derivatives, emission allowances and derivatives on emission allowances rely.

Below are the key points to be aware of.

1. When might someone need to use the AAE?

Entering into commodity and emission allowance derivatives and buying and selling emission allowances, as well as providing various services in relation to them, are regulated and require authorisation in the UK unless an exclusion applies and, where the activity is an investment service within the scope of MiFID II, an exemption also applies. The AAE is the key exemption for these types of financial instruments. The briefing note does not discuss the possible exclusions which may need to be used alongside it.

2. When can (or can’t) you can’t use the AAE?

You can use the AAE when you deal on own account or you provide investment services or both and this is ancillary to your main business when considered on a group basis. This only applies in relation to commodity and emission allowance derivatives and emission allowances so you would need different exemptions for other instruments, like FX derivatives. There are a couple of wrinkles relating to dealing on own account when executing client orders and the fact that investment services must be provided to clients or suppliers of your main business or that of your group.

However, importantly, you have to be a person whose main business, when considered on a group basis, is not the provision of investment services or banking activities or acting as a market maker for commodity derivatives. You also cannot be someone who does high frequency algorithmic trading. These requirements combined are essentially pre-conditions to using the AAE.

3. When is this activity considered to be ancillary?

This is what the FCA has been working on – finding a more effective way to determine when your potentially regulated activity is ancillary to your main business at group level because the previous MiFID II test involved some complex calculations, parts of which no longer work post-Brexit.

The conclusion after a couple of iterations and as presented in the policy statement is that you need to satisfy any one of three tests: a new de minimis test, a revised trading test and a revised capital employed test. Technically the new de minimis test is excluding you from being an investment firm, whereas the other two are answering the ancillary question, but the effect is the same: if you satisfy the pre-conditions above and one of these three tests, you can rely on the ancillary activity exemption.

4. How does the de minimis test work?

This is the new test for the UK, which the FCA refers to as the annual threshold test. A company would satisfy this test if its net outstanding notional exposure in commodity derivatives or emission allowances or derivatives on them, for cash settlement, traded in the UK and excluding those traded on a trading venue, is below £3 billion. For these purposes, a trading venue includes a UK recognised investment exchange (RIE), an EU regulated market and a third country trading venue that performs a similar function to a UK RIE, a multilateral trading facility (MTF) or an organised trading facility (OTF), so you’re looking at over-the-counter (OTC) contracts only. There are various rules on how you calculate this, but the key points are that you have to include other members of the group, you exclude certain positions and there is a special netting methodology.

5. How does the revised trading test work?

This is a much-simplified version of the trading test that previously existed in the UK as was based on the Markets in Financial Instruments Directive II (MiFID II). Under the new version, a company’s activities will be ancillary to the main business of its group where they constitute 50% or less of the total size of the other trading activities of the group. You compare the gross notional value of all contracts in commodity derivatives, emission allowances and derivatives on them that are traded by each of:

  • the company that seeks to rely on the exemption; and
  • the other companies in the group.

You’re looking at these instruments as traded on a UK trading venue or not traded on a UK trading venue but entered into by a group member from an establishment in the UK. Importantly, you exclude certain positions from the figure for the company and include them in the figure for the group.

6. How does the capital employed test work?

This is an updated version of the old capital employed test. A company’s activities will be ancillary to the main business of its group where the estimated capital for carrying out those activities accounts for not more than 50% of the capital employed at group level for carrying out the main business of the group. The numerator is the sum of:

  • 15% of each net position (which has to be calculated a particular way) multiplied by the price for the commodity derivative, emission allowance or derivative on an emission allowance; and
  • 3% of the gross position (also calculated a particular way) multiplied by the price.

You take account of all contracts traded in the UK to which any person in the group is party and which are traded on a UK trading venue or are not traded on a trading venue.

The denominator is the sum of:

  • the total assets of the group minus its short-term debt as recorded in the consolidated financial statements of the group;
  • minus its short-term debt as recorded in its consolidated financial statements of the group;
  • at the end of the relevant calculation period and applies to worldwide activities of group members, wherever located.

7. What is an excluded transaction

When undertaking your calculations, there are certain types of transactions that don’t need to be included in the certain parts of the calculations. These are referred to as excluded positions and are:

  • Intra-group transactions that serve group wide liquidity or risk management purposes;
  • Transactions which are objectively measurable as reducing risks directly relating to commercial activity or treasury financing activity (referred to shorthand as hedging transactions);
  • Transactions entered into to fulfil obligations to provide liquidity on a UK trading venue, where such obligations are required by regulatory authorities under UK MiFID or by UK trading venues; and
  • Contracts where the person within the group that is party to them is FCA authorised.

8. When does a contract qualify as a hedging transaction?

This carve out has traditionally been quite generous and this looks set to continue in the UK. The transaction has to satisfy one of three tests to be excluded under the hedging limb:

  • It reduces the risks arising from the potential change in the value of various assets and liabilities in the normal course of its business;
  • It covers the risks arising from the potential indirect impact on those values resulting from fluctuations in interest rates, inflation rates, foreign exchange rates or credit risk;
  • It qualifies as a hedging contract for UK accounting purposes.

There is some further guidance on the extent to which transactions entered into to manage risk on a portfolio basis or dynamically as risks change over time count for these purposes.

9. What do you need to do if you want to be able to rely on the ancillary activity exemption?

Each of the three tests requires some detailed calculation. This is done in the first quarter of the calendar year and requires a company to look at the three annual calculation periods preceding such date. The company relying on the exemption does not need to notify the FCA but should retain records of its workings and conclusions because it is a condition of the exemption that it reports to the FCA on the basis on which it considers it can rely on the exemption on the FCA ‘s request.

10. Can a non-UK company need to use the AAE? Would it ever need to?

As is often the case, the territorial scope of regulatory provisions is not very clear. We believe a non-UK person may need to use the AAE even though they might not be said to doing business in the UK. This could be the case where it trades on a UK trading venue or enters into OTC transactions with UK counterparties. There is an overseas person exclusion which might be an alternative in some cases but where it does not apply, the AAE is likely to be key.

Contact