Key takeaway

The decision of the Singapore International Commercial Court (SICC) in Re Jetstar Asia Airways Pte Ltd [2026] SGHC(I) 22 (Jetstar Asia Airways) confirms the ability of Singapore courts to sanction a scheme of arrangement containing the US concept of an “administrative convenience class”. Such a class allows the scheme debtor to include a large number of small-value creditor claims within a single non-voting class and deem consent to the scheme to have been provided by those creditors.

While the decision was in the context of a solvent scheme under the Companies Act 1967 (CA), the same potential is open to debtors in an insolvent scheme in Singapore, given the similar breadth of judicial discretion under the Insolvency, Restructuring and Dissolution Act 2018 (IRDA) with respect to the conduct of scheme meetings and a previous decision to that effect in Re Zipmex Pte Ltd [2024] 3 SLR 724 (Re Zipmex), which was a pre-packaged scheme under section 71 of the IRDA.

In each case, however, it is critical to show the proposed administrative convenience class is reasonable and necessary and would not cause undue prejudice. Full payment of the creditors placed in the class is a particularly material factor in that regard.

The SICC’s decision reflects a strong pattern for Singapore courts to read flexibility and creativity into the restructuring regime to facilitate pragmatic, commercial outcomes that maximise value for creditors and enhance rescue outcomes.

Background

Jetstar Asia Airways Pte Ltd (Jetstar Asia) was the operating entity of the “Jetstar Asia” business. After Jetstar Asia’s parent company, Australian carrier Qantas, elected to cease its operations in South East Asia and Japan, Jetstar Asia’s directors announced the permanent end to the Jetstar Asia business and the solvent winding up of Jetstar Asia in June 2025.

With financial support from the Qantas Group, Jetstar Asia then launched a refund program to repay eligible retail customers and settle Jetstar Asia’s remaining liabilities.

As part of the refund program, eligible customers could obtain full refunds for their unused tickets, vouchers and other credits through multiple channels, including automatic refunds where possible. Despite Jetstar Asia taking various measures to increase awareness of the refund program, uptake remained at only around 30% of total eligible customers by January 2026.

In an effort to finalise these arrangements, and with the Qantas Group’s financial support ceasing on 30 June 2026 (after which Jetstar Asia intended to commence a members’ voluntary liquidation), Jetstar Asia proposed a scheme of arrangement and sought the SICC’s sanction for the scheme under section 210 of the CA. The sanction application was brought under that provision as a solvent scheme (given the Qantas Group’s financial backing) and therefore Jetstar Asia did not require any of the Part 5 IRDA restructuring tools (for example, moratorium, cram-down, pre-pack).

The voting test is the same for solvent and insolvent schemes under s 210(3AB) of the CA, which is a majority in number representing 75% in value of those present and voting in each class, subject to the court’s power to dispense with or modify the count. However, in a solvent scheme where every class is paid in full, the court is more willing to relax the vote.

Justice Christopher Sontchi sanctioned Jetstar Asia’s scheme on 21 May 2026 and released his reasons for doing so on 24 September 2026.

Structure and content of the scheme

The scheme was intended to bind two categories of creditors:

  • Consumer Creditors – being natural persons or authorised sales agents with claims against Jetstar Asia for flight tickets, bookings or vouchers. This amounted to around 194,200 creditors, with aggregate claims of approximately S $11.394 million; and
  • Non-Consumer Creditors – being all other creditors (excluding employees, tax authorities, professional advisors and Qantas Group members) with claims against Jetstar Asia. Total approved claims in this category were around S $1.065 million.

Upon the scheme becoming effective, the claims of all Consumer Creditors would be assumed by an existing Qantas Group entity operating in the Australian and New Zealand aviation markets, Jetstar Airways Pty Ltd (TransferCo). This would give Consumer Creditors full recourse on an ongoing basis (via the refund program) against TransferCo, notwithstanding the intention for Jetstar Asia to be wound up.

Consumer Creditors were placed in a single, separate, non-voting administrative convenience class on the basis they were not required to take any action in relation to the scheme. Non-Consumer Creditors were to be paid in cash within 20 business days of the scheme becoming effective, subject to a proof of debt process overseen by a scheme manager, with disputes referable to a court-appointed independent assessor. This departure from the default procedure was approved under section 68(14)(a) of the IRDA, with the court holding that a variation should be granted where the proposed procedure is more efficient and practical and does not cause substantial prejudice.

At the scheme meeting convened on 15 April 2026, all nine Non-Consumer Creditors present voted in favour of the scheme.

Sanction of the scheme

Most aspects of the scheme were uncontroversial and routine. Among other things, appropriate disclosure of the scheme had been made to creditors and Justice Sontchi held that the scheme was manifestly reasonable, as both Consumer Creditors and Non-Consumer Creditors stood to be paid in full. The binding effect of the deed of assumption of liability by the TransferCo had also been confirmed in advice from Australian counsel. The unanimous approval of the scheme by Non-Consumer Creditors who voted (an objection later lodged by another Non-Consumer Creditor was withdrawn after a settlement was reached) was also significant in the sanction decision.

However, the particularly notable aspect of the scheme was the relatively novel application of an administrative convenience class with respect to Consumer Creditors. The material question for Justice Sontchi was whether placing all Consumer Creditors in a single class and deeming their consent to have been obtained satisfied the scheme requirements (including proper classification) under Singapore law.

At the invitation of the applicant’s counsel, Justice Sontchi used his reasons for decision primarily as an occasion to “explain the genesis of the administrative convenience class and provide some guidance on its use”, with a view to making an important contribution to Singapore law. This is the most complete treatment of this mechanism in Singapore law to date, though noting it is an uncontested first-instance decision (and hence its guidance remains to be tested in an adversarial context).

The administrative convenience class – relevant principles

In considering whether the Singapore court has the power to authorise the creation of an administrative convenience class, Justice Sontchi had regard to the position under US law. He noted that, in connection with a Chapter 11 reorganisation plan, section 1122(b) of the US Bankruptcy Code expressly permits the creation of a class which is “reasonable and necessary for administrative convenience”. That provision works in tandem with section 1126(f), under which an unimpaired class (being one whose interests are entirely unaffected by the proposed plan) is conclusively presumed to have accepted the plan, so that it is not necessary to solicit acceptance of the plan from each creditor of that class.

Justice Sontchi held that, while there is no express provision under Singapore law which sanctions the creation of an administrative convenience class, section 210(3AB)(a) of the CA gives the court the power to vary the required creditor voting thresholds. Further, section 210(1) of the CA gives the court a broad discretion over how a scheme meeting is conducted.

Justice Sontchi held that these provisions together give the court “considerable latitude” sufficient to sanction the creation of an administrative convenience class under a scheme.

In considering the limits on the exercise of the court’s discretion to sanction such a class, Justice Sontchi drew on the decision in Re Zipmex, the first Singapore case to consider an administrative convenience class. The context in Re Zipmex was a pre-packaged scheme under section 71 of the IRDA for an insolvent cryptocurrency trading platform. Creditors whose claims were below US $5,000 were placed in an administrative convenience class and were excluded from the voting exercise unless they indicated their desire to participate, in return for receiving the full value of their claims (via access to their withheld assets).

After considering Re Zipmex, as well as relevant US decisions which explored the position under the US Bankruptcy Code, Justice Sontchi held that the use of an administrative convenience class in Singapore must be “reasonable and necessary”. In meeting that requirement, the scheme applicant must be able to “justify and substantiate the gains in efficacy, feasibility or administrative convenience arising from the creation of such a class.”

Justice Sontchi held that, unlike the position taken by US courts, Singapore courts must proactively scrutinise whether this requirement is met for every purported use of an administrative convenience class – given that “the proper classification of creditors is a crucial element in a scheme of arrangement and goes to the court’s jurisdiction to sanction a scheme”.

If satisfied an administrative convenience class is reasonable and necessary, Justice Sontchi held that the court must then consider any prejudice that would be caused to both the members of that class and the other parties affected by the scheme. In that regard, Justice Sontchi held:

  • an administrative convenience class should not be sanctioned “when the applicant’s intention, as ascertained from the surrounding circumstances, is to gerrymander or artificially engineer the use of the cross-class cram down mechanism under section 70 of the IRDA” – applicable for an insolvent scheme – “or where the creation of such a class is otherwise not done bona fide or is designed to skirt around opposition;” and
  • where the administrative convenience class proposed would not be entitled to vote on the scheme, “it must be clear that their interests are not adversely impacted by the scheme”, with a “clear example” of this being where the relevant creditors are offered full payment of their claims against the scheme company.

Justice Sontchi held that these requirements were readily satisfied in Jetstar Asia’s scheme, including on the basis that:

  • all scheme creditors stood to be paid in full, so Consumer Creditors suffered no adverse effect by the administrative convenience class arrangements, and Non-Consumer Creditors were also not adversely affected by the Consumer Creditors being paid in full;
  • requiring a vote would have forced the refund program to pause, causing greater prejudice as Consumer Creditors would no longer be able to have the refunds due to them immediately processed;
  • the scale of Consumer Creditors involved (around 194,000 creditors, with aggregate claims over 10 times the Non-Consumer Creditor claim total) and a voting infrastructure cost estimated by the applicant at US $346,000-500,000 were (at the applicant’s submission) “likely to be disproportionately expensive and cumbersome”, and thereby demonstrated genuine administrative necessity; and
  • the unanimous support of Non-Consumer Creditors, together with the absence of any sign of gamesmanship, indicated the administrative class was being pursued bona fide and in good faith.

An alternative option to debtors – exclusion of small claims altogether

As an alternative to the use of an administrative convenience class, Justice Sontchi observed that a scheme applicant could simply exclude unsecured creditors with relatively small claims from the proposed scheme altogether. Justice Sontchi noted that this had occurred in the UK restructuring plan sanctioned by the High Court in Re Virgin Atlantic Airways Ltd (No 2) [2021] 1 BCLC 105.

In that matter, the court held that the exclusion of a significant number of trade creditors, including those who were owed less than £50,000 as at the cut-off date, was justified because the cost of reviewing the underlying supply contracts relating to those claims (more than 1,000 suppliers) imposed a substantial logistical burden with limited time and resources. Further, including those trade creditors in the restructuring plan would only result in a further reduction in the company’s debt burden of around £1 million.

Concluding thoughts

Administrative convenience classes – which place large numbers of low-value claims in a single non-voting class – have now been confirmed as being available under Singapore law, both in solvent and insolvent schemes. This is a continued advance in Singapore’s growing reputation as a progressive, flexible and commercially pragmatic restructuring forum.

Jetstar Asia Airways confirms that approval of an administrative convenience class is grounded in the wide discretion of the Singapore court to sanction a scheme and tailor the conduct of relevant scheme meetings, even absent an express statutory power to approve such a class.

However, a Singapore court will proactively scrutinise whether an administrative convenience class is reasonable and necessary, and does not cause undue prejudice, before approving its use for a scheme-driven restructuring, even where no creditor objects. While full payment of the non-voting class would appear to be the clearest route to establishing this test, future cases may test the limits of the requirements identified in Jetstar Asia Airways in situations where less than full payment is proposed.

Read the judgment

You can access the full judgment (as at the time of publication of this post) here.

Recent articles

  • content-type:insights/blog
  • content-type:generic
  • nrf-migrated:article-categories/inside-disputes/type/blog-post