Reproduced from Practical Law with the permission of the publishers. For further information visit www.practicallaw.com.
In DVV v DVW [2026] SGHC 164, the Singapore High Court dismissed set-aside applications which challenged an arbitrator's decision to assess the quantum of claims under a construction subcontract but reserving his jurisdiction to make a payment order until questions of apportionment between joint venture partners were determined in a parallel arbitration.
The Singapore High Court has dismissed challenges to awards made in a construction arbitration where the arbitrator assessed the quantum of claims under a construction subcontract (Sub-Contract) between an unincorporated joint venture (JV) and one of its members, but reserved jurisdiction to make a payment order after determination of apportionment between the JV members in a parallel arbitration.
Two construction companies formed the JV to undertake a Singapore project, with the applicant and respondent holding 30% and 70% respectively under the JV agreement (JVA). The JV engaged the applicant as subcontractor under the Sub-Contract.
Later, the applicant commenced two parallel arbitrations: a SIAC arbitration under the JVA, and an ad hoc arbitration under the Sub-Contract against the respondent alone (the unincorporated JV could not be sued as an entity, and the applicant could not sue itself).
In the JVA arbitration, a partial award addressed most claims but deferred the respondent's counterclaim for an indemnity for sums awarded in the Sub-Contract arbitration. In the Sub-Contract arbitration, the arbitrator assessed the claims and counterclaims but deferred any payment orders, reserving jurisdiction to make those orders after the JVA tribunal addressed apportionment.
The applicant objected to the arbitrator's failure to make payment orders and applied to set aside the awards under section 48(1)(a)(iv) and (v) of the Arbitration Act 2001 on grounds that the arbitrator had addressed matters beyond the scope of submission to arbitration and had not followed the parties' agreed arbitral procedure. The court dismissed the applications.
The court rejected the argument that the arbitrator exceeded his jurisdiction (ultra petita) by not making payment orders, holding that this ground is engaged only where a tribunal decides something outside its mandate. Furthermore, the arbitrator had not failed to deal with an issue referred to him (infra petita). He had no jurisdiction over apportionment. Nor did he delegate his jurisdiction to make payment orders; he reserved it to himself.
The court viewed the applicant's real complaint as one about the form of the award rather than arbitral procedure. It was an impermissible attack on the merits of the arbitrator's decision that payment orders should await apportionment of liability between JV members.
This case is on unusual facts given the parallel arbitrations but demonstrates that the Singapore courts are alert to challenges to awards made on jurisdictional or procedural grounds which are, in substance, complaints as to merits.
Case: DVV v DVW [2026] SGHC 164 (6 August 2026) (Dedar Singh Gill J).