Introduction

Legal considerations when terminating employees in Singapore following the conduct of internal investigations have become increasingly complex and layered. Companies conducting misconduct investigations and taking disciplinary action may find themselves facing claims for wrongful dismissal by employees under both the Singapore Employment Act 1968 (EA) and common law.

In JGP v JGQ [2026] SGECT 1 (the first reported judgment from the Singapore Employment Claims Tribunals (ECT)), Tribunal Magistrate Jared Kang Chern Wey (Tribunal Magistrate) set out the principles applicable to a statutory claim for wrongful dismissal under Section 14(2) of the EA. Section 14(2) of the EA allows an employee dismissed “without just cause or excuse” to bring a claim against the employer for remedies in the form of either reinstatement of employment or compensation up to the prescribed limit of SGD 20,000 (or SGD 30,000 in cases involving unions) (the Section 14(2) Claim).

The case involved a regulated financial institution that had conducted a group-wide investigation into potential misuse of its outpatient medical benefits for employees. It discovered a large volume of reimbursement claims were submitted with receipts obtained from a particular clinic, and a substantial number of employees had utilised those receipts to seek reimbursement after purchasing retail items such as vitamins, supplements, skincare products and household goods, in breach of its medical claims policy. After conducting an internal investigation (including giving the employees notice of the allegations and an opportunity to answer them before an impartial disciplinary committee), the company dismissed around 40 employees for having intentionally, wilfully and/or dishonestly committed serious breaches of the medical claims policy.

The Tribunal Magistrate held that the company had wrongfully dismissed “without just cause or excuse” all six employees who brought Section 14(2) Claims against the company, including a relatively junior employee who had submitted 62 improper reimbursement claims totalling approximately SGD 10,000 over a seven-month period. This was despite the Tribunal Magistrate finding that the company had: (i) prior to dismissal, conducted due inquiry into the alleged misconduct which fulfilled all procedural requirements; and (ii) satisfied the contractual notice requirements for terminating the employment without cause. In particular, the Tribunal Magistrate disagreed with the company’s substantive decision to terminate the employee, as the employee was only guilty of a lesser wrong (namely, negligence not amounting to dishonesty), and her dismissal was disproportionate in view of her mitigating circumstances and the company’s treatment of other employees (who were only given warnings or bonus reductions). The Tribunal Magistrate awarded the employee compensation equivalent to four months’ salary for loss of income and non-pecuniary harm.

The Tribunal Magistrate’s decision has significant implications. It confirms that the presence or absence of contractual notice, or adherence to contractual procedure, is not determinative of whether the employer had “just cause or excuse” for dismissing the employee. In other words, an employee may succeed in a Section 14(2) Claim even if the employer had fully complied with the contractual requirements. Moreover, it departs from common interpretations of the EA and the Employment Claims Act 2016 (ECA) in holding that: (i) dismissal of an employee with notice (or payment in lieu of notice) may still be subject to the statutory requirement of “due inquiry” (under Section 14(1) of the EA (Section 14(1))), (ii) an employer that has chosen to not give reasons for dismissal may still be required to discharge its evidential burden of establishing “just cause or excuse”, and (iii) an employee who was fully paid all contractual entitlements (in the form of notice pay etc.) may still be entitled to recover compensation for loss of income and non-pecuniary losses post-termination if the dismissal was – in the ECT’s view – “without just cause or excuse”. The decision also effectively imposes additional requirements on the company’s exercise of its contractual right to terminate with notice (or payment in lieu of notice).

While it remains to be seen whether the decision would be upheld on appeal1 (or followed in other ECT cases), employers in Singapore should in the meantime:

  • bear in mind the relevant principles and lens through which the ECT may (re)examine both the substantive grounds and procedure of any dismissal, in handling employee misconduct matters; and
  • review existing disciplinary policies and procedures to ensure they not only satisfy the necessary procedural requirements, but also contain clear internal guidelines on (among other things) the yardsticks for any assessment of appropriate disciplinary action.

In this update, we highlight the key points arising from the Tribunal Magistrate’s decision.

Principles relevant to common law wrongful dismissal claims

For context, it is pertinent to understand the common law action for wrongful dismissal, to appreciate the differences from a Section 14(2) Claim. The ECT (where parties are to be self-represented) does not hear common law wrongful dismissal claims.

Under the law of contract, an employment contract governed by Singapore law can only be terminated pursuant to either an express term (providing for termination with or without notice or payment in lieu of notice), or, if no such express term is available, by relying on a repudiatory breach of the employment contract (e.g., an employee’s serious misconduct) which gives rise to the employer’s contractual right to terminate the employment summarily for cause (i.e., without notice or payment in lieu of notice). A dismissal that adheres to the contract is not “wrongful”, regardless of reason or motive.2

In this regard, it is well-established that an employer may dismiss an employee for any reason or none at all, as long as the requisite notice is given.3 Just as employees have the freedom to resign with notice, companies have the freedom to dismiss with notice. This position stems from the fundamental principles that parties are free to enter into and exit contracts, and are generally entitled to act in their own self-interests.

Damages for wrongful dismissal at common law are thus usually confined to the contractual notice pay and any other contractual entitlements that the employee would have received, had the employment been lawfully terminated with notice or pay in lieu of notice. If the employee had already been paid the full amount of notice pay (as well as other contractual entitlements), there would be no loss of earnings suffered by the employee, and accordingly nothing substantive to compensate. Reinstatement, or non-pecuniary damages for hurt feelings, mental distress or reputational injury are typically not awarded.4

Principles relevant to Section 14(2) Claims (for dismissal “without just cause or excuse”)

Under the EA, unless otherwise agreed by way of a mutual separation, an employment contract may only be terminated:

  1. by notice, satisfying the statutory minimum notice period based on the length of service;
  2. by payment of salary in lieu of notice in (A) above; or
  3. if no notice or payment in lieu of notice is given, by summary dismissal which is only permissible on “grounds of misconduct inconsistent with the fulfilment of the express or implied conditions of the employee’s service” (pursuant to Section 14(1)) or a “wilful breach … of a condition of the contract of service” (pursuant to Section 11(2) of the EA). Procedurally, Section 14(1) further mandates that an employer may (only) “after due inquiry dismiss without notice an employee … on the grounds of misconduct …”.

Section 14(2) provides that, despite Section 14(1), where an employee considers that he has been “dismissed without just cause or excuse”, he may lodge a Section 14(2) Claim (subject to requirements for mandatory mediation). Pursuant to Sections 20(7) and 35 of the ECA, the ECT “is to have regard to” the Tripartite Guidelines on Wrongful Dismissal (Tripartite Guidelines) “when deciding any claim involving a wrongful dismissal dispute”. Section 28 of the ECA prohibits parties from contracting out of the statutory framework for wrongful dismissal claims.

Against this backdrop, the Tribunal Magistrate held that, in the context of Section 14(2) Claims:

  • The Section 14(2) Claim sits apart from the common law action: Section 14(2) Claims are statutory in nature, and are governed by the EA and the ECA. They exist separately from, and in parallel to, wrongful dismissal claims under common law. While both are often referred to as claims for “wrongful dismissal”, they are “two very substantively different claims”, as the Parliament’s introduction of the phrase “without just cause or excuse” to Section 14(2) was to provide a new substantive safeguard which employees could invoke to seek a reasons-based scrutiny that was not previously available at common law.5
  • Compliance with the employment contract is insufficient: A claimant who invokes Section 14(2) litigates a statutory wrong. The ECT is tasked to determine whether “just cause or excuse” was absent. An employee may bring a Section 14(2) Claim, notwithstanding that the dismissal was conducted in compliance with the employment contract (for instance, by giving the required contractual notice or paying salary in lieu of notice, and complying with the contractual disciplinary framework). In other words, even if a company had fully complied with the contractual requirements, the company may still be found to have dismissed the employee “without just cause or excuse”. The presence or absence of contractual notice, or adherence to contractual procedure, is not determinative of the statutory claim.6
  • Breaches of the employment contract (including any contractual disciplinary framework) may be referred to as contextual aids, but do not determine a Section 14(2) Claim: To succeed under Section 14(2), the employee must show that the employer had no valid reason (i.e., no just cause) for termination. To do so, the employee may rely on breaches of the contractual disciplinary framework for context, as part of the evidential picture. For example, a failure to follow an agreed procedure may suggest the lack of “cause”, while compliance with the procedure may strengthen the employer’s case for dismissal.7
  • Meaning of “due inquiry” required under Section 14(1): Section 14(1) forbids summary dismissals except after due inquiry. “Due inquiry” requires that the employer must provide:8 (i) adequate and reasonably clear notice of the allegations the employer proposes to rely on;9 (ii) a real opportunity for the employee to answer those allegations and to place his explanation before the decision-maker;10 and (iii) fair, open-minded, impartial consideration of that explanation, before the employer decides on misconduct as a ground for dismissal.11 Although the inquiry need not be unduly formal, the more informal the process, the greater the risk that it will fall below the threshold.12
  • “Due inquiry” is required even if an employee is dismissed with notice, if the “real basis” for termination was misconduct: If the employer wishes to keep matters at the level of contractual election (ending the employment on notice with no accusation of misconduct), it may do so without triggering the “due inquiry” requirement; but once it crosses the line into alleging misconduct, the requirement of “due inquiry” arises. Where an employer chooses to rely on misconduct as the basis for ending the employment, “due inquiry” is required even if notice (or salary in lieu of notice) is given to the employee. The Section 14(1) safeguard for employees cannot be evaded simply because the employer elected to terminate with notice or notice pay, if misconduct was the real reason for dismissal.13
  • Relevance of “due inquiry” to a Section 14(2) Claim: Where “due inquiry” is required and procedurally fulfilled, the effect is only evidential; it does not determine a Section 14(2) Claim. A fair internal process strengthens confidence in the reliability and proportionality of the employer’s decisions, but does not, by itself, prove “just cause or excuse”. Conversely, where “due inquiry” is required and not fulfilled, that lapse does not of itself establish a claim under Section 14(2); it is, however, a material weakness that may warrant adverse inferences, making it harder for the employer to discharge its burden of proof.14
  • Truth and sufficiency are required to establish “just cause or excuse”: In assessing whether the reasons cited amount to “just cause or excuse” for the dismissal, the ECT will ascertain both:15 (i) truth (i.e., whether the material particulars of that reason, including any mental element the employer itself invoked, such as dishonesty or wilfulness, are proved);16 and (ii) sufficiency (i.e., whether the proved facts, in context, amount to “just cause or excuse” justifying dismissal or rather only warrant a lesser penalty).17
  • Sufficiency takes into account the relative treatment of employees: As an element of sufficiency, the ECT will consider if there was parity of treatment of employees within the company. Like cases ought, in general, to be treated alike unless there is a principled distinction (e.g., based on seniority and responsibility; degree and duration of participation; prior record; the employee’s candour, cooperation and remorse; business risk and trust-sensitivities in role; and any safety or regulatory implications). If the company retained employees found to have committed the same wrong, by issuing warnings and reducing bonuses rather than dismissing them, such practice is strong evidence that dismissal is disproportionate and without “just cause or excuse”.18
  • A lesser wrong may be relied upon by the employer as a fallback: Where the employer’s stated reason, as framed in the notice of termination, is not proved at that level but the evidence establishes a lesser wrong, the ECT may consider that lesser basis if: (i) the lesser basis is within the gravamen of what was fairly put to the employee before dismissal (as a wholly new and different rationale cannot be introduced after the fact); (ii) it does not contradict the notice of termination’s core account of why the relationship had to end; and (iii) the employee had a real opportunity to meet that lesser case during the internal disciplinary process or, at least, in the ECT proceedings. If these conditions are met, the ECT may consider whether the lesser wrong, in context, amounted to “just cause or excuse”.19
  • Employer’s burden of proving “just cause or excuse” in a Section 14(2) Claim: Pursuant to Section 27(2) of the ECA, the employer bears the burden of proving “just cause or excuse” where: (i) an employee is summarily dismissed without notice (or payment in lieu of notice), or (ii) the employee was dismissed with notice (or payment in lieu of notice), and the notice of termination “is or purports to be given on the ground that there has been poor performance or misconduct”.20

    Accordingly, only where no reason was stated would the employee bear the burden of proof to establish that the dismissal with notice (or payment in lieu of notice) was “without just cause or excuse”.21 However, the Tribunal Magistrate took the view that an employee should not be required to infer motive from shadows. Instead, a Section 14(2) Claim may be made out by the employee proving, on the record as a whole, that no legitimate cause likely existed – in other words, the employee would not have been dismissed by an ordinary and reasonable employer. If the company chose to remain silent, it does so at its own risk, as the employee may be able to point to appraisals, commendations, tenure and clean HR records to demonstrate the likely lack of a legitimate cause in dismissing him.22
  • De novo review by the ECT of the merits: In a Section 14(2) Claim, the ECT does not merely assess whether the company’s decision is defensible. Instead, the ECT would decide afresh on the evidence, whether the dismissal was “without just cause or excuse”.23 This means that the ECT may well come to a different substantive conclusion than what the company had decided, including as to whether the employee had breached internal policies, and what should be the appropriate disciplinary action for such breach.
  • Remedies under a Section 14(2) Claim: Subject to the overall statutory caps on liability at SGD 20,000 or SGD 30,000 (as the case may be),24 a successful employee is entitled to compensation for (i) loss of income, and (ii) non-pecuniary harm. The ECT may award a sum for loss of income (up to three months’ salary) attributable to the fact and manner of dismissal without just cause or excuse, including the period of unemployment after dismissal, if the employee’s ability to secure comparable work had been impaired by the wrongful dismissal.25 Significantly, unlike the position under common law, loss of income is not confined to notice pay.26 The ECT may also award a sum for non-pecuniary harm inherent in being dismissed without just cause or excuse (i.e., affront to dignity, reputational harm, and disruption to one’s working life), equivalent to two months’ salary, which may be increased or decreased to account for aggravating or mitigating factors.27 Alternatively, a successful employee may seek reinstatement to his former role or position, although such remedy is rarely ordered in light of the relationship that has likely broken down.28

Key takeaways

The Tribunal Magistrate’s interpretation of Sections 14(1) and 14(2) of the EA effectively curtails the employer’s long-standing contractual right at common law to terminate an employee without citing reasons whatsoever, as long as sufficient notice or pay in lieu of notice is given. Subject to the outcome of any appeal against the Tribunal Magistrate’s decision, it would therefore appear that although the employee is still entitled to resign at any time without having to explain his reasons for leaving the company (by serving notice or making payment in lieu of notice), the company does not have an equivalent right to do so. This is despite the Tripartite Guidelines stating that: “As both employee and employer have a right to contractually terminate employment with notice, dismissals with notice are presumed not to be wrongful.” Disgruntled, litigious employees, who have already received full notice or notice pay, may still seek to bring a Section 14(2) Claim against the company for dismissal without just cause or excuse, thus inviting the ECT to decide – afresh on the evidence – whether there were reasonable and proportionate grounds to dismiss them.

The Tribunal Magistrate’s decision also affects whether reasons should be given for dismissal. If reasons are specified, the burden of proof is on the employer to prove both the truth and the sufficiency of those stated allegations to justify dismissal (as opposed to some lesser sanction).

However, it is also risky for the employer not to provide any reasons. Previously, it was understood that, under the Tripartite Guidelines (see illustrations 329 and 530) and Section 27(2)(b) of the ECA, the employee bears the burden of proving that the dismissal was wrongful if no reasons were given for termination with notice or payment in lieu of notice. Without proof that the dismissal was for wrongful reasons, the employee’s claim would fail. However, the Tribunal Magistrate’s decision suggests that the (evidential) burden could be reversed and the employer would have to demonstrate there was just cause or excuse, if the circumstances as a whole suggest that there was no good reason for the dismissal. This may essentially require the company to disclose its reasons even when its contractual right to terminate can be exercised without citing any reason. Not specifying any reason in the termination notice may thus create risks for the company, if the employee later seeks to rely on his previously clean employment record and satisfactory work performance to argue that he would not have been dismissed by an ordinary and reasonable employer. Based on the Tribunal Magistrate’s decision, such an argument by the employee may well succeed in a Section 14(2) Claim.

If successful, employees could potentially receive up to six months’ salary as additional compensation over and above their notice pay, which is a significant quantum. While there is an overall cap for each claim at SGD 20,000 (or SGD 30,000, as the case may be), the operational and management time and cost that companies would have to incur to defend against such claims are likely to far exceed any monetary recovery.

In handling employee misconduct matters, companies should therefore:

  • have a robust set of disciplinary policies and procedures, as well as clear yardsticks for any internal assessment of the appropriate disciplinary action to be taken;
  • take legal advice and conduct investigations under legal privilege to mitigate risks of disclosure in potential proceedings;
  • carefully consider both the procedural and substantive aspects of any internal investigation and/or disciplinary inquiry, to ensure that (among other things): (i) requirements in employment contracts, and any disciplinary policy or procedure, are complied with; (ii) “due inquiry” is satisfied in each case resulting in termination, regardless of whether such termination is with or without notice (or payment in lieu of notice); (iii) where more than one employee is to be investigated or disciplined, there is parity in treatment, with all distinguishing factors and rationale leading to any difference in outcomes fully documented; and (iv) all steps taken in the conduct of the investigation and taking of disciplinary action are fully documented with robust justifications;
  • consider whether alternatives to termination (e.g., a lesser disciplinary penalty, or mutual separation) may be more appropriate in the circumstances; and
  • carefully draft notices of termination, and consider whether reasons should be given. Where reasons are given, companies should be prepared to defend them both as to truth and sufficiency so as to constitute just cause or excuse, and bear in mind that alternative grounds not put to the employee and/or omitted in the notices may subsequently be unavailable.

If you have questions regarding internal investigations, disciplinary inquiries, employee dismissal, or any other employment matter, please feel free to contact us.

Footnotes

  1. 1

    We note that there may be an ongoing appeal in relation to the Tribunal Magistrate’s decision in JGP v JGQ [2026] SGECT 1 (JGP), as the decision indicates that applications seeking leave to appeal have been filed. As of this update, there is no reported appeal judgment in respect of the decision.

  2. 2

    JGP at [A.56].

  3. 3

    JGP at [A.49].

  4. 4

    JGP at [A.52]-[A.54].

  5. 5

    JGP at [3], [64], [A.72], [A.75], [A.138].

  6. 6

    JGP at [65], [A.106], [A.119], [A.133].

  7. 7

    JGP at [65], [71], [A.105].

  8. 8

    JGP at [69], [79(f)], [82], [A.131].

  9. 9

    JGP at [83].

  10. 10

    JGP at [84].

  11. 11

    JGP at [85]-[86].

  12. 12

    JGP at [A.131].

  13. 13

    JGP at [79(e)], [66], [68] - [70] (“whenever an employer relies on misconduct as the real basis for ending the employment, the due inquiry precondition is engaged; if the inquiry establishes misconduct, the EA permits dismissal without notice, but the employer may still choose to give notice. The choice to give notice does not dissolve the inquiry requirement that was triggered by the ground the employer chose to invoke.”).

  14. 14

    JGP at [79(h)], [A.133], [A.135], [A.138].

  15. 15

    JGP at [73], [79(j)], [A.123].

  16. 16

    JGP at [73], [91].

  17. 17

    JGP at [73], [91].

  18. 18

    JGP at [76]-[78], [79(l)], [A.126].

  19. 19

    JGP at [75], [79(k)], [A.125].

  20. 20

    JGP at [79(i)].

  21. 21

    See [9] of the Tripartite Guidelines: “To succeed in claiming that a dismissal with notice is wrongful (where no reason is given for the dismissal), an employee must substantiate a wrongful reason for the dismissal. ….”

  22. 22

    JGP at [A.91]-[A.94], [A.127].

  23. 23

    JGP at [79(c)], [91], [A.120].

  24. 24

    The claim limit may be increased from SGD 20,000 to SGD 30,000, if the employee has gone through the Tripartite Mediation Framework or mediations assisted by unions recognised under the Industrial Relations Act 1960.

  25. 25

    JGP at [104], [106], [A.156], [A.158].

  26. 26

    JGP at [A.161], [A.153]-[A.154].

  27. 27

    JGP at [107], [A-154], [A.157]-[A.159]. Aggravating factors include wrongful dismissal in a humiliating or degrading manner or a manner that caused physical harm, or any deliberate act that adversely affected the employee’s prospect of subsequent employment. Mitigating factors include (i) any misconduct or poor performance of the employee; or (ii) insubordination by the employee, which, while not providing just cause or excuse for the dismissal, was taken into account by the company in dismissing the employee. See the Second Schedule of the Singapore Employment Claims Regulations 2017.

  28. 28

    JGP at [79(m)], [A.139]-[A.140], [A.152].

  29. 29

    Illustration 3 of the Tripartite Guidelines: “C was dismissed with notice. His employer did not give any reason for the dismissal. When C asked for a reason, the employer continued to not give a reason, and explained that it was termination in accordance with the contract. C is unable to point to any facts, incidents or situations which could suggest that the employer’s intention was anything other than termination in accordance with the contract. This dismissal with notice was not wrongful.”

  30. 30

    Illustration 5 of the Tripartite Guidelines: “An employer dismissed E with notice. No reason was given for the dismissal. But E reported that the employer had made numerous discriminatory remarks about the employee’s race, stating that he preferred to hire someone of another race. This was confirmed by other employees. Even though the employer dismissed E with notice, the employer’s conduct showed that he adopted a discriminatory attitude towards E. Taken together, the facts support the conclusion that the employer dismissed E because of discrimination. Hence, the dismissal was wrongful.”

Contact