Moving to the Netherlands can have unexpected tax consequences for internationally mobile families with trust structures. Under the Dutch segregated private wealth regime (afgezonderd particulier vermogen: APV), set out in Article 2.14a of the Dutch Personal Income Tax Act 2001 (PITA), a person that becomes a Dutch-resident individual can be held liable for Dutch income tax on assets held by a family trust – even if that individual was not the settlor, has never controlled, and may never receive, any distributions from that trust.
This article provides an update on important developments in how the Netherlands taxes assets held in (Non-Dutch) trusts under the Dutch APV regime. Below, we summarise the current regime, examine recent case law – including the 2024 District Court of The Hague ruling and the 2025 Dutch Supreme Court ruling – that has reshaped its application, and set out practical steps for affected families.
The APV regime: Ending "floating wealth"
The Dutch APV regime casts a wide net: It can attribute the assets, liabilities, income and expenses of a non-Dutch trust to a Dutch-resident individual for income tax purposes – regardless of whether that individual was the settlor, exercises any control over the trust or holds any entitlement to its assets. With recent landmark case law further shaping its contours, understanding the APV regime has never been more important for families considering a move to the Netherlands.
The Dutch APV regime was introduced on January 1, 2010 with the clear objective to end what it calls "floating wealth" (zwevend vermogen) – assets parked in trusts and trust-like structures that would otherwise fall entirely outside the reach of Dutch income tax.
The mechanism is straightforward in concept, if not always in application. The regime looks through the trust wrapper and attributes its assets, liabilities, income and expenses to specific individuals. A non-Dutch trust will typically qualify as an APV if assets have been splitted into it and it is not treated as fiscally transparent. Once that threshold is met, the central question arises: to whom are the trust assets attributed for Dutch tax purposes?
Attribution: A strict statutory hierarchy
The answer lies in a rigid statutory hierarchy. The APV regime does not simply look at who benefits (or could at some point benefit) from the trust. Instead, it follows a fixed order of priority:
- The settlor (inbrenger): The primary rule attributes the APV assets to the person who settled the assets, whether during their lifetime or upon death.
- The settlor's heirs: Upon the settlor's death, attribution passes to the settlor's heirs in proportion to their inheritance entitlement under the applicable rules of succession or their will.
- Subsequent heirs: When an heir dies, that heir's own heirs take their place. This creates a continuing, generational attribution mechanism that follows the chain of succession.
- The "fictitious heir" rule: A disinherited person who is also a beneficiary of the APV (directly or indirectly) may be treated as an heir for attribution purposes.
- Residual attribution to beneficiaries: Only where the settlor, the settlor's partner and the settlor's heirs cannot be identified may the APV be attributed directly (and on a pro rata basis) to a beneficiary.
The key principle is that attribution follows the chain of heirship and does not skip a living generation. As long as a child of the settlor is alive, their children (including the settlor's grandchildren) do not enter the picture for attribution purposes. This principle, while straightforward in a domestic context, generates considerable complexity when applied to non-Dutch trusts – as recent case law demonstrates.
Where things get complicated: The 2024 District Court ruling
The above legislative hierarchy may look orderly on paper, but the real world – especially one involving trusts and succession laws in multiple jurisdictions – is rarely that straightforward. A key illustration of this is the District Court of The Hague ruling of March 12, 2024, which created uncertainties for anyone linked to a non-Dutch trust.1
In that case, the taxpayer was a Dutch-resident child of a deceased English settlor whose will and testament established a discretionary trust for the benefit of his "wife, children and grandchildren." The Dutch tax authorities attributed a portion of the trust assets to the taxpayer on the basis that she was one of three heirs for purposes of Article 2.14a PITA, however, this position was challenged by the taxpayer. The key difficulty, however, was that English law does not use the concept of "heir" (erfgenaam) in the same manner as Dutch civil law. The court acknowledged that it could not determine from the English will and testament if anyone actually qualified as an “heir” under the APV regime. It ultimately adopted the taxpayer's fall-back position, treating all persons named as beneficiaries in the trust deed (including the grandchildren) as heirs. This resulted in the trust’s assets being divided for these purposes among six individuals (rather than three), significantly reducing the taxpayer's attributed share.
Practical implications
The 2024 ruling raises several concerns for practice:
- The heir “translation” problem. The APV regime revolves around the concept of heirs (erfgenamen): a Dutch civil-law notion that may have no direct equivalent in common-law jurisdictions. English law, for example, does not recognise heirs in the Dutch sense. As the 2024 ruling demonstrates, this may create legal uncertainty: If the court itself cannot determine who the heirs are, how can taxpayers reliably predict the outcome?
- In practice, the risk is that the Dutch tax authorities adopt a narrow interpretation of who qualifies as an heir (resulting in a larger per-person attribution), while the taxpayer argues for a broader class. Until higher courts provide further guidance, this remains an open and potentially costly question.
- Inter vivos vs. testamentary trusts. The 2024 ruling concerned a testamentary trust (created by the settlor's will upon death). The distinction between testamentary trusts and inter vivos trusts (settled during the settlor's lifetime) can be relevant, because an inter vivos trust constitutes a separate legal act independent of the settlor's testamentary dispositions. This may affect how the succession-based attribution rules apply and, in particular, whether the ambiguities seen in the 2024 ruling are equally present.
- Rebutting attribution: a high threshold. The law does offer an escape route: an heir can rebut the statutory attribution by demonstrating a "hermetic separation" from the APV. However, the burden of proof is stringent. The heir must show that neither they, nor their partner or their heirs, is or can ever become a beneficiary of the trust – whether legally or in fact, directly or indirectly. In our experience, and based on the case law to date, meeting this standard is exceptionally difficult for most family trusts with broad beneficiary classes.
- Beneficiary does not equal fictitious heir. A common misconception is that any beneficiary who is also a descendant of the settlor automatically becomes a "fictitious heir" for APV purposes. This is not correct. The fictitious heir rule applies only to individuals who would have inherited under the applicable intestacy rules (i.e., the rules governing inheritance where no valid will exists) but were deliberately excluded by the settlor's will. Being named as a trust beneficiary, without more, does not trigger this provision.
The 2025 Dutch Supreme Court’s ruling: Additional ground for attribution
In its ruling of September 26, 2025, the Dutch Supreme Court (Hoge Raad) confirmed an important additional ground for attribution: the concrete, legally enforceable right (concreet juridisch afdwingbaar recht).2 If a beneficiary holds a fixed or vested right against trust assets, attribution may follow even if that beneficiary is not an heir. This effectively creates a parallel route alongside the statutory hierarchy and means that, while the question of who qualifies as an heir remains important, it is not the only basis on which attribution may arise.
The Supreme Court further indicated that the existence and scope of a beneficiary’s rights must be assessed on the basis of the specific terms of the trust and the rights that arise from them. A purely discretionary interest, where the trustees retain genuine and substantive discretion as to whether and to what extent distributions are made, would generally not, in itself, result in attribution under the Supreme Court’s test.
However, the analysis is fact-specific and depends on the substance of the beneficiary’s position rather than the terminology used in the trust deed. If, for example, the trustees’ discretion is materially constrained or the beneficiary has a vested or otherwise legally enforceable right to income or capital, the outcome may be different. A careful review of the trust deed and the nature of the beneficiary’s rights is therefore essential.
Practical recommendations
For families and individuals connected to non-Dutch trust structures, the following steps are advisable:
- Seek early advice. If you are relocating to the Netherlands – or are already resident – and have any relationship with a non-Dutch trust, do not wait for the tax authorities to raise questions. An early assessment of the APV implications can avoid costly surprises and provide time to consider structuring options.
- Review trust documentation carefully. The outcome of an APV analysis often turns on the precise terms of the trust: Who is the settlor? What law governs the estate? What is the nature of the beneficiary's interest: discretionary or fixed? As the 2024 ruling shows, the way in which beneficiaries and heirs are described in the trust documentation can be decisive. Having comprehensive and up-to-date documentation ready is essential.
- Monitor developments in case law. The law in this area is developing rapidly. The 2024 District Court of The Hague ruling and the 2025 Dutch Supreme Court decision have materially reshaped the landscape, and further cases are already expected. Positions taken in prior years may require reassessment in light of new judicial guidance.
- Coordinate across jurisdictions. The APV regime applies Dutch legal concepts to non-Dutch legal relationships, which inevitably requires coordination between Dutch tax advisors and trust or estate lawyers in the relevant non-Dutch jurisdiction. A purely Dutch or purely non-Dutch analysis will rarely be sufficient.
The bottom line
The Dutch APV regime is one of the more far-reaching attribution tools in international tax law. It can – and does – result in Dutch-resident individuals being taxed on trust assets they do not control and may never receive. The 2024 District Court ruling has added a layer of uncertainty by exposing how difficult it can be to apply the regime's Dutch legal concepts to non-Dutch trusts, while the 2025 Supreme Court ruling has clarified – but also expanded – the grounds for attribution.
With proper planning and timely advice, the regime's consequences can be understood, managed, and in many cases mitigated. The key is to address these questions proactively, rather than reactively when a tax assessment arrives.
If you would like to discuss how the APV regime may affect your position, or if you require advice on structuring options, please do not hesitate to contact our Amsterdam Tax team. We would be pleased to discuss your circumstances and discuss how we can assist you.