The Court of Appeal (the CoA) in Skyros Maritime Corp & another v Hapag-Lloyd AG [2025] EWCA Civ 1529 has confirmed that, where a charterer redelivers a vessel late, the owners are entitled to the normal measure of damages for the overrun, namely the difference between the charter rate and the relevant market rate for that period. This applies regardless of the owner’s plans for the vessel on expiry of the charterparty, including if they could or would have sold or re‑fixed the vessel. The CoA held that those arrangements are res inter alios acta (i.e., collateral matters) and are to be disregarded when assessing damages.

Background

The dispute arose from two NYPE time charters for the container vessels “MV Skyros” and “MV Agios Minas” (the Vessels). The Vessels were returned late (MV Skyros by two days and MV Agios Minas by seven days), with hire paid at the charter rates during the overrun period, despite a sharp rise in charter market rates. Before redelivery, the owners had also entered into memoranda of agreement (MOAs) for the sale of the Vessels after redelivery, in which they had agreed not to enter into further charter fixtures. Therefore, even if redelivered on time, the Vessels would not have been chartered out, whether at the market rate or not.

The owners commenced arbitration proceedings seeking damages for the period of overrun. They sought to rely on the standard market measure of damages (the difference between market rates and the charter rate). Alternatively, they claimed quantum meruit (a reasonable sum in respect of the services actually supplied), user damages (where one party wrongfully uses another party’s property), and negotiating damages (calculated by the amount the claimant could hypothetically negotiate from the defendant in return for releasing them from their obligations). The charterer argued that, due to the MOAs, the owners suffered no economic loss and were only entitled to nominal damages.

The arbitrators found for the owners, awarding substantial damages on the primary basis of quantum meruit. The charterers appealed. The High Court disagreed with the arbitrators, finding that the owners had not lost the opportunity to take advantage of the higher market rates during the period of late redelivery, due to the MOAs, and so they were limited to nominal damages.

Permission to appeal was granted on two issues only: (1) whether the owners were entitled in principle to recover user damages; and (2) whether the owners’ contracts for the sale of the Vessels must be disregarded in assessing any damages. Accordingly, the issues concerning quantum meruit and negotiating damages were not addressed by the CoA.

You can read our analysis of the High Court judgment, including the High Court’s analysis of quantum meruit and negotiating damages, here.

The Court of Appeal’s decision

The Court found in favour of the owners and restored the arbitrators’ award. It held that the owners succeeded on the normal measure for late redelivery and that it was unnecessary (and inappropriate) to resort to quantum meruit, user damages, or negotiating damages.

Three aspects of the judgment are particularly significant:

First, the CoA reaffirmed the normal measure for late redelivery with reference to “a formidable line of authority”. Where the market rate at the redelivery date exceeds the charter rate, damages for the overrun are assessed by reference to the difference between those rates for the period of the overrun. The CoA emphasised that this principle is long-settled and has been expressly recognised by the House of Lords in The Achilleas [2008] UKHL 48, [2009] 1 AC 61. Importantly, it stressed that there has never been any suggestion that entitlement to recover damages in line with the normal measure depends on whether the owner actually would or could have entered the market to fix a follow-on charter at the contractual redelivery date. The CoA suggested that this approach “promotes certainty in commercial dealings”, adding that, were it otherwise, the extent of a charterer’s liability for late redelivery would be unknown unless they investigated the owner’s planned future use of the vessel (e.g., sale, drydocking plans, repositioning voyages, or forward fixtures). To that end, the CoA confirmed that the fact the owners had entered into the MOAs did not preclude them from seeking the normal measure of damages.

Second, the CoA carefully distinguished remoteness from the res inter alios acta principle. It noted that an assessment of damages involves first determining what the injured party has lost, and then determining how much can be recovered. The CoA confirmed that remoteness relates to the second question, i.e., whether the loss was in reasonable contemplation at the time of contracting. By contrast, res inter alios acta operates at the first stage of defining the loss and excludes from consideration certain collateral circumstances bearing on the injured party’s actual financial position because they arise independently of the breach. Applying that principle, the owners’ MOAs, including their commitments not to re-fix, were collateral and to be ignored in assessing damages.

Third, while “user damages” were addressed only in the alternative, the CoA declined to recharacterise late redelivery as wrongful use of property and accordingly award “user damages". While the CoA recognised that late redelivery is “to some extent” wrongful use of property, it acknowledged that it is a use to which the owners have agreed, irrespective of whether the last voyage is legitimate. On the CoA’s analysis, the claim succeeds on conventional compensatory principles without the need to resort to user damages. It was reluctant to introduce user damages as a novel route to recovery in this context, particularly when in fact no loss has been suffered.

Separately, the CoA declined to comment on whether the last voyages of the Vessels were legitimate or illegitimate. It noted that, if a charterer fails to redeliver, without fault of the owner or some other “exonerating clause”, then it commits a breach of contract in any event, and that the normal measure of damages would apply irrespective of whether the last voyage was legitimate or illegitimate.

Key takeaways

Although it remains to be seen whether there will be a further appeal, in the meantime, it is clear that:

  1. Owners’ entitlement to the normal measure endures. Where a vessel is redelivered late in a rising market, owners are entitled to damages equal to the difference between the charter rate and the relevant market rate for the overrun period. This does not depend on whether the owner could or would have re fixed at the terminal date, nor does it depend on whether the last voyage was legitimate or illegitimate.
  2. Collateral arrangements are disregarded. Owners’ MOAs, sale commitments, intended drydocking, repositioning, or other forward plans are to be ignored when assessing damages. Charterers cannot seek to reduce their liability by pointing to collateral arrangements. As such, there is no point in investigating, and no need to investigate, an owner’s forward plans for the vessel.
  3. Remoteness still limits exceptional claims. As in The Achilleas, losses tied to distinct follow on bargains (e.g., lost forward fixtures or lost sales if buyers gain a cancellation right for failure to deliver on time) are not generally recoverable for late redelivery.

Further reading: Skyros Maritime Corporation & another -v- Hapag-Lloyd AG [2025] EWCA Civ 1529. The full judgment can be found here.

With thanks to James Kennedy for his assistance in preparing this post.

Contact