Will a million people read this article? We don’t know. But if you have a view, you could logon to a prediction market website and purchase a contract that pays out if we hit a million readers.

Prediction markets have been hitting the headlines and are seeing increased interest globally, with some analysts estimating that the “trading” volumes could reach USD 1 trillion by 2030. Although trading volumes are soaring, the nature of prediction markets have raised a number of regulatory questions.

In this article, we highlight key UAE legal issues that clients should be aware of.

What is a prediction market?

Before we address legal issues, it is important to understand what a prediction market is.

Simply put, a prediction market is a financial market where you can obtain exposure to the outcome of real world events, such as election outcomes, financial or economic events, award shows, weather events and sports event outcomes. By providing a market through which participants are able to freely buy and sell exposure to the outcome of certain events, participants collectively create a forecast of the likelihood of those events occurring.

Prediction markets do this by facilitating the trading of event contracts (Event Contracts). These are binary contracts typically structured as ‘YES’ or ‘NO’ shares tied to the occurrence of a defined future event. A ‘YES’ share pays $1 if the specified event occurs and $0 if it does not. A ‘NO’ share operates inversely. These shares trade at prices between $0 and $1, with the market price in liquid markets reflecting the aggregated view of participants as to the probability of the event occurring.

Popular prediction markets allow participants to buy Event Contracts on anything from the outcome of an election, a sports match and even whether the temperature will hit a particular number in your city today.

The key legal issues are as follows:

  1. How are Event Contracts classified under UAE law?
  2. How are Event Contracts regulated in the UAE?
  3. Is there a market abuse risk?
  4. How are outcomes decided?

We address each of these in turn below.

How are Event Contracts classified under UAE law?

The key question here is whether Event Contracts should be treated as a form of gambling or as financial products. In the UAE, the line between gambling and financial product is critically important because gambling is strictly prohibited under Islamic Sharia law due to the element of excessive uncertainty or “gharar” that causes one party to benefit from the other’s loss. Gambling is also a punishable criminal offence under the current version of the UAE’s Penal Code which defines gambling as “a game whereby each of the parties thereto agrees - in case of losing - to pay to the winner a certain sum of money or any other thing agreed upon.” A similar offence is provided for under the UAE’s Cybercrimes Law. In contrast to the UK, the UAE’s gambling regime does not exempt from the criminal offence gambling contracts merely because their making or acceptance constitutes a regulated activity.

Further, the UAE Civil Code currently provides that any contract of gambling shall be void. The scope of this broad provision will be narrowed when the new Civil Code comes into effect on June 1, 2026 (see previous article here).

Noting the effect the Civil Code and Penal Code may have on complex financial products, the UAE’s Netting Law provides that contracts which meet the definition of a “Qualified Financial Contract” are not “[…] deemed void or unenforceable for any reason relating to aleatory contracts (Gharar) provisions of any law, including in relation to games, matches, gambling, betting or lotteries”.

In light of the complex legal matrix that may apply to Event Contracts, it is therefore important to assess whether Event Contracts are a form of gambling, or a qualified financial contract which falls outside the scope of the UAE gambling prohibitions. The UAE’s matrix of gambling-related laws makes this assessment significantly more complicated than in other jurisdictions.

How are Event Contracts regulated?

Event Contracts sit in a grey area: on the one hand, they are likely a type of exchange traded option and therefore may require a financial services license. On the other hand, Event Contracts that allow participants to “bet” on the outcome of a sports match may be closer to gambling. Therefore, Event Contracts straddle the line between requiring a financial services license and a gambling license.

Currently, the UAE does not have a clear regulatory framework dedicated specifically to prediction markets and Event Contracts. Given the novelty of prediction markets globally, this is not surprising. It is quite likely that this position may change in future.

We note that in September 2023, the UAE announced the formation of the General Commercial Gaming Regulatory Authority (GCGRA). The GCGRA oversees commercial gaming, which includes lottery operations, internet gaming, sports wagering and land based gaming facilities.

At present, it remains uncertain whether Event Contracts fall within the scope of internet gaming or sports wagering and should therefore be regulated by the GCGRA, or whether they should instead be characterised as financial products subject to oversight by financial services regulators. The question also remains as to whether Event Contracts may require dual licensing by both the GCGRA and a financial services regulator.

Further, even if such products may be characterised as financial products, it remains to be seen whether the UAE’s various financial services regulators adopt a consistent, unified approach, or whether differing approaches will emerge.

Is there a market abuse risk?

Recently, prediction markets have been in the media spotlight for all the wrong reasons. There have been many instances of anonymous individuals placing outsized bets moments before the announcement of a key political event. This raises concerns in relation to insider trading and marketing integrity risks.

Indeed, the structure of event contracts creates obvious potential for participants with access to material non-public information to profit at the expense of other traders. This risk is particularly acute for crypto-connected prediction markets which allow participants to connect unhosted wallets and therefore remain somewhat anonymous when purchasing Event Contracts.

It remains to be seen what measures prediction markets will implement in order to mitigate the potential for market abuse and therefore maintain fair and equitable markets. If these risks are not addressed, participants’ trust in prediction markets will fall.

How are outcomes decided?

Given Event Contracts pay out on the occurrence of an outcome, deciding whether an outcome has occurred is very important. For clients operating prediction markets, this is an issue which may present litigation risk as well as potentially engage consumer protection law.

For “simple” Event Contracts tied to the outcome of a sports match, this risk is negligible. However, for more complex Event Contracts where outcomes have a risk of ambiguity, the risks are greater. For example, there may be an Event Contract that Country A will carry out a successful cyber attack on Country B. The ambiguity may arise if Country A claims they carried out the attack whilst Country B denies the attack was successful.

This presents a litigation risk for the operator of the prediction market if event outcomes cannot be properly adjudicated. Therefore, it is important to ensure that Event Contracts are clearly worded and that the sources used to determine that an event has occurred are clearly disclosed to clients.

Conclusion

The rising interest in prediction markets shows no signs of slowing down. These markets sit at the intersection of financial regulation, derivatives, digital assets, and gaming regulation, while also raising important questions around gambling prohibitions and the Islamic Sharia law concept of gharar.

In the UAE, we are seeing increased interest and have advised a number of clients on the regulation of prediction markets and Event Contracts. However, it remains to be seen how the UAE regulators will regulate event contracts. In the meantime, navigating complex and sometimes conflicting regulatory frameworks effectively remains essential for entities operating within the prediction market sector.

For insights on developments in prediction markets in the US see:

https://www.nortonrosefulbright.com/en-us/knowledge/publications/ad8a494a/prediction-markets-at-a-crossroads-preemption-enforcement-and-rulemaking

For a broader perspective, the following episode might be helpful to listen to Episode 19 of our “Split the Difference” podcast, which explores prediction markets and event contracts and offers a thoughtful comparison of the UK and US regulatory approaches.

This article has been written by Middle East Partner and Head of Financial Services Regulatory Matthew Shanahan, Senior Associate Hasanali Pirbhai and Associate Jack Abrehart.
Should you have any queries or questions, please get in touch with one of the key contacts listed below.

Contact