The geopolitical conflict in the Middle East continues to drive volatility of global financial markets across asset classes, including equities, structured products, commodities, energy linked instruments and foreign exchange. For financial institutions, volatility of this kind has historically resulted in a corresponding rise in mis‑selling allegations following market downturns. These disputes often emerge well after the point of sale and are increasingly framed not only in contract and tort, but also as regulatory breaches capable of establishing civil liability.
This article examines the types of issues, both regulatory and contractual, that often form part of mis‑selling claims under DIFC law, and offers practical guidance for financial institutions defending such claims.
Litigation risk
Mis-selling claims brought before the DIFC courts can be based on allegations of misleading statements, unsuitable recommendations or failure to comply with duties of care. The conduct giving rise to a mis-selling claim will often be founded on alleged contraventions of regulatory rules which govern financial institutions. Mis-selling claims are rarely confined to a single cause of action, and claimants typically advance overlapping arguments grounded in:
- claims in contract or in tort in respect of advice given or representations made; and
- claims for regulatory breaches, for example of the Dubai Financial Services Authority (“DFSA”) Regulatory Law.
Tort/contract: claimants may commence litigation proceedings in respect of alleged negligent misstatements or advisory negligence. These can be actions in tort and/or in contract depending on the terms of the client agreement.
Regulatory breaches: Article 94 of the DFSA Regulatory Law 2004 is typically relied upon to convert alleged breaches of DFSA Conduct of Business Rules such as suitability, disclosure or communications obligations into a civil damages claim. Article 94 does not impose strict liability or override contractual risk allocation, and the courts have made clear in the landmark decision of Rafed Abdel Mohsen Bader Al Khorafi & Ors v Bank Sarasin‑Alpen (ME) Ltd & Bank Sarasin & Co Ltd 2 [2009] CFI 026 that a claimant must still satisfy the legal tests of causation, loss and remoteness.
The DIFC courts possess wide powers to grant recovery for the loss and can make orders for the recovery of damages, compensation or the recovery of property.
Underlying regulatory principles
The regulatory considerations in respect of mis-selling claims can generally be split into three different baskets:
- general principles applicable to DFSA-regulated financial institutions (“Firms”);
- conduct of business obligations; and
- product specific considerations.
The most pertinent risks related to mis-selling claims are generally (i) the requirement to communicate to clients in a manner that is clear, fair and not misleading, (ii) the requirement to observe high standards of integrity and fair dealing, and (iii) the requirement to act with due skill, care and diligence.
- General principles
Integrity: generally, Firms must conduct business with integrity at all times. In a mis-selling context, a claimant may allege that the relevant Firm’s sales conduct fell short of this overarching standard.
Fair dealing: Firms must pay due regard to their customers' interests and treat them fairly. This obligation is particularly relevant where there is an imbalance of sophistication or bargaining power between the Firm and the client, particularly for dealings with retail clients.
Proper standards of market conduct: Firms must observe proper standards of market conduct. This general principle may encompass allegations of high-pressure sales tactics, failure to act in the client's best interests, or departure from accepted market practice.
- Conduct of business obligations
Suitability and appropriateness: where a personal recommendation is made, a financial institution must ensure the product is suitable having regard to the client's knowledge, experience, financial situation, and objectives. If the financial institution acted in an advisory capacity in relation to the mis-sold product, suitability can be relevant.
Fair, clear, and not misleading communications: financial institutions must ensure that all client communications, including marketing materials, product literature, and oral representations, are fair, clear, and not misleading. This is a key battleground in mis-selling disputes, particularly where materials are alleged to have downplayed risk or overstated potential returns.
Client categorisation: the level of regulatory protection afforded to a client depends on how the client has been categorised (retail, professional, or market counterparty). Mis-categorisation of a client, or a failure to apply the correct standard of protection, can be relevant to a mis-selling claim. For example, most of the protections for complex products will only apply to retail clients; they won’t be relevant for professional clients or market counterparties.
- Product specific considerations
We consider below some common product-specific considerations which are particularly relevant to claims during volatile markets.
Leveraged products: where the product involves leverage, including CFDs or margin-traded derivatives, financial institutions may be subject to obligations including standardised risk warnings, negative balance protection, and margin close-out rules. Claimants may allege that the financial institution misrepresented these protections or failed to apply them.
Complex or structured products: for complex or structured instruments, enhanced obligations may arise in relation to the explanation of product mechanics. Failure by a financial institution to ensure the client genuinely understood the product is a common complaint.
Defending mis-selling allegations
- Considerations for litigation proceedings
It should be noted that the courts often decide these cases on the evidence of the underlying documentation and communication between the parties. This can include off-channel communication such as WhatsApp conversations between the relationship manager and client on the execution of trades or investment advice. Advice on unrecorded lines is a contravention of regulatory rules, and the admissibility of such evidence can become an additional issue in the dispute. Ensuring business communication is made through official channels will reduce the risk of satellite litigation, which often prolongs the dispute and leads to further increased costs. Below, we explore the principal legal defences to mis-selling claims.
Contractual provisions: contracts governing the service or transaction provided by a financial institution should include robust provisions to limit the financial institution’s liability for external factors affecting the performance of products such as market risk. Common provisions include (i) acknowledgements that the client is commercially sophisticated and/or understands the risks of the transaction, (ii) confirmations (where relevant) that the financial institution has not provided any advice to the client regarding the financial product, and (iii) “non-reliance” clauses asserting that financial institution has not made and/or the client has not relied on any representations about the product other than in the contract.
In the courts of England and Wales, financial institutions have successfully used contractual estoppel to defend mis-selling claims and enforce the original terms of the contract. This defence operates on the basis that the parties contractually agreed to a certain state of affairs and prevents either party from later asserting a contrary factual position to invalidate the contract. To our knowledge, contractual estoppel remains untested by the DIFC courts, but financial institutions may consider running similar defences by relying on contractual provisions to demonstrate an agreed position that:
- the client is a sophisticated investor who understood the risks of the transaction;
- the financial institution has not made, and the client has not relied on, any representations about the financial product other than in the contract (non-reliance clauses); and
- where relevant, the financial institution has not provided any advice to the client regarding the product.
Limitation periods: if legal proceedings are commenced, financial institutions should assess whether the claim is brought within the limitation period. A claim brought after the expiry of the limitation period functions as a complete defence and the DIFC courts will dismiss the claim. Article 28 of the DIFC Court Law generally mandates that proceedings are filed within six years from the date of the breach.
Jurisdiction: financial institutions should assess whether the claim has been brought in the proper forum. This procedural “defence” is relevant where there is a foreign element to the factual situation. For example, the client agreement governing the relationship between the parties could provide for determination of a dispute in one jurisdiction, where the underlying services agreement may stipulate for the products to be booked in another jurisdiction, with a different dispute resolution clause.
- Regulatory consequences
From a regulatory perspective, misconduct arising from mis‑selling allegations can expose financial institutions to enforcement action by the DFSA. The DFSA may receive a complaint directly from an affected client, or the financial institution may itself decide to notify the DFSA of the mis-selling allegation. The key point for financial institutions operating in the DIFC to recognise is that unresolved client dissatisfaction can escalate beyond a private dispute and develop into a matter attracting regulatory scrutiny.
When an investigation is opened, the DFSA has extensive information‑gathering powers. These powers allow the regulator to require the production of documents, to compel individuals to attend interviews, and to obtain any additional information it considers necessary for the purpose of the investigation. The breadth of these powers means that an investigation can quickly become resource intensive and disruptive for the financial institution under review, even before any findings of misconduct have been made.
If misconduct is ultimately substantiated, the DFSA has a wide range of enforcement tools available, including the imposition of a financial penalty on the financial institution concerned. It may also pursue civil proceedings in the DIFC Courts to recover damages or obtain compensation on behalf of affected clients, although this is rare and is likely reserved for the most egregious cases. Importantly, enforcement action is not necessarily confined to the financial institution itself. Where individuals are knowingly concerned in the contravention, the DFSA may also take action against those individuals directly, including by withdrawing their Authorised Individual status, which would preclude them from performing any licensed function in the DIFC.
At the conclusion of enforcement proceedings, the DFSA will usually publish a Decision Notice that sets out the details of the contravention and the sanctions imposed. The publication of such notices can cause significant reputational damage to the financial institution and to any individuals who are named.
Mitigating the risk of litigation
Whilst losses caused by volatile market events do not alone translate into legal or regulatory liability, in our experience such losses create the environment for a steady rise in mis-selling allegations. It is during periods of market stress where relationships - and litigation and/or regulatory risk - are most acutely tested. Silence, overly reassuring commentary, or reactive messaging can all be used against financial institutions after the event.
Financial institutions would be well advised to proactively communicate with clients during volatile periods to restate known risks, explain market drivers and contextualise short‑term performance. Reminders should be given to employees about the need to communicate with clients only through appropriate channels. When addressing client complaints, care should be taken to avoid admissions or any reassurance that could be read as minimising risk or downplaying potential losses. Early, measured engagement can reduce the risk of complaint escalation, maintain client trust and preserve the commercial relationship. If a complaint does escalate, early consideration should be given to whether any of the financial institution’s regulatory notification requirements are engaged.
Norton Rose Fulbright is one of the leading banking disputes firms in the market and has significant experience with these types of claims. If you have any questions or concerns regarding the issues raised in this topic, please feel free to reach out to our team for assistance.
The authors would like to acknowledge the contributions to this article by Puruvi Ruparel.